4. Kay is studying the variables Daily Total Sunshine (\(x\)) and Daily Total Rainfall (\(y\)) from the large data set for Leeming in 2015
Kay starts with 5th May and then selects every 10th day thereafter.
(a) State the name of the sampling technique Kay uses. (1)
Kay wants to find the regression line of \(y\) on \(x\) for these data.
(b) Using your knowledge of the large data set, explain how Kay might need to clean these data before finding the equation of the regression line. (1)
The equation of the regression line Kay finds is \(y = 0.741 + 0.199x\)
(c) Using your knowledge of the large data set,
(i) state the units of the gradient of the regression line,
(ii) give an interpretation of the \(y\)-intercept of the regression line. (2)
Kay’s teacher claimed that the greater the amount of sunshine in a day the lower the amount of rain there should be.
(d) State, giving a reason, whether the teacher’s claim is true for Kay’s data. (1)
The teacher used all the data for these variables from the large data set for Leeming in 2015, as a sample. The teacher calculated the product moment correlation coefficient for \(x\) and \(y\) to be \(-0.160\)
In a suitable test to determine whether there is evidence to support the teacher’s claim, the \(p\)-value was 0.015
(e) Using a 5% level of significance, state the hypotheses and conclusion for this test. (2)
(f) For the test in part (e) describe
(i) the sample,
(ii) a possible population. (2)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Systematic (sampling)
B1
1.2
(1)
Notes
B1: for systematic (ignore other non-contradictory descriptions). Condone misspelling. If a clear choice is given e.g. stratified or systematic we take the final answer.
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
The (Daily Total) Rainfall data may contain “tr” entries (these will need a suitable value substituted before calculations can take place.)
B1
2.4
(1)
Notes
B1: for mention of “tr” or “trace” entries in rain(fall) [ or \(y\)] data. Ignore “n/a”. Ignore any comment about what to do with trace.
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) mm/h (o.e.) e.g. \(\mathrm{mm\,h^{-1}}\) or \(\mathrm{mm\,hrs^{-1}}\) or \(\dfrac{\text{mm}}{\text{hours}}\)
B1
1.1b
(ii) When there is no sun(shine) there is (on average) 0.7(41) (mm) of rain or the amount of rain when there is no sun(shine) (o.e.)
B1
2.4
(2)
Notes
(i) B1: for mm/h or equivalent in words.
(ii) B1: for the idea of amount of rain when no sun. “Minimum rain” is B0 Don’t need value or units but if given must be correct or consistent with (i)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
e.g. Not consistent (since); Kay’s line says positive correlation or gradient or regression coefficient or regression line or 0.199 is positive
B1
2.4
(1)
Notes
B1: for a suitable reason and saying not consistent (o.e.) e.g. “false” or “untrue” or “no” Reason only needs to be about the line and may be a description e.g. as \(x\) increases \(y\) increases or at least 2 values of \(x\) substituted and \(y\) values evaluated
[\(p\)-value < 5% so significant result] there is evidence to support the teacher’s claim
B1
2.2b
(2)
Notes
B1: for both hypotheses correct in terms of \(\rho\) (condone attempt at \(\rho\) that looks like \(p\))
B1: for a correct conclusion in context with no contradiction. Using words “support” and “teacher’s claim” or “negative correlation” and “sun or \(x\)” and “rain or \(y\)” [If a comparison is given it must be \(0.015 < 0.05\)]
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) The sample is rainfall (\(y\)) and sunshine (\(x\)) for May~Oct in (Leeming) in 2015
B1
1.1b
(ii) e.g. (rainfall and sunshine) for: (Leeming) for all of 2015, or Leeming anytime (not just May~Oct) or Leeming for May~October for other years too or May~Oct in UK etc
B1
3.3
(2)
(9 marks)
Notes
(i) B1: for recognising that all the data/days for these variables in LDS for 2015 is the sample. Condone omitting “Leeming” B0 for “sunshine and rainfall for Leeming in 2015” It could be the population.
(ii) B1: for a suitable attempt to describe a population. The teacher’s sample must be a subset.
2. Runners in an athletics club can train with either coach \(A\) or coach \(B\) for the 400 m race.
Coach \(A\) trains 120 runners for the 400 m and records the best time, \(x\) seconds, for each runner.
The results are summarised by the following statistics
\[\sum x = 6612 \qquad \sum x^2 = 364\,902\]
(a) Calculate the mean of the best times for the runners trained by coach \(A\) (1)
(b) Calculate the standard deviation of the best times for the runners trained by coach \(A\) (2)
The mean and standard deviation for the best times of the 100 runners trained for the 400 m by coach \(B\) are 55.1 seconds and 3.6 seconds respectively.
A 400 m race consists of equal numbers of the fastest runners trained by coach \(A\) and by coach \(B\)
(c) State, giving a reason, which coach is more likely to have trained the winner. (2)
B1: for 55.1 or \(55\frac{1}{10}\) only (may be seen in the question) ISW e.g. 55.1 followed by 55 etc Do not accept \(\frac{551}{10}\) that scores B0
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\left[\sigma_x =\right] \sqrt{\dfrac{364\,902}{120} - (\text{``}55.1\text{''})^2}\) or \(\sqrt{4.84}\)
M1
1.1b
\(= \mathbf{2.2}\) (seconds)
A1
1.1b
(2)
Notes
Ignore units in this question
M1: for a correct expression (values seen not just a formula)(including \(\sqrt{\phantom{x}}\))
A1: for 2.2 or \(\frac{11}{5}\) o.e. (allow \(s = 2.209\ldots\) so awrt 2.21) Correct answer is 2 marks
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Coach \(B\) because standard deviation is greater
M1
2.4
This means \(B\) has a greater range and therefore more extreme values
A1ft
2.2b
(2)
(5 marks)
Notes
Ignore units in this question
Ignore comments about different number of runners. Don’t need to state means are the same. If there is no answer given for (b) then no marks can be scored in (c)
“2.2” < 3.6
B1: for coach \(B\) and states s.d. of \(B\) is greater o.e. Must compare. Allow implied choose \(B\) e.g. \(B\) has a greater range or \(B\)s values are more spread out or \(3.6 > \text{``}2.2\text{''}\) or \(\sigma_B > \text{``}2.2\text{''}\) May say s.d. of \(A\) is smaller which is equivalent to saying s.d. of \(B\) is larger
dB1: (dep on 1st B1 scored) for clear reason why greater s.d. means choose coach \(B\) Idea of greater range and more extreme values (faster times) in \(B\) e.g. \(B\) has more (or greater chance of or greater % of) runners at lower times (may compare mean – 1 or 2 or 3 standard deviations to show that \(B\) has the quicker time) e.g. coach \(A\) (52.9) > (51.5) coach \(B\) so coach \(B\) likely to be quickest
NB: “coach \(B\) since \(B\) has greater range /s.d. and so more extreme values” scores B1B1
3. Ming is studying the large data set for Perth in 2015
He intended to use all the data available to find summary statistics for the Daily Mean Air Temperature, \(x\) °C. Unfortunately, Ming selected an incorrect variable on the spreadsheet. This incorrect variable gave a mean of 5.3 and a standard deviation of 12.4
(a) Using your knowledge of the large data set, suggest which variable Ming selected. (1)
The correct values for the Daily Mean Air Temperature are summarised as
(b) Calculate the mean and standard deviation for these data. (3)
One of the months from the large data set for Perth in 2015 has
mean \(\bar{x} = 19.4\)
standard deviation \(\sigma_x = 2.83\)
for Daily Mean Air Temperature.
(c) Suggest, giving a reason, a month these data may have come from. (2)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Rain[fall] (allow [Mean] Windspeed)
B1
1.2
(1)
Notes
Answers may appear next to the question.
B1 for Rain[fall] or precipitation (e.g. allow Daily Total [or Mean or max] Rainfall etc) (or allow Mean Windspeed or just “windspeed” BUT not max windspeed or “gust”) If they give more than one answer we take the last one. (NB Actual windspeed mean is 8.2, sd 2.38. No other quantitative variables available)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
[\(\bar{x} =\)] \(15.2239\ldots =\) awrt 15.2
B1
1.1b
\(\sigma_x = \sqrt{\dfrac{44\,695.4}{184} - \text{``}15.22..\text{''}^2}\) or \(\sqrt{11.1(422\ldots)}\)
M1
1.1b
\(= 3.33800\ldots\) awrt 3.34
A1
1.1b
(3)
Notes
B1 for awrt 15.2 (Do not accept fractions or mixed numbers)
M1 for a correct expression including square root (ft their mean) May be implied by an answer of 3.3 or better.
A1 for awrt 3.34 [Allow \(s = 3.3471\ldots\) i.e. awrt 3.35 if correct formula/expression is seen]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Mean is higher than average OR a summer/spring month If they say winter/autumn they must explain that these are hotter months for Perth.
M1
2.4
[Perth is southern hemisphere or Australia so latest available] month is Oct
A1cso
2.2b
(2)
(6 marks)
Notes
If answer in (b)(i) \(\gt 19.4\) and an attempt is made in (c) please send to review.
M1 for a reason mentioning that mean or temperature is higher (o.e.) e.g. it is a warmer/hotter month is OK or sight of \(19.4 \gt\) (their) 15.2 Only ft their 15.2 if it is less than 19.4 OR suggesting a summer/spring month. Ignore incorrect statements that are irrelevant or don’t contradict For incorrect statements that contradict score M0
A1cso dep on M1 scored for inferring October Must choose just October not a range like August~October (NB actual mean for Sep is 15.6 and sd 3.19 and this scores A0) Can accept for example “high mean so December” for M1A0
SC M1A1 for “October since Perth is in the southern hemisphere/Australia” M1A0 for “Sep or Nov or Dec or Jan or Feb and “Perth is in the southern hemisphere/Australia” M0A0 just “Perth is in the southern hemisphere/Australia” without a month M0A0
3. Ben is studying the Daily Total Rainfall, \(x\) mm, in Leeming for 1987
He used all the data from the large data set and summarised the information in the following table.
\(x\)
0
0.1–0.5
0.6–1.0
1.1–1.9
2.0–4.0
4.1–6.9
7.0–12.0
12.1–20.9
21.0–32.0
tr
Frequency
55
18
18
21
17
9
9
6
2
29
(a) Explain how the data will need to be cleaned before Ben can start to calculate statistics such as the mean and standard deviation. (2)
Using all 184 of these values, Ben estimates \(\sum x = 390\) and \(\sum x^2 = 4336\)
(b) Calculate estimates for
(i) the mean Daily Total Rainfall,
(ii) the standard deviation of the Daily Total Rainfall. (3)
Ben suggests using the statistic calculated in part (b)(i) to estimate the annual mean Daily Total Rainfall in Leeming for 1987
(c) Using your knowledge of the large data set,
(i) give a reason why these data would not be suitable,
(ii) state, giving a reason, how you would expect the estimate in part (b)(i) to differ from the actual annual mean Daily Total Rainfall in Leeming for 1987 (2)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Need to replace tr with a numerical value
M1
1.2
Value of tr is between 0 and 0.05 suggest using e.g 0.025, 0 or value \(\leqslant 0.05\)
A1
1.1b
(2)
Notes
M1: for recognising that tr must be replaced (oe) with a numerical value The following examples would score M0: The tr values are worth 0 so ignore (not replacing) or must remove outliers or fill gaps in table or make widths the same or need to find mid-points
A1: for using a suitable value: e.g. 0.025 (or allow 0) i.e. any value in [0, 0.05] (these give \(\sum x = 390\) (3sf), use of 0.05 gives 390.8, use of 0 gives 389.3 allow in (b)(i))
(ii) \([\sigma =]\sqrt{\dfrac{(\text{awrt})4336}{184} - \text{``}\bar{x}^2\text{''}}\) or allow \(\left[\sigma^2 =\right] \dfrac{(\text{awrt})4336}{184} - \text{``}\bar{x}^2\text{''}\) or awrt 19.1
M1
1.1b
\(= 4.367\ldots\) awrt 4.37
A1
1.1b
(3)
Notes
(b)(i) B1: for awrt 2.12 or allow simplified fraction or mixed number. B0 for \(\frac{390}{184}\)
(ii) M1: for a correct expression for standard deviation or variance. Allow \(\sum x^2 =\) awrt 4336 Ignore their label \(\sigma\) or \(\sigma^2\) Can ft their mean
A1: for awrt 4.37 [Use of \(s\) gives 4.3791… so for correct use seen allow awrt 4.38]
SC:Using \(n = 155\) Allow M1 for expression \([\sigma =]\sqrt{\dfrac{(\text{awrt})4336}{155} - \text{``}\bar{x}^2\text{''}} = \sqrt{21.64\ldots}\) or 4.65…
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Only covers May~Oct (so not a suitable sample)
B1
1.1b
(ii) e.g. Winter months are missing when we’d expect more rain so expect estimate in (b)(i) to be an underestimate (oe)
B1
2.4
(2)
(7 marks)
Notes
Part (c) can effectively be marked together.
(c)(i) B1: for a comment mentioning that data is just from May~Oct (so not representative of the whole year). Just saying “only 184 days so not representative” is B0, must mention May ~ Oct
(ii) B1: for comment that missing/winter months expected to have more rain (oe) and “underestimate”(oe) We are looking for all 3 of these ideas here:
A statement or implication that missing data is from winter or different months.
A suggestion about the rainfall in these months (probably more rain).
A statement about the impact on the estimate in (b)(i) equivalent to saying it would be an underestimate or the (actual) mean will be higher.
SC: If you see “Leeming or N or NE has less rain in winter months” – please send to review
(i) the mean of the Daily Total Rainfall in Camborne for August 2015,
(ii) the standard deviation of the Daily Total Rainfall in Camborne for August 2015. (3)
Dian believes that the mean Daily Total Rainfall in August is less in the South of the UK than in the North of the UK. The mean Daily Total Rainfall in Leuchars for August 2015 is 1.72 mm to 2 decimal places.
(c) State, giving a reason, whether this provides evidence to support Dian’s belief. (2)
Dian uses the large data set to estimate the proportion of days with no rain in Camborne for 1987 to be 0.27 to 2 decimal places.
(d) Explain why the distribution B(14, 0.27) might not be a reasonable model for the number of days without rain for a 14-day summer event. (1)
3. Stav is studying the large data set for September 2015
He codes the variable Daily Mean Pressure, \(x\), using the formula \(y = x - 1010\)
The data for all 30 days from Hurn are summarised by\[\sum y = 214 \qquad \sum y^2 = 5912\]
(a) State the units of the variable \(x\) (1)
(b) Find the mean Daily Mean Pressure for these 30 days. (2)
(c) Find the standard deviation of Daily Mean Pressure for these 30 days. (3)
Stav knows that, in the UK, winds circulate
in a clockwise direction around a region of high pressure
in an anticlockwise direction around a region of low pressure
The table gives the Daily Mean Pressure for 3 locations from the large data set on 26/09/2015
Location
Heathrow
Hurn
Leuchars
Daily Mean Pressure
1029
1028
1028
Cardinal Wind Direction
The Cardinal Wind Directions for these 3 locations on 26/09/2015 were, in random order,
W NE E
You may assume that these 3 locations were under a single region of pressure.
(d) Using your knowledge of the large data set, place each of these Cardinal Wind Directions in the correct location in the table. Give a reason for your answer. (2)
B1 for “hectopascal” or hPa (condone pascals, allow millibars or mb) o.e. Do NOT allow kPa or kilopascals or Pa on its own
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\bar{x} = \bar{y} + 1010\) or \(\dfrac{214}{30} + 1010\)
M1
1.1b
\(= 1017.1333\ldots\) awrt 1017
A1
1.1b
(2)
Notes
M1 for a strategy to find \(\bar{x}\) Allow an attempt to find \(\sum x\) that gets as far as \(\sum x = \sum y - 30 \times 1010\) [= 30 514]
A1 for awrt 1017 (accept 1020) [Ignore incorrect units]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\sigma_x = \sigma_y\) (or statement that standard deviation is not affected by this type of coding)
M1
3.1b
\([\sigma_y =]\ \sqrt{\dfrac{5912}{30} - (\text{``}7.13[33\ldots]\text{''})^2}\) or \(\sqrt{146.1822\ldots}\)
M1
1.1b
\(= 12.0905\ldots\) awrt 12.1
A1
1.1b
(3)
Notes
1st M1 for an overall strategy using the fact \(\sigma_x = \sigma_y\) (can be implied by correct final ans) or for \(\sum x = 30\,514\) and \(\sum x^2 = 31\,041\,192\) (both seen and correct)
2nd M1 for a correct expression (with \(\sqrt{\phantom{x}}\)) (ft their \(\bar{y}\) to 3sf) allow awrt 146 for 146.1822.. or for correct expression in \(x\) can ft their \(\sum x \gt 30\,000\) or their answer to (b)
A1 (dep on 2nd M1) for awrt 12.1 [Ignore incorrect units]
Final answer Final ans of awrt 12.1 scores 3/3 but if they then adjust for \(x\) e.g. add 1010 (M0M1A1)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
High pressure (since approx. mean + sd) so clockwise Locations are (from North to South): Leuchars, Heathrow, Hurn
B1
2.4
Wind direction is direction wind blows from So: Heathrow (NE) Hurn (E) Leuchars (W)
B1
2.2a
(2)
(8 marks)
Notes
1st B1 for at least one of these reasons (these 2 lines) clearly stated (may see diagram) Need “high pressure” and “clockwise” to score on 1st line Contradictory statements B0 e.g. correct N~S list but say “anticlockwise”
2nd B1 (indep of 1st B1) for deducing the 3 correct directions either in the table or stated as above If the answers in table and text are different we take the table (as question says)
M1 for sight of \(\mathrm{B}(36, 0.08)\) Allow in words: binomial with \(n = 36\) and \(p = 0.08\) may be implied by one correct answer to 2sf or sight of \(\mathrm{P}(X \leqslant 6) = 0.97776\ldots\) i.e. awrt 0.98 Allow for \(36\mathrm{C}4 \times 0.08^4 \times 0.92^{32}\) as this is “correct use”
(i) 1st A1 for awrt 0.167 NB An answer of just awrt 0.167 scores M1(\(\Rightarrow\))1st A1
(ii) 2nd A1 for awrt 0.0222
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
P(In dance club and dance tango) \(= 0.4 \times 0.08 =\) 0.032or \(\underline{\underline{\dfrac{4}{125}}}\) or3.2%
B1
1.1b
(1)
Notes
B1 for 0.032 o.e. (Can allow for sight of \(0.4 \times 0.08\))
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
[Let \(T\) = those who can dance the Tango. Sight or use of] \(T \sim \mathrm{B}(50, \text{``}0.032\text{''})\)
M1 for sight of \(\mathrm{B}(50, \text{``}0.032\text{''})\) ft their answer to (c) provided it is a probability \(\neq 0.08\) may be implied by correct answer or sight of \([\mathrm{P}(T \leqslant 3)] = 0.924348\ldots\) i.e. awrt 0.924 or \(\mathrm{P}(T \leqslant 2)\) as part of \(1 - \mathrm{P}(T \leqslant 2)\) calc.
A1 for awrt 0.785
MR Allow MR of 50 (e.g. 30) provided clearly attempting \(\mathrm{P}(T \leqslant 2)\) and score M1A0
3. Each member of a group of 27 people was timed when completing a puzzle.
The time taken, \(x\) minutes, for each member of the group was recorded.
These times are summarised in the following box and whisker plot.
(a) Find the range of the times. (1)
(b) Find the interquartile range of the times. (1)
For these 27 people \(\sum x = 607.5\) and \(\sum x^2 = 17\,623.25\)
(c) calculate the mean time taken to complete the puzzle, (1)
(d) calculate the standard deviation of the times taken to complete the puzzle. (2)
Taruni defines an outlier as a value more than 3 standard deviations above the mean.
(e) State how many outliers Taruni would say there are in these data, giving a reason for your answer. (1)
Adam and Beth also completed the puzzle in \(a\) minutes and \(b\) minutes respectively, where \(a \gt b\). When their times are included with the data of the other 27 people
the median time increases
the mean time does not change
(f) Suggest a possible value for \(a\) and a possible value for \(b\), explaining how your values satisfy the above conditions. (3)
(g) Without carrying out any further calculations, explain why the standard deviation of all 29 times will be lower than your answer to part (d). (1)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
[\(68 - 7 =\)] 61 (only)
B1
1.1b
(1)
Notes
B1: for correctly interpreting the box plot to find the range (more than 1 answer is B0)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
[\(25 - 14\)] = 11
B1
1.1b
(1)
Notes
B1: for correct understanding of IQR and answer of 11
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\left[\mu \text{ or } \bar{x} = \dfrac{607.5}{27} =\right]\) = 22.5
B1
1.1b
(1)
Notes
B1: for 22.5 only (or exact equivalent such as \(\frac{45}{2}\)). Allow 22 mins and 30 secs.
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\sigma = \sqrt{\dfrac{17\,623.25}{27} - \text{``}22.5\text{''}^2}\) or \(\sqrt{146.4629\ldots}\)
M1
1.1b
= 12.10218… awrt 12.1
A1
1.1b
(2)
Notes
M1: for a correct expression including square root. Allow \(\sqrt{146}\) or better. Ft their mean
A1: for awrt 12.1 NB Allow use of \(s = 12.3327\ldots\) or awrt 12.3
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\mu + 3\sigma = \text{``}22.5\text{''} + 3 \times \text{``}12.1\ldots\text{''} = \text{awrt } 59\) so only one outlier
B1ft
1.1b
(1)
Notes
B1ft: for a correct calculation or value based on their \(\mu\) and \(\sigma\) and compatible conclusion
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Median increases implies that both values must be > 20
M1
3.1b
Mean is the same means that \(a + b = 45\)
M1
1.1b
So possible values are: e.g. \(b = 21\) and \(a = 24\) (o.e.)
A1
2.2b
(3)
Notes
1st M1: Correct start to the problem and a correct statement about the values based on median Allow if their final two values are both >20
2nd M1: for a correct explanation leading to equation \(a + b = 45\) (o.e. e.g. equidistant from mean) Allow if their final two values sum to 45
A1: for a correct pair of values (both > 20 with a sum of 45) and at least some attempt to explain how their values satisfy at least one of the conditions (both > 20 or \(a + b = 45\)). Ignore \(a =\) or \(b =\) labels
NB: The values for \(a\) and \(b\) do not need to be integers.
Mark scheme (g)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Both values will be less than 1 standard deviation from the mean and so the standard deviation of all 29 values will be smaller
B1
2.4
(1)
(10 marks)
Notes
B1: for a correct explanation. Must mention that both values are less than 1 sd (ft their answer to (d)) from the mean
The partially completed box plot in Figure 1 shows the distribution of daily mean air temperatures using the data from the large data set for Beijing in 2015
An outlier is defined as a value more than \(1.5 \times \text{IQR}\) below \(Q_1\) or more than \(1.5 \times \text{IQR}\) above \(Q_3\)
The three lowest air temperatures in the data set are \(7.6\,{}^{\circ}\text{C}\), \(8.1\,{}^{\circ}\text{C}\) and \(9.1\,{}^{\circ}\text{C}\) The highest air temperature in the data set is \(32.5\,{}^{\circ}\text{C}\)
(a) Complete the box plot in Figure 1 showing clearly any outliers. (4)
(b) Using your knowledge of the large data set, suggest from which month the two outliers are likely to have come. (1)
Using the data from the large data set, Simon produced the following summary statistics for the daily mean air temperature, \(x\,{}^{\circ}\text{C}\), for Beijing in 2015
(c) Show that, to 3 significant figures, the standard deviation is \(5.19\,{}^{\circ}\text{C}\) (1)
Simon decides to model the air temperatures with the random variable
\[T \sim \mathrm{N}(22.6,\ 5.19^2)\]
(d) Using Simon’s model, calculate the 10th to 90th interpercentile range. (3)
Simon wants to model another variable from the large data set for Beijing using a normal distribution.
(e) State two variables from the large data set for Beijing that are not suitable to be modelled by a normal distribution. Give a reason for each answer. (2)
Plotting one upper whisker to 32.5 and one lower whisker to 8.6 or 9.1
A1
1.1b
Plotting 7.6 and 8.1 as the only two outliers
A1
1.1b
(4)
Notes
B1: for a correct calculation for the IQR (implied by 10.8 or 8.6 or 37.4 seen)
M1: for a complete method for either lower outlier limit or upper outlier limit (allow ft on their IQR) (may be implied by the 1st A1 or a lower whisker at 8.6)
A1: both whiskers plotted correctly (allow ½ square tolerance)
A1: only two outliers plotted, 7.6 and 8.1 (must be disconnected from whisker)
NOTE: A fully correct box plot with no incorrect working scores 4/4
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
October (since it is the month with the coldest temperatures between May and October in Beijing)
B1
2.4
(1)
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\([\sigma =]\sqrt{\dfrac{4952.906}{184}}\) or e.g. \([\sigma =]\sqrt{\dfrac{\mathrm{S}_{xx}}{n}} = 5.188\ldots\) \([= 5.19^*]\)
B1cso*
1.1b
(1)
Notes
B1cso*: Correct expression with square root or correct formula and 5.188 or better
Allow a complete correct method finding \(\sum x^2 = \text{awrt } 98720\) and \(\sigma = \sqrt{\dfrac{98715.9\ldots}{184} - \left(\dfrac{4153.6}{184}\right)^2}\)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(z = (\pm)\ 1.28(16)\) or \([P_{90} =]\ 29.251\ldots\) or \([P_{10} =]\ 15.948\ldots\)
B1
3.1b
\(2 \times 1.2816 \times 5.19\) or ‘\(29.251\ldots\)’ – ‘\(15.948\ldots\)’
M1
1.1b
\(=\) awrt 13.3
A1
1.1b
(3)
Notes
B1: Identifying \(z\)-value for 10th or 90th percentile (allow awrt \((\pm)\ 1.28\)) or for identifying \([P_{90} =]\ 29.251\ldots\) (awrt 29.3) or \([P_{10} =]\ 15.948\ldots\) (awrt 15.9) (This may be implied by a correct answer awrt 13.3)
M1: for \(2 \times z \times 5.19\) where \(1 \lt z \lt 2\) or for their \(P_{90} - P_{10}\) where \(25 \lt P_{90} \lt 35\) and \(10 \lt P_{10} \lt 20\)
A1: awrt 13.3
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Daily mean wind speed/Beaufort conversion since it is qualitative Rainfall since it is not symmetric/lots of days with 0 rainfall
B1 B1
2.4 2.4
(2)
(11 marks)
Notes
B1: for one variable identified and a correct supporting reason
B1: for two variables identified and a correct supporting reason for each
Allow any two of the following:
Wind speed/Beaufort since the data is non-numeric (o.e.). They need not mention Beaufort provided there is a description of the data as non-numeric (Do not allow wind direction/wind gust)
Rainfall as not symmetric/is skewed/is not bell shaped/lots of 0s /many days with no rain/mean≠mode or median
Date since each data value appears once/it is uniformly distributed
Daily mean pressure since it is not symmetric/is skewed/not bell shaped
Daily mean wind speed since it is not symmetric/is skewed/not bell shaped
Do not allow ‘not continuous’ or ‘discrete’ as a supporting reason. Ignore extraneous non-contradicting statements
4. Charlie is studying the time it takes members of his company to travel to the office. He stands by the door to the office from 08 40 to 08 50 one morning and asks workers, as they arrive, how long their journey was.
(a) State the sampling method Charlie used. (1)
(b) State and briefly describe an alternative method of non-random sampling Charlie could have used to obtain a sample of 40 workers. (2)
Taruni decided to ask every member of the company the time, \(x\) minutes, it takes them to travel to the office.
(c) State the data selection process Taruni used. (1)
Taruni’s results are summarised by the box plot and summary statistics below.
(d) Write down the interquartile range for these data. (1)
(e) Calculate the mean and the standard deviation for these data. (3)
(f) State, giving a reason, whether you would recommend using the mean and standard deviation or the median and interquartile range to describe these data. (2)
Rana and David both work for the company and have both moved house since Taruni collected her data.
Rana’s journey to work has changed from 75 minutes to 35 minutes and David’s journey to work has changed from 60 minutes to 33 minutes.
Taruni drew her box plot again and only had to change two values.
(g) Explain which two values Taruni must have changed and whether each of these values has increased or decreased. (3)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Convenience or opportunity [sampling]
B1
1.2
(1)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Quota [sampling]
B1
1.1a
e.g. Take 4 people every 10 minutes
B1
1.1b
(2)
Notes
1st B1 for quota (sampling) mentioned (“Stratified” or “systematic” or “random” are B0B0)
2nd B1 for a description of how such a system might work, requires suitable strata or categories e.g. time slots, departments, gender, age groups, distance travelled etc Suggestion of randomness is B0
M1 for a correct expression for the sd (including \(\sqrt{\ }\)) ft their mean
A1 for awrt 15.4 (Allow \(s = 15.4667\ldots\) awrt 15.5)
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
AO
There are outliers in the data (or data is skew) which will affect mean and sd
B1
2.4
Therefore use median and IQR
dB1
2.4
(2)
Notes
1st B1 for acknowledging outliers or skewness are a problem for mean and sd “extreme values”/“anomalies” OK May be implied by saying median and IQR not affected by.. We need to see mention of “outliers”, “skewness” and the problem so “data is skewed so use median and IQR” is B0 unless mention that they are not affected by extreme values or mean and standard deviation can be “inflated” by the positive skew etc
2nd dB1 dep on 1st B1 for therefore choosing median and IQR
Mark scheme (g)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Value of 20, LQ at 26 and outliers will not change or state that median and upper quartile are the values that do change
B1
1.1b
More values now below 40 than above so \(Q_2\) or \(Q_3\) will change and be lower
M1
2.1
Both \(Q_2\) and \(Q_3\) will be lower
A1
2.4
(3)
(13 marks)
Notes
B1 for identifying 2 of these 3 groups of unchanged values or stating only \(Q_2\) and \(Q_3\) change
M1 for explaining that median or UQ should be lower. E.g. the 2 values have moved to below 40 (or 58) and therefore more than 50% below 40 or (more than 75% below 58) or an argument to show that the other 3 values are the same. (o.e.) Allow arrows on box plot provided statement in words about increased % below 40 or 58 etc
A1 for stating median and UQ are both lower with clear evidence of M1 scored
[If lots of values on 40 then median might not change but, since two values do change then UQ would change. If this meant that 92 became an outlier then we would have a new value for upper whisker and an extra outlier so effectively 3 values are altered. So median changes]
2. An estate agent is studying the cost of office space in London. He takes a random sample of 90 offices and calculates the cost, £\(x\) per square foot. His results are given in the table below.
Cost (£\(x\))
Frequency (f)
Midpoint (£\(y\))
\(20 \leqslant x \lt 40\)
12
30
\(40 \leqslant x \lt 45\)
13
42.5
\(45 \leqslant x \lt 50\)
25
47.5
\(50 \leqslant x \lt 60\)
32
55
\(60 \leqslant x \lt 80\)
8
70
(You may use \(\sum \mathrm{f}y^2 = 226\,687.5\))
A histogram is drawn for these data and the bar representing \(50 \leqslant x \lt 60\) is 2 cm wide and 8 cm high.
(a) Calculate the width and height of the bar representing \(20 \leqslant x \lt 40\) (3)
(b) Use linear interpolation to estimate the median cost. (2)
(c) Estimate the mean cost of office space for these data. (2)
(d) Estimate the standard deviation for these data. (2)
(e) Describe, giving a reason, the skewness. (1)
Rika suggests that the cost of office space in London can be modelled by a normal distribution with mean £50 and standard deviation £10
(f) With reference to your answer to part (e), comment on Rika’s suggestion. (1)
(g) Use Rika’s model to estimate the 80th percentile of the cost of office space in London. (3)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
Width (\(w\)) = 4 cm
B1
Areas: 16 cm\(^2\) represents 32 offices (o.e.) or their \(h = \dfrac{6}{\text{their } w}\) (3sf) or \(\dfrac{8}{3.2} \times 0.6\)
M1
So height (\(h\)) = 1.5 cm
A1
(3)
Notes
M1 for a correct calculation of areas 1 cm\(^2\) = 2 offices (o.e.)
A1 for \(h\) = 1.5 cm (Correct answer only 2/2)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
e.g. \((45) + \dfrac{20}{25} \times 5\) or \((50) - \dfrac{5}{25} \times 5\) (o.e.) ; = (£) 49
M1; A1
(2)
Notes
M1 for a correct expression without end point. Allow “\(n\) + 1” so e.g. \((45) + \frac{20.5}{25} \times 5\)
A1 for 49 or, if ( \(n\) + 1) used, allow 49.1 (Correct answer of 49 only 2/2)
M1 for an attempt at \(\frac{\sum \mathrm{f}y}{90}\) with at least 3 correct products of \(\sum \mathrm{f}y\) or \(4000 \leqslant \sum \mathrm{f}y \leqslant 5000\)
A1 for 49.11 (Allow 49.1 from correct working) (Correct answer only 2/2, 49.1 only M1A0)
M1 for a correct expression including \(\sqrt{\ }\), ft their mean. Allow use of \(s\)
A1 for awrt 10.3 Allow \(s\) = awrt 10.4 if clearly used. [NB use of 49.1 gives 10.389 \(\Rightarrow\) A0] (Correct answer of 10.3 with no working is 2/2)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
Mean \(\approx\) median so distribution is symmetric (no skew or very little skew) [Allow mean > median or \(k(\bar{x} - Q_2)\) (\(k\)>0) so +ve skew if compatible with their figures] [If using quartiles we must see \(Q_1 = 44.0\) and \(Q_3 = 55.5\) used]
B1ft
(1)
Notes
B1ft for reason and “symmetric” (or other correct) statement [Allow positive skew] Allow ft of their (b) and their (c). For “symmetric” need \(|\bar{x} - Q_2| \lt 1\) “correlation” is B0
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
Symmetric ( or little skew) so normal (or Rika’s suggestion) may be suitable
B1ft
(1)
Notes
B1ft Suggest normal is or isn’t suitable with suitable reason based on (e) or mean and med
Mark scheme (g)
Scheme
Marks
\(\dfrac{c - 50}{10} = 0.8416\) [N.B. use of (1 – 0.8416) is B0]
M1, B1
\(c = 58.416\) = (£) 58.42 awrt 58.4
A1
(3)
(14 marks)
Notes
M1 for stand’ing using “\(c\)”, 50 and 10 and setting equal to \(\pm z\) value where \(0.84 \leqslant z \leqslant 0.85\)
B1 for using \(z = \pm 0.8416\) or better (calc gives 0.8416212…) in standard’ attempt e.g. \(\sqrt{10}\) for 10
A1 for awrt 58.4 (accept 3sf here) (Ans only of awrt 58.4 is M1B0A1 but 58.416 or better is 3/3)
1. A clothes shop manager records the weekly sales figures, £\(s\), and the average weekly temperature, \(t\) °C, for 6 weeks during the summer. The sales figures were coded so that
(a) Find \(\mathrm{S}_{wt}\) and \(\mathrm{S}_{tt}\) (3)
(b) Write down the value of \(\mathrm{S}_{ss}\) and the value of \(\mathrm{S}_{st}\) (2)
(c) Find the product moment correlation coefficient between \(s\) and \(t\). (2)
The manager of the clothes shop believes that a linear regression model may be appropriate to describe these data.
(d) State, giving a reason, whether or not your value of the correlation coefficient supports the manager’s belief. (1)
(e) Find the equation of the regression line of \(w\) on \(t\), giving your answer in the form \(w = a + bt\) (3)
(f) Hence find the equation of the regression line of \(s\) on \(t\), giving your answer in the form \(s = c + dt\), where \(c\) and \(d\) are correct to 3 significant figures. (2)
(g) Using your equation in part (f), interpret the effect of a 1 °C increase in average weekly temperature on weekly sales during the summer. (1)
M1 for a correct expression using their values provided \(\mathrm{S}_{tt}\) and \(\mathrm{S}_{ss}\) both > 0
A1 for awrt – 0.801 (Correct ans. only M1A1, – 0.80 with no working M1A0)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
\(r\) is close to – 1 or \(|r|\) is close to 1 or “strong” (o.e.) [negative] correlation … so “yes” ordoes support the belief
B1ft
(1)
Notes
B1ft for a correct comment that uses their value of \(r\) as support, provided \(0.5 \leqslant |r| \leqslant 1\) For \(|r| \lt 0.5\) comment must be “does not support”, because “weak” (o.e.) correlation.
NB “points lie close to a straight line” is B0 unless supported by mention of their value of \(r\)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
\(b = \dfrac{\text{"}-49\text{"}}{\text{"}74.8\dot{3}\text{"}} = [-0.6547\ldots],\ \ a = \dfrac{42}{6} - b \times \dfrac{119}{6} = [19.9866\ldots]\) or \(a = 7 - b \times 19.8\dot{3}\)
M1, M1
So \(w = 20.0 - 0.655t\)
A1
(3)
Notes
1st M1 for a correct expression for \(b\) or awrt \(-0.66\) or \(-0.65\) Ft their answers from (a)
2nd M1 for a correct expression for \(a\) ft their value for \(b\)
A1 for a correct equation in \(w\) and \(t\) only with \(a = 20\) or awrt 20.0 and \(b\) = awrt – 0.655 (No fractions) If their \(a\) and \(b\) are given to more than 3 sf, accept answers in (f) to 3sf or better.
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
\(s = 20\,000 - 655t\) or \(c = 20\,000\) and \(d = -655\)
B1ft B1ft
(2)
Notes
1st B1 ft for correct \(c\) or “their 20.0”\(\times 1000\) 2nd B1ft for correct \(d\) or their “– 0.655”\(\times 1000\) Values can be in an \(s\), \(t\) eq’n or \(c =\), \(d =\) (Their \(a\) and \(b\) needn’t be to 3 sf and ft their letter for \(t\))
Mark scheme (g)
Scheme
Marks
Decrease in sales of [£] 655 ( ignore any minus sign)
B1ft
(1)
(14 marks)
Notes
B1ft for stating clearly both decrease (o.e.) and [£] 655. Ft their \(d\) and allow “increase” if \(d \gt 0\)
5. A midwife records the weights, in kg, of a sample of 50 babies born at a hospital. Her results are given in the table below.
Weight (\(w\) kg)
Frequency (f)
Weight midpoint (\(x\))
\(0 \leqslant w \lt 2\)
1
1
\(2 \leqslant w \lt 3\)
8
2.5
\(3 \leqslant w \lt 3.5\)
17
3.25
\(3.5 \leqslant w \lt 4\)
17
3.75
\(4 \leqslant w \lt 5\)
7
4.5
[You may use \(\sum \mathrm{f}x^2 = 611.375\)]
A histogram has been drawn to represent these data.
The bar representing the weight \(2 \leqslant w \lt 3\) has a width of 1 cm and a height of 4 cm.
(a) Calculate the width and height of the bar representing a weight of \(3 \leqslant w \lt 3.5\) (3)
(b) Use linear interpolation to estimate the median weight of these babies. (2)
(c)
(i) Show that an estimate of the mean weight of these babies is 3.43 kg.
(ii) Find an estimate of the standard deviation of the weights of these babies. (3)
Shyam decides to model the weights of babies born at the hospital, by the random variable \(W\), where \(W \sim \mathrm{N}(3.43, 0.65^2)\)
(d) Find \(\mathrm{P}(W \lt 3)\) (3)
(e) With reference to your answers to (b), (c)(i) and (d) comment on Shyam’s decision. (3)
A newborn baby weighing 3.43 kg is born at the hospital.
(f) Without carrying out any further calculations, state, giving a reason, what effect the addition of this newborn baby to the sample would have on your estimate of the
(i) mean,
(ii) standard deviation. (3)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
Width = 0.5 (cm)
B1
e.g 4 [cm\(^2\)] represents 8 babies or frequency densities are 8 and 34
M1
Height = 17 (cm)
A1
(3)
Notes
M1 for clear representation of area with frequency or height\(\times\)width = 8.5
A1 for 17 (cm) [Must be clear it is height not frequency] (Ans only must satisfy \(h \times w = 8.5\))
(i) B1cso for \(\Sigma \mathrm{f}x\) (at least 3 correct & no incorrect products seen) and correct \(\dfrac{\sum \mathrm{f}x}{50}\) or \(\dfrac{171.5}{50}\)
(ii) M1 for a correct expression including square root. Must use 3.43 no ft A1 for awrt 0.680 (accept 0.68). Allow use of \(s\) = awrt 0.687 (Ans only 2/2)
3. Before going on holiday to Seapron, Tania records the weekly rainfall (\(x\) mm) at Seapron for 8 weeks during the summer. Her results are summarised as
\[\sum x = 86.8 \qquad \sum x^2 = 985.88\]
(a) Find the standard deviation, \(\sigma_x\), for these data. (3)
Tania also records the number of hours of sunshine (\(y\) hours) per week at Seapron for these 8 weeks and obtains the following
(b) Show that \(\mathrm{S}_{yy} = 716\) (correct to 3 significant figures) (1)
(c) Find \(\mathrm{S}_{xy}\) (2)
(d) Calculate the product moment correlation coefficient, \(r\), for these data. (2)
During Tania’s week-long holiday at Seapron there are 14 mm of rain and 70 hours of sunshine.
(e) State, giving a reason, what the effect of adding this information to the above data would be on the value of the product moment correlation coefficient. (2)
M1 for a correct expr’ for st. dev or variance (ignore label)[may be implied by 2.35 or 5.5125]
1st A1 for a correct expression for st. dev (must have square root) can ignore label
2nd A1 for awrt 2.35 (allow \(s = 2.5099\ldots\) or awrt 2.51). If they have \(\sigma^2 = 2.35\) score A0 but condone no label
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
\(\mathrm{S}_{yy} = 8 \times \sigma_y^{\,2} = 716\) (3 sf) but may see \(1136.584 - \dfrac{58^2}{8}\) or \(27628(.084168) - \dfrac{464^2}{8}\) or 716.08... (= 716 to 3 sf) (*)
B1cso
(1)
Notes
B1cso for a correct expression or sight of at least 716.08… (NB limits: 716.00~716.16) Do not allow verification. Beware circular arguments: \(716 \to \Sigma y^2 \to\) expr’ \(\to 716\)
M1 for a correct expression for \(\mathrm{S}_{xy}\) (NB \(\Sigma y = 464\))
A1 for \(-133.9\) or awrt \(-134\) [No fractions] (Answer only 2/2)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
\(r = \dfrac{-133.9/8}{\sigma_x \times \sigma_y}\) or \(\dfrac{-133.9}{\sqrt{44.1 \times 716}}\)
M1
\(= \) awrt \(-\)0.753 or \(-\)0.754
A1
(2)
Notes
M1 for a correct expression for \(r\) (ft their values for \(\mathrm{S}_{xy}\) and \(\sigma_x\) or \(\mathrm{S}_{xx}\))[Allow ft of \(\mathrm{S}_{yy}\)]
A1 for awrt \(-0.753\) or \(-0.754\) (Answer only 2/2)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
\(r \lt 0\) means high sunshine and low rain; this is high sunshine high rain
B1
[this is not in keeping with the trend so] \(r\) is closer to 0 or \(|r|\) decreases
B1
(2)
(10 marks)
Notes
If they do not have an answer to (d) or their value of \(r\) is > 0 or \(|r| \gt 1\) score B0B0 here
1st B1 for a suitable reason contradicting \(r \lt 0\) e.g. new value is not in keeping with trendor both \(14 \gt \bar{x}\) and \(70 \gt \bar{y}\) or saying both above average. Allow for \(-0.48 \lt\) new \(r \lt -0.47\)
2nd B1 for a correct statement about \(r\) getting closer to zero e.g. \(|r|\) decreases A comment that \(r\) decreases or \(r\) is smaller or \(r\) is “less negative” is B0 “\(r\) increases” is B0 unless they also say that it gets closer to 0
M1 for a correct expression (condone missing \(-\))
A1 for awrt \(-0.749\) (\(-0.75\) or awrt 0.749 with no working scores M1 A0).
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
\(-0.749\)
B1ft
(1)
Notes
B1ft for \(-0.749\) or ft their answer to (b) to at least 2sf. Must be in the range \(-1 \lt \text{'}(b)\text{'} \lt 1\)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
House H: 156 400/85 = [£1840/m\(^2\) or \(q = 4\)] House J: 172 900/95 = [£1820/m\(^2\) or \(q = 2\)]
M1
Since (\(r = -0.749\),) there is negative correlation. or The higher the price (per square metre), the lower the distance from the train station.
dM1
Therefore…..House H is likely to be closer.
A1
(3)
(8 marks)
Notes
M1 for calculating price/square metre for both \(H\) and \(J\). Can be implied by sight of 1840 and 1820 (so OK if not labelled or mis-labelled) These may be seen in the table in the question. Allow comment like “\(H\) is £20/square metre more than \(J\)”
dM1 dependent on 1st M1 for a statement that correlation is negative or a contextualised interpretation of the negative correlation.
\(r \gt 0\) If \(r \gt 0\) allow equivalent statements about positive correlation
A1 (dependent on both Ms) for House H is likely to be closer (No ft if \(r \gt 0\))
5. A survey of 100 households gave the following results for weekly income £\(y\).
Income \(y\) (£)
Mid-point
Frequency \(f\)
\(0 \leqslant y \lt 200\)
100
12
\(200 \leqslant y \lt 240\)
220
28
\(240 \leqslant y \lt 320\)
280
22
\(320 \leqslant y \lt 400\)
360
18
\(400 \leqslant y \lt 600\)
500
12
\(600 \leqslant y \lt 800\)
700
8
(You may use \(\sum fy^2 = 12\,452\,800\))
A histogram was drawn and the class \(200 \leqslant y \lt 240\) was represented by a rectangle of width 2 cm and height 7 cm.
(a) Calculate the width and the height of the rectangle representing the class \(320 \leqslant y \lt 400\) (3)
(b) Use linear interpolation to estimate the median weekly income to the nearest pound. (2)
(c) Estimate the mean and the standard deviation of the weekly income for these data. (4)
One measure of skewness is \(\dfrac{3(\text{mean} - \text{median})}{\text{standard deviation}}\).
(d) Use this measure to calculate the skewness for these data and describe its value. (2)
Katie suggests using the random variable \(X\) which has a normal distribution with mean 320 and standard deviation 150 to model the weekly income for these data.
(e) Find \(\mathrm{P}(240 \lt X \lt 400)\). (2)
(f) With reference to your calculations in parts (d) and (e) and the data in the table, comment on Katie’s suggestion. (2)
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
Width = 4 (cm)
B1
Area of 14 cm\(^2\) represents frequency 28 and area of \(4h\) represents 18
M1
Or \(\dfrac{4h}{18} = \dfrac{14}{28}\) (o.e.) \(\boldsymbol{h} = \underline{\mathbf{2.25}}\) (cm)
A1
(3)
Notes
B1 for width (ignore units)
M1 for clear method using area and frequency or their width \(\times\) their height = 9 e.g. seeing both fd of 0.7 and 0.225 (may see fd in the table) [Must use correct interval]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
\(m = (240) + \dfrac{10}{22}\times 80\) (o.e.)
M1
\(= 276.36\ldots\) (\(\frac{3040}{11}\)) ((£)276 \(\leqslant m \lt\) (£)276.5)
A1
(2)
Notes
M1 for \(\dfrac{10}{22}\times 80\) or \(\dfrac{10.5}{22}\times 80\) (o.e.). Allow use of \((n + 1)\) leading to £278.18… or [278, 278.5)
A1 Do not award if incorrect end-point seen but answer only is 2/2
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
\(\sum fy = 31600\) leading to \(\underline{\bar{y} = 316}\)
1st M1 attempt at \(\sum fy\) with at least 3 correct products or ans. that rounds to 30 000 (to 1 sf) &/100
2nd M1 for correct expression including \(\sqrt{\ }\). Follow through \(\bar{y}\). Need \(\sum fy^2\) correct but condone a minor transcription error e.g. 12458200.
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
Skewness \(= 0.764\ldots\) (awrt 0.76 or 0.75) [If \(n + 1\) used in (b) and \(m\) = £278 accept awrt 0.73 or 0.72]
B1
Positive skew
B1ft
(2)
Notes
1st B1 for awrt 0.76/0.75 for \(m\) = £276 or awrt 0.73/0.72 for \(m\) = £278
2nd B1ft for a correct description of their skew based on their measure or if no measure given based on their values of mean and median. (correlation is B0)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
\(z = \pm\dfrac{80}{150}\)
M1
\(\mathrm{P}(240 \lt X \lt 400) = \underline{\mathbf{0.40 \sim 0.41}}\)
A1
(2)
Notes
M1 for an attempt to standardise using the 320 and 150 and either 240 or 400 (implied by 0.53)
A1 for answer in range [0.40, 0.41] (tables gives 0.4038, calculator 0.40619...) Ans only 2/2
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
(e) suggests a reasonable fit for this range BUT (d) since skew it will not be a good fit overall
B2/1/0
(2)
(15 marks)
Notes
For B2 we need 2 comments that make reference to each of part (e) and part (d) One comment should suggest it is not good since skew. The other it is since matches range in (e)
17 A maths teacher holds a revision session every Wednesday.
In a random sample of eight Wednesdays, the number of students who attended is listed below.
2
4
3
1
4
5
2
3
(a) Find the mean of these eight values. [1 mark]
(b) Find the variance of these eight values. [1 mark]
(c) The teacher believes that the number of students who attended a revision session each Wednesday can be modelled by the binomial distribution \(\mathrm{B}(30, 0.1)\).
Comment on whether the mean and variance found in parts (a) and (b) support the teacher’s belief.
Fully justify your answer.
[3 marks]
(d) The teacher wanted to decide if a Saturday morning revision session was worth doing.
The teacher asked the first 10 students who entered the classroom if they would attend a Saturday session.
(i) Name this method of sampling. [1 mark]
(ii) Describe one advantage of this method of sampling. [1 mark]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Obtains 3
B1
1.1b
(1)
Typical solution
Mean = 3
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Obtains 1.5 Accept AWRT 1.7
B1
1.1b
(1)
Typical solution
Variance = 1.5
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Calculates the mean or variance of the given model \(\mathrm{B}(30, 0.1)\) or forms a correct equation in one variable to find \(n\) or \(p\) for binomial model using their mean from part (a) and their variance from part (b)
M1
3.1a
Obtains the correct mean 3 and variance 2.7 or obtains the correct \(n = 6\) and \(p = 0.5\) for binomial model Accept \(n = 7\) and \(p = 0.43\) for binomial model if using variance 1.7
A1
1.1b
Infers that it is not suitable because of different variance or infers teacher’s belief not supported because of different variance or infers that it is not suitable because of different \(n\) and \(p\) from \(n = 30\) and \(p = 0.1\) Must make a single overarching conclusion Must have obtained correct mean from part (a) and correct variance from part (b) To be awarded R1, marks M1A1 must be scored
16 The distance, in kilometres, travelled from home to work by 340 individuals is shown in the histogram.
(a)
(i) Estimate the number of individuals who travel between 3 km and 5 km from home to work.
Fully justify your answer.
[4 marks]
(ii) Give one reason why your answer to part (a)(i) is only an estimate. [1 mark]
(b) The histogram shows that the data is skewed.
State the type of skewness.
[1 mark]
(c) Explain why frequency density is used in this histogram. [1 mark]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Adds the correct area of each rectangle using scale factor eg. \(17x\) or states that there are 34 big (cm) squares or states that there are 850 small (2mm) squares PI by their ratio or 1cm = 20 seen on the vertical scale or by correct answer
M1
3.1a
Calculates their ratio PI by eg 340 ÷ their 17 or 20 or 340 ÷ their 34 or 10 or 340 ÷ their 850 or 0.4 or by correct answer May be been seen in calculation PI by their ratio or 1cm = 20 seen on the vertical scale without incorrect working
M1
1.1a
States one of 340 ÷ their 17 × 9.5 340 ÷ their 34 × 19 340 ÷ their 850 × 475 May be embedded in calculation PI by correct answer
Concludes correctly in context for the means Comparison must include the word such as ‘on average’ or ‘typically’ etc Follow through the correct comparison of 3100 with their mean from part 14(a)
E1F
2.4
Concludes correctly in context for the standard deviations Comparison must include the word such as ‘varies’, ‘spread’ ‘disperse’ ‘variation’ or ‘consistent’ etc Follow through the correct comparison of 325 with their standard deviation from part 14(b) Do not allow comparison that includes ‘range’ or ‘variety’
E1F
2.4
(2)
(5 marks)
Typical solution
The cost of energy for households in Village A is less on average
The variation in cost of energy is higher in Village A.
(i) It was decided to remove any of the masses which fall outside the following interval.\[\text{median} - 1.5 \times \text{interquartile range} \leqslant \text{mass} \leqslant \text{median} + 1.5 \times \text{interquartile range}\]
Show that only one of the eight masses in the sample should be removed. [3 marks]
(ii) Write down the statistical name for the mass that should be removed in part (a)(i). [1 mark]
(b) The table shows the probability distribution of the number of previous owners, \(N\), for a sample of cars taken from the Large Data Set.
\(n\)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6 or more
\(\mathrm{P}(N = n)\)
0.14
0.37
\(0.9k\)
0.25
\(0.4k\)
\(1.7k\)
0
Find the value of \(\mathrm{P}(1 \leqslant N \lt 5)\) [4 marks]
(c) An expert team is investigating whether there have been any changes in CO2 emissions from all cars taken from the Large Data Set.
The team decided to collect a quota sample of 200 cars to reflect the different years and the different makes of cars in the Large Data Set.
(i) Using your knowledge of the Large Data Set, explain how the team can collect this sample. [2 marks]
(ii) Describe one disadvantage of quota sampling. [1 mark]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Finds IQR PI by correct expression or value for the lower or upper limit
B1
1.1b
Substitutes their IQR and obtains a value for the lower or upper limit PI by correct value for the lower or upper limit
M1
1.1a
Obtains correct lower and upper limits and selects mass 2040
Forms the equation for total probability PI by \(k = 0.08\) OE
M1
3.1b
Obtains the correct value of \(k\) OE
A1
1.1b
Forms a correct expression for \(\mathrm{P}(1 \leqslant N \lt 5)\) with or without \(k\) substituted e.g \(0.37 + 0.9k + 0.25 + 0.4k\) or \(0.62 + 1.3k\) or \(1 - 0.14 - 1.7k\) OE
(i) Identifies the LDS contains cars from 2 years or chooses 100 cars from each year or identifies the LDS contains 5 makes of car or chooses 40 from each make
Condone statement 20 of each car or 10 groups
M1
2.4
Concludes that 20 cars selected from each of the 5 makes of car for both years
R1
2.4
(2)
(ii) States that the disadvantage of quota sampling in LDS is that it is biased or not random or not proportionate.
E1
3.5b
(1)
(11 marks)
Typical solution
(i)
Select 20 of each of the five makes of car in each of the two years.
18 In a particular year, the height of a male athlete at the Summer Olympics has a mean 1.78 metres and standard deviation 0.23 metres.
The heights of 95% of male athletes are between 1.33 metres and 2.22 metres.
(a) Comment on whether a normal distribution may be suitable to model the height of a male athlete at the Summer Olympics in this particular year. [3 marks]
(b) You may assume that the height of a male athlete at the Summer Olympics may be modelled by a normal distribution with mean 1.78 metres and standard deviation 0.23 metres.
(i) Find the probability that the height of a randomly selected male athlete is 1.82 metres. [1 mark]
(ii) Find the probability that the height of a randomly selected male athlete is between 1.70 metres and 1.90 metres. [1 mark]
(iii) Two male athletes are chosen at random.
Calculate the probability that both of their heights are between 1.70 metres and 1.90 metres. [1 mark]
(c) The summarised data for the heights, \(h\) metres, of a random sample of 40 male athletes at the Winter Olympics is given below.\[\sum h = 69.2 \qquad \sum (h - \bar{h})^2 = 2.81\]
Use this data to calculate estimates of the mean and standard deviation of the heights of male athletes at the Winter Olympics. [3 marks]
(d) Using your answers from part (c), compare the heights of male athletes at the Summer Olympics and male athletes at the Winter Olympics. [2 marks]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Calculates 1.78 ± 2 × 0.23 or 1.78 ± 1.96 × 0.23 or calculates \(P(1.33 \lt x \lt 2.22)\) PI by 0.9469 or 0.947 or calculates \(\dfrac{1.33 - 1.78}{0.23}\) and \(\dfrac{2.22 - 1.78}{0.23}\)
M1
3.1b
Obtains 1.32 and 2.24 and states they are approximately 1.33 and 2.22 or obtains 1.33 and 2.23 and states they are approximately 1.33 and 2.22 or obtains 0.9469 or 0.947 and states is approximately 0.95 or obtains −1.96 and 1.91 and states are approximately −2 and 2
A1
2.4
Infers that the normal distribution may be suitable because height is continuous data and 95% of heights lies within two standard deviations of the mean or Infers that the normal distribution may be suitable because height is continuous data and 94.69% or 94.7% of heights lies between 1.33 and 2.22
Height is continuous data and 95% of heights lies within two standard deviations of the mean so normal may be a suitable model.
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) States 0
B1
1.2
(1)
(ii) Calculates the correct probability AWFW [0.335, 0.34]
B1
1.1b
(1)
(iii) Finds the value of their answer to (b)(ii) squared Their answer must be correct to at least 2sf
B1F
3.1b
(1)
Typical solution
(i)
0
(ii)
0.335
(iii)
\[0.335^2 = 0.112\]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Obtains 1.73 CAO Ignore missing or incorrect units
B1
1.1b
Uses the correct formula for standard deviation eg \(s = \sqrt{\dfrac{2.81}{39}}\)
Do not allow variance = \(\sqrt{\dfrac{2.81}{40}}\)
M1
1.1a
Obtains the correct standard deviation AWFW [0.265, 0.27] Allow if not labelled but if labelled, must be correct Ignore missing or incorrect units
A1
1.1b
(3)
Typical solution
Mean = 1.73
Standard deviation \(= \sqrt{\dfrac{2.81}{40}}\)
\(=\) 0.265
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Uses their mean and 1.78 to compare heights Comparison must include on average. Follow through their answer to part (c) Do not allow ‘general’ Allow statement that they’re about the same on average
E1F
2.2b
Uses their standard deviation and 0.23 to compare heights Comparison must include ‘varies’, ‘spread’ ‘disperse’ ‘more variation’ or ‘consistent’ Follow through their answer to part (c) Allow statement that they are about the same Do not allow comparison that includes ‘range’ or ‘variety’
E1F
2.2b
(2)
(11 marks)
Typical solution
Summer athletes are taller on average than Winter athletes.
Summer athletes’ heights are less varied than the heights of Winter athletes.
13 The table below is an extract from the Large Data Set.
Propulsion Type
Region
Engine Size
Mass
CO2
Particulate Emissions
2
London
1896
1533
154
0.04
2
North West
1896
1423
146
0.029
2
North West
1896
1353
138
0.025
2
South West
1998
1547
159
0.026
2
London
1896
1388
138
0.025
2
South West
1896
1214
130
0.011
2
South West
1896
1480
146
0.029
2
South West
1896
1413
146
0.024
2
South West
2496
1695
192
0.034
2
South West
1422
1251
122
0.025
2
South West
1995
2075
175
0.034
2
London
1896
1285
140
0.036
2
North West
1896
0
146
(a)
(i) Calculate the mean and standard deviation of CO2 emissions in the table. [2 marks]
(ii) Any value more than 2 standard deviations from the mean can be identified as an outlier.
Determine, using this definition of an outlier, if there are any outliers in this sample of CO2 emissions.
Fully justify your answer. [2 marks]
(b) Maria claims that the last line in the table must contain two errors.
Use your knowledge of the Large Data Set to comment on Maria’s claim. [2 marks]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Calculates correct value of mean AWRT 149
B1
1.1b
Calculates correct value of standard deviation AWRT 17.8 Accept AWRT 18.5
B1
1.1b
(2)
(ii) Calculates either their mean + 2 × standard deviation or their mean − 2 × standard deviation
M1
1.1b
Deduces that the CO2 value of 192 is the only outlier – must make a clear comparison and have both lower and upper outlier boundaries FT their mean and standard deviation
R1F
2.2a
(2)
Typical solution
(i)
Mean = 148.6
Standard deviation = 17.8
(ii)
148.6 + 2 × 17.8 = 184.2
148.6 − 2 × 17.8 = 113
192 > 184.2
192 is the only outlier
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Explains that the 0 value is an error because every car has a mass or there is a driver mass
E1
2.2b
Explains that the blank cell may not be an error as the LDS only has particulate emissions recorded for some cars
E1
2.2b
(2)
(6 marks)
Typical solution
The 0 value is an error because every car has a mass
The blank cell may not be an error as not all particulate emissions are recorded in the LDS
15 A political party is holding an election to choose a new leader.
A statistician within the party decides to sample 70 party members to find their opinions of the leadership candidates.
There are 4735 members under 30 years old and 8565 members 30 years old and over.
The statistician wants to use a sample of 70 party members in the survey.
He decides to use a random stratified sample.
(a) Calculate how many of each age group should be included in his sample. [2 marks]
(b) Explain how he could collect the random sample of members under 30 years old. [3 marks]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Uses correct proportion to find either category PI by correct answer Accept 24 or 25 for 24.9 and 45 or 46 for 45.1
M1
1.1a
Obtains the correct number of under 30 years old and 30 years old and over Accept 24 paired with 46 ISW
A1
1.1b
(2)
Typical solution
\[\frac{4735}{13\,300} \times 70 = 24.9\]
= 25 under 30 years old
\[\frac{8565}{13\,300} \times 70 = 45.1\]
= 45 above 30 years old
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Sets up enumerated population using valid numbering stating range used OE
E1
2.4
Explains how to obtain random numbers using calculator or number generator Must refer to replacement if using alternative suitable method eg hat or lottery
E1
2.4
Explains how to select their amount of people under 30 years old ensuring different numbers chosen OE Must state ignore repeats if using alternative suitable method eg hat or lottery
E1F
2.4
(3)
(5 marks)
Typical solution
Give each member under 30 years old a number from 1 to 4735
Generate random four-digit integers using a calculator
Continue until 25 different numbers have been identified and select the members given those numbers
12 The box plot below summarises the CO2 emissions, in g/km, for cars in the Large Data Set from the London and North West regions.
(a) Using the box plot, give one comparison of central tendency and one comparison of spread for the two regions. [2 marks]
(b) Jaspal, an environmental researcher, used all of the data in the Large Data Set to produce a statistical comparison of the CO2 and CO emissions in regions of England.
Using your knowledge of the Large Data Set, give two reasons why his conclusions may be invalid. [2 marks]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Compares correctly the medians and infers that London is greater Must use median only References to values (London 142 and North West 129), if used, must be correct
E1
2.2b
Compares correctly the ranges and infers that London is less or compares correctly the IQR/SIQR and infers that London’s IQR/SIQR is greater Must use range/IQR/SIQR only References to values, range (London 307 and North West 343) /IQR (London 49 and North West 37) /SIQR (London 24.5 and North West 18.5) if used, must be correct
E1
2.2b
(2)
Typical solution
Central tendency Median in London is greater than the median in the North West
Spread Range in London is less than the range in the North West
Notes
The SIQR values are London 24.5 and North West 18.5 (corrected from the printed mark scheme, which gives 143.5 and 136.5: these are the midpoints of the quartiles, not the semi-interquartile ranges).
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Gives one reason why his conclusion may be invalid
E1
2.4
Gives a second reason why his conclusion may be invalid Other reasons Some values for CO2 or CO are missing in the LDS LDS has outliers/skewed LDS uses CO2 or CO from cars only LDS on shows data for cars registered in 2002 and 2016 Values in the LDS were not exact or have been rounded Information not representative of England OE
States correctly that the mean would increase with a valid reason or increases to 162.2 Accept the mean would increase as the lower/lowest value has been removed or other valid reason
B1
2.2b
States correctly that the standard deviation would decrease with a valid reason or decreases to 5.03 Accept the standard deviation would decrease because the data is less spread out or other valid reason
B1
2.2b
(6 marks)
Typical solution
The mean would increase because Ann’s height is less than the mean
Standard deviation would decrease because Ann’s height is an outlier
18 In a region of England, the government decides to use an advertising campaign to encourage people to eat more healthily.
Before the campaign, the mean consumption of chocolate per person per week was known to be 66.5 g, with a standard deviation of 21.2 g
(a) After the campaign, the first 750 available people from this region were surveyed to find out their average consumption of chocolate.
(i) State the sampling method used to collect the survey. [1 mark]
(ii) Explain why this sample should not be used to conduct a hypothesis test. [1 mark]
(b) A second sample of 750 people revealed that the mean consumption of chocolate per person per week was 65.4 g
Investigate, at the 10% level of significance, whether the advertising campaign has decreased the mean consumption of chocolate per person per week.
Assume that an appropriate sampling method was used and that the consumption of chocolate is normally distributed with an unchanged standard deviation. [6 marks]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) States opportunistic (sampling). Accept opportunity/convenience.
B1
AO1.2
(ii) Explains that sample is not random.
E1
AO3.5b
Typical solution
(i)
Opportunistic sampling
(ii)
The sample is not random.
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
States both hypotheses correctly for one-tailed test
B1
AO2.5
Formulates the test statistic
M1
AO1.1a
Obtains the correct value of the test statistic
A1
AO1.1b
States the correct critical \(z\)-value OE
B1
AO1.1b
Infers H0 rejected CSO
A1
AO2.2b
Correctly concludes in context. (FT only available if first B1 and M1 scored).
16 A survey of 120 adults found that the volume, \(X\) litres per person, of carbonated drinks they consumed in a week had the following results:
\[\sum x = 165.6 \qquad \sum x^2 = 261.8\]
(a)
(i) Calculate the mean of \(X\). [1 mark]
(ii) Calculate the standard deviation of \(X\). [2 marks]
(b) Assuming that \(X\) can be modelled by a normal distribution find
(i) \(\mathrm{P}(0.5 \lt X \lt 1.5)\) [2 marks]
(ii) \(\mathrm{P}(X = 1)\) [1 mark]
(c) Determine with a reason, whether a normal distribution is suitable to model this data. [2 marks]
(d) It is known that the volume, \(Y\) litres per person, of energy drinks consumed in a week may be modelled by a normal distribution with standard deviation 0.21
Given that \(\mathrm{P}(Y \gt 0.75) = 0.10\), find the value of \(\mu\), correct to three significant figures. [4 marks]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Obtains the correct mean
B1
AO1.1b
(ii) Uses the correct formula for standard deviation
M1
AO1.1a
Obtains the correct standard deviation
A1
AO1.1b
Typical solution
(i)
1.38
(ii)
\[\sqrt{\frac{261.8}{120} - 1.38^2}\]
0.526 to 0.529
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Uses the model to calculate a normal probability
M1
AO3.4
Obtains correct probability
A1
AO1.1b
(ii) Recalls correct value of 0
B1
AO1.2
Typical solution
(i)
0.5417 to 0.5428
(ii)
0
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Calculates the value of mean – 3 x standard deviations
M1
AO1.1b
Concludes that model might be inappropriate as the value is less than 0
A1
AO2.2b
Typical solution
-0.1998 to -0.207
This is less than 0 and so model might not be appropriate
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Standardises appropriately and formalises a probability statement PI by fully correct equation
M1
AO3.1b
Obtains \(z\) value from inverse normal distribution \((\pm 1.2816)\)
M1
AO1.1a
Forms a correct equation using standardised result and \(z\) value
A1
AO1.1b
Solves the equation to find the correct value of \(\mu\)
13 The table below shows an extract from the Large Data Set.
Year
2011
2012
2013
2014
% change since 2011
Other takeaway food brought home
0
0
0
0
\(-29\)
Sarah claims that the \(-29\)% change since 2011 is incorrect, as there is no change between 2011 and 2014.
Using your knowledge of the Large Data Set to justify your answer, explain whether Sarah’s claim is correct. [3 marks]
Mark scheme
Scheme
Marks
AO
Explains that the actual recorded values for ‘Other takeaway food brought home’ are non-zero but have been rounded to the nearest whole number with reference to knowledge of the Large Data Set (could be implied) OE
E1
AO2.4
Explains that if unrounded numbers were used then the change could be calculated with reference to knowledge of the Large Data Set (could be implied) OE
E1
AO2.4
Deduces that Sarah’s claim is incorrect
R1
AO2.2a
(3 marks)
Typical solution
The values in the table are rounded to the nearest whole number so are actually non zero
They are available to a large number of decimal places in the data set, which, if used, would show that the -29% is correct
13 The table shows excerpts from the census data for Age Structure in 2001 and 2011 for four Local Authorities (LAs) in South West England.
Age
LA
Year
0 to 4
5 to 7
8 to 9
10 to 14
15
16 to 17
18 to 19
20 to 24
25 to 29
Bournemouth
2001 2011
8 171 10 275
5 103 4 862
3 579 2 999
8 752 8 399
1 681 1 732
3 255 3 517
4 289 6 141
12 901 17 130
11 785 14 935
City of Bristol
2001 2011
23 453 29 633
12 887 14 371
8 794 8 466
22 871 21 703
4 791 4 408
8 690 8 922
11 812 13 711
34 798 44 371
32 001 40 752
Plymouth
2001 2011
13 213 15 336
8 535 7 956
6 091 4 991
16 078 13 645
3 106 2 954
6 103 6 011
7 454 8 839
17 245 24 343
14 885 18 888
Swindon
2001 2011
11 392 14 083
7 194 7 551
4 862 4 722
12 121 12 433
2 178 2 593
4 337 5 141
3 798 4 690
10 212 12 859
13 816 15 075
Researchers want to investigate whether there is evidence that those people who were residents in these LAs in 2001 were still resident in the same LAs in 2011.
(a) One researcher suggests that, for each of the LAs, they should compare the sum of the data for 2001 for Age 15 to 19 with the data for 2011 for Age 25 to 29.
Explain why this comparison is relevant. [1]
(b) The census data also includes data for the following age ranges:
Age
30 to 44
45 to 59
60 to 64
65 to 74
75 to 84
85 to 89
90 +
Explain why none of these data ranges are helpful in this context. [1]
(c) The data for one of these four LAs show that some of the 0 to 4 year olds living in that LA in 2001 are definitely no longer living there in 2011.
Explain which LA this is. [1]
(d) One of the researchers says that there has been little movement in or out of Bournemouth between 2001 and 2011 for those who were aged 5 to 7 in 2001.
(i) Use values from the table to show that this statement is not contradicted by the data. [2]
(ii) Explain why the statement is not necessarily correct. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Those who were in the ranges 15 to 19 in 2001 were in the range 25 to 29 in 2011
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: Accept e.g.:
“these ranges are the same width and 10 years apart”
“will include the same cohort for comparison”
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
None of the given ranges provide an appropriate pair of groups for comparison because the only pair that are two corresponding ranges 10 years apart are 65-74 and 75-84, where numbers will be decreasing.
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: Accept e.g.:
“too old”
“not a stable group for comparison”
“there are not two [appropriate] ranges that are 10 years apart [and non-overlapping etc.]”
“ageing population means that the number of residents will be decreasing”
“ranges of 14[or 15] years are not useful for comparison” [as not everyone will have moved to the next class after 10]
But not “age gaps too large” or “classes too wide” B0
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Bristol because \((2011, 10\text{ to }14) \lt (2001, 0\text{ to }4)\) or \(21703 \lt 23453\) or “the population of 10-14 in 2011 is less than the population of 0-4 in 2001”
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: Bristol stated and explanation in words or values given (must refer to ‘decrease’ or ‘less’ or provide an inequality oe). If values are quoted then they may be rounded (to 2sf or better) but must be correct. Accept e.g.
Decrease in population of 1750
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Little change in overall numbers
B1
2.3
\(5103 \to 5249\)
B1
1.1
[2]
(ii) Individuals may have moved out and been replaced by others
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
(d)(i)
B1: For a correct statement in words or symbols. Accept e.g.
“the population is approximately the same”
“the population has only gone up slightly”
(NB candidates who obtain incorrect values could score B1B0)
B1: For correctly using correct values from the table e.g.
Scale factor 1.03.
Accept 5103 and 5249 seen anywhere
Accept \(1732 + 3517\) for 5249 (ISW incorrect addition)
The statement \(5103 \approx 5249\) scores B1B1.
(d)(ii)
B1: Or equivalent, e.g. may not be the same people Accept e.g.
“could have been large movement in and [equally] large movement out”
9 Some students in a year-group took two tests, Test 1 and Test 2. The maximum mark in each test was 120. The students’ marks are illustrated in the cumulative frequency diagram. The diagram is reproduced in the Printed Answer Booklet.
(a) All the students in the year-group took Test 1, but some students missed Test 2.
State the number of students who missed Test 2. [1]
(b) Find an estimate of the number of students whose marks for Test 1 were in the range 45 to 65 inclusive. [2]
(c) The final parts of the graphs are horizontal.
For Test 1, explain what this means about the results. [1]
(d) It is required that the number of students obtaining grade A* should be the same on both tests. The minimum mark for grade A* on Test 2 was 76.
Find the minimum mark for grade A* on Test 1. [1]
A teacher commented that the median marks on both tests were very similar. This suggests that, on average, the levels of difficulty on both tests were about the same.
(e) Use the cumulative frequency diagram to make another comparison between Test 1 and Test 2 about the easier questions on both papers. [1]
The marks for Test 1 are summarised in the table.
Test 1 mark
\(\leqslant 29\)
30–39
40–49
50–59
60–69
70–79
\(\geqslant 80\)
Frequency
0
10
40
60
33
7
0
(f)
(i) Find estimates of the mean and standard deviation of the Test 1 marks. [3]
(ii) Use your answers to part (f)(i) to comment on whether there may be any outliers amongst the Test 1 marks. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
4
B1
3.1a
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
[Number of students scoring \(\leqslant 45\)] \(= 28\) [Number of students scoring \(\leqslant 65\)] \(= 130\)
M1
3.1a
[Number of students scoring between 45-65 is:] \(130 - 28 = 102\)
A1
1.1
[2]
Notes
M1: Two appropriate values in the following ranges (selected and used): Value in range [26,32] Value in range [128,134]
A1: Value in range [96,108]
If no working seen, award 2/2 marks for a correct answer in [96,108]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
No student scored more than 78 marks
B1
2.2a
[1]
Notes
B1: Must include a value in range [76,80] Condone ‘the maximum mark [scored by a student] was 78’ but not ‘the maximum possible mark was…’
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
69
B1
2.2a
[1]
Notes
B1: Value in range [68,70]
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
The easier questions on Test 1 are easier than the easier questions on Test 2.
B1
3.2a
[1]
Notes
B1: Must be referring to the easier questions but could refer to e.g. ‘minimum mark’ or ‘starting score’ or ‘bottom of graph’ Accept e.g.:
The easier questions on Test 2 are harder [than the easier questions on Test 1]
Lower-attaining (weaker) students scored better on Test 1
On Test 2 some people have marks lower than… whereas on Test 1 the minimum mark was…
Test 1 had more easier questions (or Test 2 had fewer easier questions)
(ii) \(53.6 \pm 2 \times 9.66\) [\(= 34.3\) and \(72.9\)]
M1
1.1
There may be outliers [in the 30-39 and 70-79 classes].
A1
2.2b
[2]
Notes
(f)(i)
M1: Correct method for mean soi, using attempted midpts soi (allow incorrect midpoints but not use of boundary values) Should see midpoints multiplied by frequencies and summation implied. NB \(\Sigma x = 8045\), \(\Sigma x^2 = 445467.5\) May be implied by correct answer (A1)
A1: awrt 53.6
B1: awrt 9.66
(f)(ii)
M1: FT their (f)(i) i.e. \(\bar{x} \pm 2 \times s\). Allow this mark for correct values seen.
A1: Dependent on correct values to 2sf (awrt 34 and 73) Accept “there are outliers at both ends” Condone ‘there are outliers’
SCB1 for \(53.6 \pm 3 \times 9.66 = 24.6\) and \(82.6\) (3sf) so no outliers (1/2)
12 Ryan has to choose one student at random from a group of 11 students. Ryan makes the choice using a single throw of two fair, six-sided dice, together with the following table.
Total score on the two dice
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Student chosen
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
(a) Show that this sampling method is not random. [2]
Sasha suggests making the choice using a single throw of two fair, six-sided dice, together with the following table.
Scores on the two dice
1, 1
1, 2
2, 1
1, 3
3, 1
1, 4
4, 1
1, 5
5, 1
1, 6
6, 1
Student chosen
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
Ryan says that a further instruction is needed to complete the method.
(b)
(i) Write a suitable further instruction. [1]
(ii) Using Sasha’s method, state the probability of choosing student E. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Two correct, unequal probabilities: e.g. \(\mathrm{P}(2) = \frac{1}{36},\ \mathrm{P}(3) = \frac{2}{36}\)
M1
2.4
Probabilities not equal (and hence not random).
A1
3.5b
[2]
Notes
M1: Must be seen. Condone a correct statement e.g. “The probability of obtaining 2 is not the same as the probability of getting 3” – must refer to specific scores, need not compute probabilities (but if given these must be correct).
A1: A generalised conclusion must be present:
Allow “probabilities are not the same”
May come at the beginning e.g. “the chance of each student being chosen is not equal because…”
Alternative using combinations
Scheme
Marks
Demonstrate that there are more ways of obtaining one answer than another e.g. “there are more ways of obtaining 4 than 2”
M1
(Hence student C is more likely to be chosen than student A) and therefore the probabilities are not equal (and hence not random).
A1
M1: Must be seen. Must refer to specific scores but need not compute the number of combinations/ways (but if given these must be correct).
A1: A generalised conclusion must be present:
Accept “student __ is more likely to be chosen than student __, therefore it is not random”
Accept “some scores are more likely than others”
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Throw repeatedly until one of these pairs is obtained
B1
3.5c
[1]
(ii) \(\dfrac{1}{11}\)
B1
3.4
[1]
Notes
(b)(i)B1: Any valid correction to the method, e.g.:
“If obtain a pair not included, throw again.”
“make the two dice distinguishable” (because 1,3 and 3,1 have different students) or “throw in order”
Condone extending to the entire sample space (e.g. “assign a further 2 pairs to each student and the remaining 3 to ‘throw again’”) but the method must remain random.
11 The chart below represents the percentage increases (PI) in the numbers of employees using four different methods of travel to work from 2001 and 2011, in five different Local Authorities (LAs) in Wales.
(a)
(i) State, with a reason, which of the four methods of transport probably had the greatest overall percentage growth in these LAs between 2001 and 2011. [1]
(ii) Explain why your answer to part (a)(i) is not definite. [1]
(b) A student suggests that the chart can be used to estimate the total percentage change for these methods of transport in each individual LA. Give two reasons why the student is likely to be wrong. [2]
(c) A student wants to investigate the trend from 2001 to 2011 in numbers using underground, metro, light rail or tram. The actual numbers of people using these methods in these LAs in 2001 were all less than 50 (and in one case was 4). Explain why this means that the chart does not provide very helpful information for the student. [1]
(d) Let \(D\) denote the number of people in the Vale of Glamorgan whose usual method of travel to work is “Driving a car or van”, and let \(H\) denote the number of people in the Vale of Glamorgan who “Work mainly at or from home”. Between 2001 and 2011 the increase in \(D\) was approximately 3.5 times the increase in \(H\). Use this fact and the information in the chart to estimate the ratio \(D : H\) in 2001. [3]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Train, because all increases over 50%
B1
2.2b
[1]
(ii) The chart does not show where in the range each value is Or We do not know the (relative) sizes of each LA
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
(a)(i)B1: Must specify Train and give a reason. Any sensible reason related to chart, e.g.:
“Train has two of highest category and three of the 2nd highest”
May refer to colours (e.g. dark, darker, darkest)
(a)(ii)B1: Any sensible reason relating to either ‘exact values’ or ‘actual/relative sizes of each LA’. Examples:
“we do not know exact values because the data is grouped” B1
“grouped” (without reference to exact values) B0
“increases could be much higher than 90%” B1
“low % of high number may be greater than high % of low number” B1
“not all workers accounted for” B0
“may be errors in data” B0
NB throughout this question, do not credit reasons that don’t relate to the question or that attempt to criticise the data set (rather than the chart/presentation and reasoning from it).
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Do not know the initial proportions of each mode of transport
B1
2.3
Do not know the exact % increases
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
B1 B1: Any 2 distinct correct reasons. Examples:
“% ranges are wide” B1
“Do not know the upper limit for +90% PI” B1
“Do not know values within -10 to +10%” B1
“Do not know baseline values for each mode” B1
“size of the LAs” (not relevant here) B0
Do not credit criticism of underlying data or grouping of modes of transport (e.g. walking/working from home) B0
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(Small) changes in these small numbers will lead to large % increases (which may give a misleading impression of the overall trend).
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: Must refer to numbers or absolute values, not just %, e.g.:
“actual increases small (so hard to see trend)” B1
Do not credit references to grouped data / exact values here (not relevant) B0
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Increase in \(D\) is 20% and in \(H\) is 40%
M1
3.1a
\(0.2D_{01} \approx 3.5 \times 0.4H_{01}\)
M1
1.1
\(D : H\) is \(7 : 1\)
A1
2.2b
[3]
Notes
M1: M1 for sight of midpoints: 20% and 40%
Allow 0.2 and 0.4
Condone 1.2 and 1.4
Alternatively may see comparison of corresponding lower and upper bounds e.g. 10% -> 30% and 30% -> 50% (this leads to an estimate of 8.15) – M1
M1: For setting up two expressions and correctly using 3.5 (must be on the correct side). Do not accept 1.2, 1.4 here (NB \(3.5 \times 0.4 = 1.4\)) Allow = instead of \(\approx\) Must be using two estimates for midpoints or considering both sets of lower/upper bounds
A1: Accept 3.5:0.5. If lower and upper bounds used, accept 8(.15):1 Need not be given as a ratio: accept \(\frac{D_{01}}{H_{01}} \approx 7\) oe but not \(D = 7H\) Note that 7:2 often comes from not using any information from the chart (M0M0A0)
13 The scatter diagram uses information about all the Local Authorities (LAs) in the UK, taken from the 2011 census.
For each LA it shows the percentage (\(x\)) of employees who used public transport to travel to work and the percentage (\(y\)) who used motorised private transport.
“Public transport” includes train, bus, minibus, coach, underground, metro and light rail. “Motorised private transport” includes car, van, motorcycle, scooter, moped, taxi and passenger in a car or van.
(a) Most of the points in the diagram lie on or near the line with equation \(x + y = k\), where \(k\) is a constant.
(i) Give a possible value for \(k\). [1]
(ii) Hence give an approximate value for the percentage of employees who either worked from home or walked or cycled to work. [1]
(b) The average amount of fuel used per person per day for travelling to work in any LA is denoted by F. Consider the two groups of LAs where the percentages using motorised private transport are highest and lowest.
(i) Using only the information in the diagram, suggest, with a reason, which of these two groups will have greater values of F than the other group. [1]
A student says that it is not possible to give a reliable answer to part (b)(i) without some further information.
(ii) Suggest two kinds of further information which would enable a more reliable answer to be given. [2]
(c) Points \(A\) and \(B\) in the diagram are the most extreme outliers. Use their positions on the diagram to answer the following questions about the two LAs represented by these two points.
(i) The two LAs share a certain characteristic. Describe, with a justification, this characteristic. [2]
(ii) The environments in these two LAs are very different. Describe, with a justification, this difference. [2]
(d) A student says that it is difficult to extract detailed information from the scatter diagram. Explain whether you agree with this criticism. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) \(k = 70\) to 80 inclusive
B1
1.2
[1]
(ii) \(100 -\) their \(k\)
B1FT
2.2a
[1]
Notes
(a)(ii)
B1FT: Strictly FT their \(k\) (i.e. this must be \(100 -\) their \(k\) only)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) The group with highest usage of private (motorised) transport (top left), because private transport uses more fuel than public transport (for the same travel distance, per person).
B1
2.2b
[1]
(ii) e.g. Lengths of journeys (or distance travelled) and
B1
2.4
e.g. how many people travel in each vehicle used (or ‘occupancy’ of each mode)
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
(b)(i)
B1: For a clear explanation that must both identify the group unambiguously (e.g. ‘top left’, ‘least public transport use’) and give a reason. Accept equivalent justifications e.g. ‘each individual uses more fuel’
(b)(ii)
B1 B1: For two sensible distinct suggestions. Acceptable answers include:
The type or amount of fuel used (by different modes of transport)
Proportion or usage of Electric Vehicles
Types of vehicle used (or available)
Proportion of the different modes of transport within each category
The occupancy of each mode (or e.g. car sharing)
Proportion of full-time vs part-time working patterns
Do not accept:
Population size (because \(F\) is per person)
Number of those not in work (because \(F\) is for employees)
References to emissions e.g. ‘given off’ (because \(F\) is the amount of fuel used)
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Large percentage walk/cycle/work from home
B1
2.2b
Small area
B1
2.4
[2]
(ii) \(A\) is rural, \(B\) is urban
B1
2.2b
Public transport is absent in \(A\) but used in \(B\) or, eg, Those in \(B\) who don’t walk, don’t use cars, so there is probably a lot of traffic, so \(B\) is urban. No public transport in \(A\) so \(A\) is rural
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
(c)(i)
B1: For the shared characteristic (any of walk/cycle/work from home). Condone ‘these have the lowest total proportion using public or motorised private transport combined’ but do not accept only ‘lower percentage using motorised private transport’ or ‘lower percentage using public transport’ – need both
B1: For a justification (must be related to the LA). Acceptable answers include:
‘less need to travel to work’
‘shorter journeys’
‘better walking/cycling infrastructure’
But not just ‘more work from home’ (this is the characteristic)
(\(A\) is Scilly Isles, \(B\) is City of London)
(c)(ii)
B1: B1 for identifying the difference in environment (must make a comparison e.g. ‘\(A\) is more rural than \(B\)’). Accept clearly equivalent statements e.g. ‘city’ or ‘countryside’
B1: B1 for justification. Cannot just restate the data so do not accept e.g. ‘\(A\) has low public transport use’ – must give a justification as to why this might be. Accept e.g. ‘less availability of public transport’ Other sensible answers may be seen e.g. ‘motorised private transport is almost absent in \(B\) but more widely used in \(A\)’
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Some points are too close together to read
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
B1: Must make a specific criticism of the graph related to reading values. Acceptable answers include:
‘the scale is not precise enough to read detailed values’
‘closely clustered points mean it is hard to read’
‘there are no gridlines so cannot read exact values’
Do not accept generic statements such as ‘the data may not be accurate’ or references to information not included on the graph.
9 A school contains 500 students in years 7 to 11 and 250 students in years 12 and 13. A random sample of 20 students is selected to represent the school at a parents’ evening. The number of students in the sample who are from years 12 and 13 is denoted by \(X\).
(a) State a suitable binomial model for \(X\). [1]
Use your model to answer the following.
(b)
(i) Write down an expression for \(\mathrm{P}(X = x)\). [1]
(ii) State, in set notation, the values of \(x\) for which your expression is valid. [1]
(c) Find \(\mathrm{P}(5 \leqslant X \leqslant 9)\). [2]
(d) State one disadvantage of using a random sample in this context. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\mathrm{B}\left(20, \frac{1}{3}\right)\)
B1
3.3
[1]
Notes
B1: Allow ‘\(n = 20, p = \frac{1}{3}\)’ or just \(\left(20, \frac{1}{3}\right)\). Accept \(p = 0.\dot{3}\) but not 0.333
(ii) \(\{x : x \in \mathbb{Z},\ 0 \leqslant x \leqslant 20\}\)
B1FT
1.2
[1]
Notes
(b)(i)
B1FT: FT their values of \(n\) and \(p\) and allow \(\dbinom{20}{x}\) as alternative to \({}^{20}\mathrm{C}_x\) (If decimals used both must be correct to 3sf)
(b)(ii)
B1FT: FT their ‘20’ only Any acceptable alternative in set notation Indication that \(x\) is an integer must be present (but condone ‘integer’ or ‘whole number’ or \(x \in \mathbb{N}\))
M1: Condone \(\mathrm{P}(X \leqslant 9) - \mathrm{P}(X \leqslant 5)\), or \(0.90810 - 0.29721\) or 0.611 May be implied by correct working or answer. Allow sum of \(\mathrm{P}(X = x)\) for \(x\) from 5 to 9.
A1:BC cao
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
May include too many from one year and too few from another year
B1
3.5b
[1]
Notes
B1: For an explanation (which must be in context) showing clear recognition that a random sample (of this size) would not be representative across the year groups. Acceptable similar answers in context include:
‘should include roughly equal numbers from each year’
‘not representative of each year group’
‘may not include students from every year group’
Do not accept ‘may end up with more students from Y7-11 than from Y12-13’ (because a representative sample would have this) Must be in context – so do not accept generic answers without context such as just: ‘It might be biased’ or ‘It’s not representative’ or ‘it should be a stratified sample’
Do not accept answers solely referring to the suitability of the individual students within the sample to represent the school
8 The stem-and-leaf diagram shows the heights, in centimetres, of 15 plants.
0
2
1
0
2
4
3
0 2 4 9
4
1 2 4 7 9
5
3 7
6
2
Key: 2 | 5 means 25 cm.
(a) Draw a box-and-whisker plot to illustrate the data. [4]
A statistician intends to analyse the data, but wants to ignore any outliers before doing so.
(b) Discuss briefly whether there are any heights in the diagram which the statistician should ignore. [3]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Median = 41
B1
1.1
Quartiles = 30, 49
B1
1.1
B1FT
1.2
B1
1.2
[4]
Notes
B1: (Median) Stated or shown on diagram (need not be labelled)
B1: (Quartiles) Stated or shown on diagram (need not be labelled)
B1FT: Correct diagram, FT their median & quartiles & correct end points shown (2, 62) – all correct to +/−0.5 (Must see a box with a vertical line and two whiskers)
B1: An appropriate linear scale, consistently labelled. (This mark can only be awarded if a box-and-whisker plot is drawn)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Using \(Q_1 - 1.5 \times IQR\) or \(Q_3 + 1.5 \times IQR\)
M1: Attempting to calculate either with their quartiles (may be implied by 1.5 or 77.5)
A1: Must see both correct calculations or both 1.5 and 77.5
A1: www (so must be from correct calculations) Accept a single statement of ‘no outliers’ following correct calculations oe e.g. ‘no heights should be ignored’
Alternative using mean and sd
Scheme
Marks
\(\mu \pm 2\sigma = 37.7 \pm 2 \times 16.0\)
M1
\(\mu + 2\sigma = 69.6\) (3sf) Hence no (upper) outliers
10 The table shows the age structure of usual residents of 18 Local Authorities (LAs) in the North West region of the UK in 2011.
Local Authority
Age 0 to 17
Age 18 to 24
Age 25 to 64
Age 65 and over
A
26.20%
9.06%
51.81%
12.92%
B
23.32%
8.99%
52.32%
15.37%
C
22.24%
8.96%
52.56%
16.23%
D
22.67%
8.10%
53.27%
15.96%
E
20.70%
7.77%
54.77%
16.76%
F
18.14%
6.51%
51.13%
24.21%
G
18.96%
14.20%
48.51%
18.33%
H
19.06%
14.79%
52.12%
14.04%
I
25.15%
9.04%
51.16%
14.65%
J
22.93%
8.81%
52.22%
16.04%
K
21.48%
13.98%
50.82%
13.73%
L
23.98%
9.20%
52.26%
14.56%
M
21.67%
11.19%
52.94%
14.19%
N
17.82%
6.01%
51.93%
24.23%
O
22.83%
7.30%
53.86%
16.01%
P
21.76%
8.28%
54.03%
15.93%
Q
21.42%
8.43%
53.90%
16.25%
R
18.61%
7.33%
49.35%
24.71%
Percentage of residents
(a) Without reference to any other columns, explain how you would use only the columns for the age ranges 0 to 17 and 18 to 24 to decide whether an LA might be one of the following.
(i) An LA that includes a university [1]
(ii) An LA that attracts young couples to live [1]
(iii) An LA that attracts retired people to live [1]
(b) Using your answers to part (a), identify the following.
(i) Four LAs that might include a university [1]
(ii) Three LAs that might be attractive to retired people [1]
(c) Explain why your answer to part (b)(ii), based only on the columns for the age ranges 0 to 17 and 18 to 24, may not be reliable. [1]
(d) The lower quartile, median and upper quartile of the percentages in the column “Age 65 and over” are 14.56%, 15.99% and 16.76% respectively. Use this information to comment on your answers to part (b)(ii) and part (c). [2]
In a magazine article, a councillor plans to describe a typical LA in the North West region. He wants to quote the average percentage of residents aged 65 or over.
(e) The mean of the percentages in the column “Age 65 and over” is 16.90%. Use this information, and the information given in part (d), to explain whether the median or the mean better represents the data in the column “Age 65 and over”. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) High(er) or increased proportion 18–24
B1
2.2b
[1]
(ii) High(er) or increased proportion either/both
B1
2.2b
[1]
(iii) Low(er) or decreased proportion either/both
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
All parts of Q10: Allow “percentage” or “value” or “number” or “rate” etc for proportion in all parts of qu 10
(a)(i) B1: eg “many 18-24” Ignore any LA mentioned Ignore extras only if they don’t contradict High 18-24 only
(a)(ii) B1: or high proportion of younger. Ignore any LA mentioned Ignore extras
(a)(iii) B1: or low proportion of younger. Ignore any LA mentioned eg “LA F because low % in younger ages” B1 Ignore extras
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) G, H, K, M
B1
2.2b
[1]
(ii) F, N, R
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
All parts of Q10: Allow “percentage” or “value” or “number” or “rate” etc for proportion in all parts of qu 10
(b)(i) B1: No extras or omissions
(b)(ii) B1: No extras or omissions
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Imply need to consider other age range(s) Examples: May be a large % of 25-64 (or 65+) Some LAs have low 0-17 and 18-24 and 65+ Low 0-17 & 18-24 does not mean high 65+
Need to consider other factors or anomalies
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
All parts of Q10: Allow “percentage” or “value” or “number” or “rate” etc for proportion in all parts of qu 10
B1: Low 0-17 & 18-24 not \(\Rightarrow\) attractive to older High % of young people does not necessarily imply low % of older people Older people may want live near young relatives
Eg May be reasons for low % younger people eg no schools
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
State all 3 LAs are > 1.5×IQR above UQ
B1
1.2
Confirms F, N, R (implied) despite (c)
B1
2.2a
[2]
Notes
All parts of Q10: Allow “percentage” or “value” or “number” or “rate” etc for proportion in all parts of qu 10
NB. No ft for either mark
B1: Or \(16.76 + 1.5 \times (16.76 - 14.56)\) \((= 20.06)\) Ignore attempt at lower limit
B1: Independent mark. But must mention (c)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Mean > UQ
B1*
1.1
Median better
B1dep
2.2b
[2]
Notes
All parts of Q10: Allow “percentage” or “value” or “number” or “rate” etc for proportion in all parts of qu 10
or mean is in 4th quartile Ignore all else Not Mean skewed by F, N, R so median better Not Median not skewed by F, N, R so better Not Mean because need take account of outliers (or F,N,R)
9 The heights, in centimetres, of a random sample of 150 plants of a certain variety were measured. The results are summarised in the histogram.
One of the 150 plants is chosen at random, and its height, \(X\) cm, is noted.
(a) Show that \(\mathrm{P}(20 \lt X \lt 30) = 0.147\), correct to 3 significant figures. [2]
Sam suggests that the distribution of \(X\) can be well modelled by the distribution \(\mathrm{N}(40, 100)\).
(b)
(i) Give a brief justification for the use of the normal distribution in this context. [1]
(ii) Give a brief justification for the choice of the parameter values 40 and 100. [2]
(c) Use Sam’s model to find \(\mathrm{P}(20 \lt X \lt 30)\). [1]
Nina suggests a different model. She uses the midpoints of the classes to calculate estimates, \(m\) and \(s\), for the mean and standard deviation respectively, in centimetres, of the 150 heights. She then uses the distribution \(\mathrm{N}(m, s^2)\) as her model.
(d) Use Nina’s model to find \(\mathrm{P}(20 \lt X \lt 30)\). [4]
(e)
(i) Complete the table in the Printed Answer Booklet to show the probabilities obtained from Sam’s model and Nina’s model. [2]
\(x\)
< 20
20 to 30
30 to 35
35 to 40
40 to 45
45 to 50
50 to 60
> 60
Histogram
0.027
0.147
0.153
0.187
0.193
0.147
0.133
0.013
\(\mathrm{N}(40, 100)\)
0.023
0.150
0.191
0.136
0.023
\(\mathrm{N}(m, s^2)\)
0.030
0.153
0.189
0.130
0.023
(ii) By considering the different ranges of values of \(X\) given in the table, discuss how well the two models fit the original distribution. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Area of 20-30 block ÷ total area
M1
1.2
\(= \dfrac{110}{750}\) or \(\dfrac{22}{150}\) or \(\dfrac{4.4}{30}\) \(= 0.147\) (3 sf) (AG)
A1
1.1
[2]
Notes
M1:attempted, using any units, eg small squares or cm2
A1: Correct calculation seen and answer 0.147 seen Not any method starting with 0.147, eg \(0.147 \times 150 = 22.05\)
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) Roughly bell-shaped
B1
2.2b
[1]
(ii) Roughly symmetrical about \(x = 40\), or area to left of 40 \(\approx\) area to right of 40 or the peak is at 40 or 40 is in the middle
B1
2.4
\(70 - 40 \approx 3\sigma\), hence \(\sigma \approx 10\) or most values within 20 of mean, so \(20 \approx 2\sigma\) or (Area within \(40 \pm 10\))/total eg 510/750 or \(102/150 = 0.68\) or \(\approx \frac{2}{3}\)
B1
3.3
[2]
Notes
(b)(i)
B1: or Roughly symmetrical and peaks in middle or has one peak and tails off at each end, or drops off either side All 3 of these must be seen (except “Bell-shaped” scores B1) Not “Shape is like normal curve” Ignore all else
(b)(ii)
B1: or calculate mean and obtain \(\frac{5915}{150}\) or 39.4 Allow 40 has the highest frequency or frequency density Ignore all else
B1: or calculate sd and obtain 10.3 Most data is within \(6\sigma\) Must see correct fraction and \(\approx \frac{2}{3}\), or 68% or 0.68
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
0.136 (3 sf)
B1
1.1
[1]
Notes
B1:BC
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(m = 39.4\) or \(\dfrac{5915}{150}\) or \(\dfrac{1183}{30}\),
B1
3.1a
\(s = 10.3\) (3 sf) or \(s^2 = 106\) (3 sf)
B1
1.1
0.150 or 0.151 or 0.152 (3 sf) Allow 0.15
B2
3.4 1.1
[4]
Notes
B1: Allow \(39.1 \leqslant m \leqslant 39.7\) Ignore method BC
B1: Allow \(105.5 \leqslant s^2 \leqslant 108.5\) or \(10.27 \leqslant s \leqslant 10.42\) Ignore method (Use of denominator \(n\) or \((n - 1)\) is OK for full marks) OR if neither mark scored, M1 for attempting find frequencies or areas (NOT heights) or at least five of these seen: 4, 22, 23, 28, 29, 22, 20, 2 or 20, 110, 115, 140, 145, 110, 100, 10
B2: cao Correct with unclear or no working; B1B1B1B1 or B1 for 0.145 to 0.158
NB No retrospective marks if 0.151 seen in table for (e)(i)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i)
\(x\)
< 20
20 to 30
30 to 35
35 to 40
40 to 45
45 to 50
50 to 60
> 60
Histogram
0.027
0.147
0.153
0.187
0.193
0.147
0.133
0.013
\(\mathrm{N}(40, 100)\)
0.023
0.136
0.150
0.191
0.191
0.150
0.136
0.023
\(\mathrm{N}(m, s^2)\)
0.030
0.151
0.153
0.189
0.183
0.142
0.130
0.023
(the values to be found are in bold)
B1 B1
1.1 3.4
[2]
(ii) Nina's model better fit for lower values of \(X\) Nina's model better fit for any ranges < 40 Nina’s model less good fit for 40-45 (or >60)
B1
3.5a
Sam's model better fit for higher values Sam's model better fit for any ranges > 40 Sam’s model less good fit for 20-30 (or >60)
B1
3.5a
[2]
Notes
(e)(i)
No FT
B1 for middle row correct \(\pm 0.001\) NB
B1 for bottom row correct \(\pm 0.003\) NB
(e)(ii)
Allow “more accurate” or “less accurate” or similar
BUT SC: “Both less good fit for >60” alone: B1 only NOT “Both are fairly good fit” B0B0 Ignore all else NB No ft
13 The four pie charts illustrate the numbers of employees using different methods of travel in four Local Authorities in 2011.
(a) State, with reasons, which of the four Local Authorities is most likely to be a rural area with many hills. [2]
(b) Explain why pie charts are more suitable for answering part (a) than bar charts showing the same data. [1]
(c) Two of the Local Authorities represent urban areas.
(i) State with a reason which two Local Authorities are likely to be urban. [2]
(ii) One urban Local Authority introduced a Park-and-Ride service in 2006. Users of this service drive to the edge of the urban area and then use buses to take them into the centre of the area. A student claims that a comparison of the corresponding pie charts for 2001 (not shown) and 2011 would enable them to identify which Local Authority this was. State with a reason whether you agree with the student. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
A: High private and low public OR B: Low bicycle and low public OR B: Low bicycle and high private OR C: Low bicycle and high private
B2
[2]
Notes
Allow B1 for A or B or C with one correct factor only. Ignore else
All answers can be implied Ignore all else
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
Pie charts allow comparison of proportions Pie charts show proportions oe Ignore all else
B1
[1]
Notes
NOT: Bar charts don’t show proportions unless also state pies do. Assume “They” means pie charts. NOT: It’s easier to compare data Pie charts don’t easily show which is greatest Allow percentages instead of proportions
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
(i) C and D
B1
Larger (or high or most) proportion public transport Can be implied. Ignore all else
B1
[2]
(ii) LDS says “The method of travel used is for the longest part, by distance, of the usual journey to work” Correct answers therefore should assume users of P&R will report only private, not public
Method of travel is the type used for the longest part of the journey
B1
Most people using Park-and-Ride would still say they were using private transport.
B1
[2]
Notes
(c)(i)
B1: Both, no others
B1: Dep applied to at least one of C and D, even if other LA mentioned
B-marks are independent
(c)(ii)
B1: "Disagree" may be implied
B1: independent Ignore all else
Scheme
Marks
People will still have to travel by car, so the results won’t be very different
B2
Alternatives, assuming (incorrectly) users of P&R will report both methods or just public:
Scheme
Marks
Public transport increase or private decrease “Agree” may be implied. Ignore all else
B1 B0
P&R will result in more people using private transport, so this will show an increase Not just “Increase in private” without justification
B1 B0
Users of P&R will use both public and private, so not clear
B1 B0
No, because other changes might have been made that affect the proportions.
B2
If P&R users report both, or just public, then yes, public will show increase
B2
Recognition of issue as to whether P&R users should report private or public Hence unclear whether change will show
B1 B1
Other sensible answers may be seen not covered in this MS
11 Zac is planning to write a report on the music preferences of the students at his college. There is a large number of students at the college.
(a) State one reason why Zac might wish to obtain information from a sample of students, rather than from all the students. [1]
(b) Amaya suggests that Zac should use a sample that is stratified by school year. Give one advantage of this method as compared with random sampling, in this context. [1]
Zac decides to take a random sample of 60 students from his college. He asks each student how many hours per week, on average, they spend listening to music during term. From his results he calculates the following statistics.
Mean
Standard deviation
Median
Lower quartile
Upper quartile
21.0
4.20
20.5
18.0
22.9
(c) Sundip tells Zac that, during term, she spends on average 30 hours per week listening to music. Discuss briefly whether this value should be considered an outlier. [3]
(d) Layla claims that, during term, each student spends on average 20 hours per week listening to music. Zac believes that the true figure is higher than 20 hours. He uses his results to carry out a hypothesis test at the 5% significance level. Assume that the time spent listening to music is normally distributed with standard deviation 4.20 hours. Carry out the test. [7]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
Population large oe
B1
[1]
Notes
or, eg Would take too long to contact all students. NOT “Easier”
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
eg: Includes students from all years (or ages) Numbers in years in correct proportions Different years might like different music
B1
[1]
Notes
or: Different years may have different numbers of students
NOT “It’s more representative” or “Takes all students into account” “You get a range of people” “It avoids bias”
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
\(21 + 2 \times 4.2 = 29.4\)
B1
\(22.9 + 1.5(22.9 - 18.0) = 30.25\)
B1
Unclear whether 30 is an outlier
B1
[3]
Notes
B1: Allow “30 is more than 2 sds away from the mean”
B1: Allow “30 is less than 1.5×IQR from UQ”
B1: or eg "It depends which definition you use." Any comment implying uncertainty Ignore comments about mean ± 3 sds or mean ± 1 sd
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
\(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 20\)
B1
\(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \gt 20\) where \(\mu\) = pop mean time spent oe
B1
\(\overline{X} \sim \mathrm{N}\left(20, \dfrac{4.2^2}{60}\right)\) and \(\overline{X} = 21\)
There is evidence that (mean) time spent is \(\gt 20\) hours or eg there is evidence to support Zac’s belief
A1f
[7]
NB Use of \(4.2^2/60\) as sd gives \(p = 0.000335\)
Notes
NB Allow 2 sf throughout
B1 B1: Allow other letters, not \(X\) unless defined. Not \(\overline{X}\) B1B0 for 1 error eg 2-tail or:
2-tail: B1B0
undefined \(\mu\): B1B0
not in terms of parameter: B1B0
\(\mu\) = sample mean implied: B1B0
Not include value 20: B0B0
eg \(\mathrm{H}_0 = 20\) etc: B0B0
M1: Correct distribution and value of \(\overline{X}\). stated or implied eg by 0.0326 or 0.967 or 20.9 or 1.84 or 0.000335 even if within incorrect statement eg \(\mathrm{P}(X = 21) = 0.0326\) Condone \(\dfrac{4.2^2}{\sqrt{60}}\) or \(\dfrac{4.2^2}{60^2}\) or \(\dfrac{4.2}{60}\)
A1:BC Allow 2 sf, ie 0.033
A1: Dep 0.0326 or 1.84 or 0.9674 or \(\mathrm{P}(X \gt 21)\) or \(\mathrm{P}(X \geqslant 21)\) soi Must compare like with like, eg NOT prob cf \(z\)-value or large prob cf small prob or CV cf wrong end of acceptance region
M1: Dependent on clearly valid comparison of like with like. Dep 0.0326 or 0.9674 or 20.9 or 1.84 or \(\mathrm{P}(X \gt 21)\) or \(\mathrm{P}(X \geqslant 21)\) soi (corrected from the printed mark scheme: it printed “0.0485 or 0.951”, values that do not arise in this question) May be implied by conclusion, eg “There is evidence that mean time is \(\gt 20\) hours” M1A1
A1f: In context, not definite; eg “Mean time is \(\gt 20\) hours": A0 But “There is evidence to reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\) and that mean time is \(\gt 20\) h” M1A1 Allow opposite conclusion, ft their values, if above conditions met and loses 2nd A1. But potentially can score all the other 6 marks
14 Table 1 shows the numbers of usual residents in the age range 0 to 4 in 15 Local Authorities (LAs) in 2001 and 2011. The table also shows the increase in the numbers in this age group, and the same increase as a percentage.
2001
2011
Increase
% Increase
Bolton
16 779
18 765
1 986
11.84%
Bury
11 117
12 235
1 118
10.06%
Knowsley
9 454
9 121
−333
−3.52%
Liverpool
24 840
26 099
1 259
5.07%
Manchester
24 693
36 413
11 720
47.46%
Oldham
15 196
16 491
1 295
8.52%
Rochdale
13 771
14 754
983
7.14%
Salford
12 529
16 255
3 726
29.74%
Sefton
14 896
14 601
−295
−1.98%
St. Helens
10 083
10 269
186
1.84%
Stockport
16 457
17 342
885
5.38%
Tameside
12 803
14 439
1 636
12.78%
Trafford
11 971
14 870
2 899
24.22%
Wigan
17 561
19 681
2 120
12.07%
Wirral
17 475
18 514
1 039
5.95%
Table 1
Fig. 2 shows the increase in each LA in raw numbers, and Fig. 3 shows the percentage increase in each LA.
Fig. 2Fig. 3
(a) The Education Committees in these LAs need to plan for the provision of schools for pupils in their districts.
(i) Explain why, in this context, the increase is more important than the actual numbers. [1]
(ii) In which of the following LAs was there likely to have been the greatest need for extra teachers in the years following 2011: Bolton, Sefton, Tameside or Wigan? Give a reason for your answer. [2]
(iii) State an assumption about the populations needed to make your answer in part (ii) valid. [1]
(b) In two of the 15 LAs the proportion of young families is greater than in the other 13 LAs. Suggest, using only data from Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 and/or Table 1, which two LAs these are most likely to be. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) The actual number of extra pupils determines the number of places needed Shows how many new students there will be Shows trend so LA can provide accordingly Need to know expected number of pupils
B1
2.2b
[1]
(ii) Wigan Increase in number is greatest there
B1 B1
2.2b 2.2b
[2]
(iii) E.g. all those in this category stay in the LA Populations continue growing at same rate Populations all growing at same rate The population increases consistently NOT Increase has been steady
All LAs have the same teacher/pupil ratio All LAs have same need for teachers in 2011
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
(a)(i) The existing numbers are already catered for Increase in provision Not Need to know increase in proportion of pupils
(a)(ii) Allow “Wigan and Bolton” Ignore mention of % increase. Ignore extras.
(a)(iii) No decrease in population Children born in that LA will go to school in that LA Assume no great influx or outflow of children after 2011. The LAs are not currently understaffed Ignore extra eg “between 2001 & 2011”
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Manchester and Salford B1 Highest % or absolute increase B1dep
Manchester and Liverpool B1 The two highest in 2011 B1dep
SC Manchester (alone), Highest % or absolute increase: B1B0
B1 B1
2.2b 2.4
[2]
Notes
Wigan and Bolton B1 Highest numbers in 2011 except Manchester and Liverpool, which are very large B1dep
Salford and Trafford B1 They have the largest absolute (or %) increase, but are small (or not huge like Manchester) B1dep
11 As part of a research project, the masses, \(m\) grams, of a random sample of 1000 pebbles from a certain beach were recorded. The results are summarised in the table.
Mass (g)
\(50 \leqslant m \lt 150\)
\(150 \leqslant m \lt 200\)
\(200 \leqslant m \lt 250\)
\(250 \leqslant m \lt 350\)
Frequency
162
318
355
165
(a) Calculate estimates of the mean and standard deviation of these masses. [2]
The masses, \(x\) grams, of a random sample of 1000 pebbles on a different beach were also found. It was proposed that the distribution of these masses should be modelled by the random variable \(X \sim \mathrm{N}(200, 3600)\).
(b) Use the model to find \(\mathrm{P}(150 \lt X \lt 210)\). [1]
(c) Use the model to determine \(x_1\) such that \(\mathrm{P}(160 \lt X \lt x_1) = 0.6\), giving your answer correct to five significant figures. [3]
It was found that the smallest and largest masses of the pebbles in this second sample were 112 g and 288 g respectively.
(d) Use these results to show that the model may not be appropriate. [1]
(e) Suggest a different value of a parameter of the model in the light of these results. [2]
B1: soi, eg by \(\mathrm{P}(X \gt 160) = 0.748\) or 0.747 or by 0.147 or 0.148
T&I: correct answer scores B1M1A1, otherwise max B1 SC Answer 263 with correct working: B1M1A0 SC Answer 263 with inadequate working: B1 only
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
112 and 288 are within 2 sd from mean (no working needed) \(\mathrm{P}(X \lt 112) = 0.0708\), which is \(\gt 0.025\) or \(\gt 0.0013\) or \(\gt 0\)
B1
3.5a
[1]
Notes
or \(\mu + 2\sigma = 320\) (\(\mu + 3\sigma = 380\)) which is > than 288 or \(\mathrm{P}(112 \lt M \lt 288) = 0.858\) which is < than 0.95 (or 0.99) or \(p = 0.858\), but model suggests \(p = 1\) NOT 0.858 alone B0
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Reduce \(\sigma\)
B1
3.5c
\(288 - 200 = 2\sigma\) or \(288 - 200 = 3\sigma\) or \(288 - 112 = 4\sigma\) or \(288 - 112 = 6\sigma\) \(\sigma = 44\) \(\sigma = 29.3\) or about 30
B1
3.3
[2]
Notes
B1: May be implied by value of \(\sigma\)
B1: Allow more precise correct methods Allow \(\sigma\) between 25 and 50. No working needed B1B1 or \(\sigma^2\) between 625 and 2500
9 The histogram shows information about the numbers of cars in five different price ranges, sold in one year at a car showroom.
It is given that 66 cars in the price range £10 000 to £20 000 were sold.
(a) Find the number of cars sold in the price range £50 000 to £90 000. [1]
(b) State the units of the frequency density. [1]
(c) Suggest one change that the management could make to the diagram so that it would provide more information. [1]
(d) Estimate the number of cars sold in the price range £50 000 to £60 000. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\((40000 \times 0.002 =)\ 80\)
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Frequency per £ or No. of cars per £
B1
1.1
[1]
Notes
Allow cars / £ Allow as fraction NOT cars / price NOT cars / money
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Show fds for four separate classes within £50000 - £90000
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
Make price intervals smaller Show the median (or similar) Include more bars Give a title Explain \(y\)-axis better or give units of f.d. Give the frequencies
11 A trainer was asked to give a lecture on population profiles in different Local Authorities (LAs) in the UK. Using data from the 2011 census, he created the following scatter diagram for 17 selected LAs.
He selected the 17 LAs using the following method. The proportions of people aged 18 to 24 and aged 65+ in any Local Authority are denoted by \(P_{\text{young}}\) and \(P_{\text{senior}}\) respectively. The trainer used a spreadsheet to calculate the value of \(k = \dfrac{P_{\text{young}}}{P_{\text{senior}}}\) for each of the 348 LAs in the UK. He then used specific ranges of values of \(k\) to select the 17 LAs.
(a) Estimate the ranges of values of \(k\) that he used to select these 17 LAs. [2]
(b) Using the 17 LAs the trainer carried out a hypothesis test with the following hypotheses. \(\mathrm{H}_0\): There is no linear correlation in the population between \(P_{\text{young}}\) and \(P_{\text{senior}}\). \(\mathrm{H}_1\): There is negative linear correlation in the population between \(P_{\text{young}}\) and \(P_{\text{senior}}\). He found that the value of Pearson’s product-moment correlation coefficient for the 17 LAs is \(-0.797\), correct to 3 significant figures.
(i) Use the table below to show that this value is significant at the 1% level. [2]
The trainer concluded that there is evidence of negative linear correlation between \(P_{\text{young}}\) and \(P_{\text{senior}}\) in the population.
(ii) Use the diagram to comment on the reliability of this conclusion. [2]
(c) Describe one outstanding feature of the population in the areas represented by the points in the bottom right hand corner of the diagram. [1]
(d) The trainer’s audience included representatives from several universities. Suggest a reason why the diagram might be of particular interest to these people. [1]
Critical values of Pearson’s product-moment correlation coefficient
1-tail test
5%
2.5%
1%
0.5%
2-tail test
10%
5%
2%
1%
\(n\)
1
-
-
-
-
2
-
-
-
-
3
0.9877
0.9969
0.9995
0.9999
4
0.9000
0.9500
0.9800
0.9900
5
0.8054
0.8783
0.9343
0.9587
6
0.7293
0.8114
0.8822
0.9172
7
0.6694
0.7545
0.8329
0.8745
8
0.6215
0.7067
0.7887
0.8343
9
0.5822
0.6664
0.7498
0.7977
10
0.5494
0.6319
0.7155
0.7646
11
0.5214
0.6021
0.6851
0.7348
12
0.4973
0.5760
0.6581
0.7079
13
0.4762
0.5529
0.6339
0.6835
14
0.4575
0.5324
0.6120
0.6614
15
0.4409
0.5140
0.5923
0.6411
16
0.4259
0.4973
0.5742
0.6226
17
0.4124
0.4821
0.5577
0.6055
18
0.4000
0.4683
0.5425
0.5897
19
0.3887
0.4555
0.5285
0.5751
20
0.3783
0.4438
0.5155
0.5614
21
0.3687
0.4329
0.5034
0.5487
22
0.3598
0.4227
0.4921
0.5368
23
0.3515
0.4132
0.4815
0.5256
24
0.3438
0.4044
0.4716
0.5151
25
0.3365
0.3961
0.4622
0.5052
26
0.3297
0.3882
0.4534
0.4958
27
0.3233
0.3809
0.4451
0.4869
28
0.3172
0.3739
0.4372
0.4785
29
0.3115
0.3673
0.4297
0.4705
30
0.3061
0.3610
0.4226
0.4629
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(k \gt 1.4\) (allow \(k \gt 1.1\) to 1.6) \(k \lt 0.25\) (allow \(k \lt 0.2\) to 0.3)
B1 B1
2.2b 2.2b
or \(1.4 \lt k \lt \ldots\ldots\) B1 \(\ldots\ldots \lt k \lt 0.25\) (ranges as above) B1
[2]
Notes
Allow \(\geqslant\) and \(\leqslant\) SC: \(0.25 \lt k \lt 1.4\): B1B0 (ranges as on left) Allow "\(x\)"
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) \(0.797 \gt 0.5577\) or \(-0.797 \lt -0.5577\) or \(|-0.797| \gt 0.5577\)
B2
3.1b 3.2a
[2]
(ii) There are clusters (or groups etc.)
B1*
2.3
Apparent good correlation caused by clusters or Two clusters with no –ve corr'n within them or a comment similar to one of the above. AND Conclusion unreliable or Value of \(r\) is misleading oe
B1 dep B1*
3.5b
[2]
Notes
(b)(i) B2: \(0.797 \gt 0.6055\) or \(-0.797 \lt -0.6055\) B1 \(\pm 0.5577\) B1 Allow \(\geqslant\) or \(\leqslant\)
(b)(ii) or Not bivariate normal distribution B1 so use of tables for \(r\) not valid B1 NOT Too scattered Not represent whole pop Small sample Clusters not on reg line B1B0
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
High prop of 65+ or Low prop of 18-24 Prop of young very similar, or \(\approx 0.06\) Proportion of senior to young is high
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: If consider only one age-group, must be proportion not number If consider both age-groups, allow eg Higher number of seniors than young or Many seniors, few young NOT: Similar proportions of 65+ Population is elderly
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Top left points contain high prop of 18-24s. (So these LAs may be areas where there are universities or where they can recruit)
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: Shows places where large nos of 18-24s Shows where to focus recruiting. So universities can recruit. 18-24s are their target group. No need to specify "Top left group" Allow "students" or "young" instead of "18-24s" Any implication that diagram enables you to see information about location of young people
10 A certain forest contains only trees of a particular species. Dipak wished to take a random sample of 5 trees from the forest. He numbered the trees from 1 to 784. Then, using his calculator, he generated the random digits 14 781 049. Using these digits, Dipak formed 5 three-digit numbers. He took the first, second and third digits, followed by the second, third and fourth digits and so on. In this way he obtained the following list of numbers for his sample.
147 478 781 104 49
(i) Explain why Dipak omitted the number 810 from his list. [1]
(ii) Explain why Dipak’s sample is not random. [1]
The mean height of all trees of this species is known to be 4.2 m. Dipak wishes to test whether the mean height of trees in the forest is less than 4.2 m. He now uses a correct method to choose a random sample of 50 trees and finds that their mean height is 4.0 m. It is given that the standard deviation of trees in the forest is 0.8 m.
(iii) Carry out the test at the 2% significance level. [7]
Mark scheme (i)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Only 784 trees and \(810 \gt 784\)
E1
2.4
[1]
Notes
E1: or other similar
Mark scheme (ii)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg Each no. not independent of previous no. Each no. is related to the next
E1
2.3
[1]
Notes
E1: Allow 2nd digit of each no. is 1st of next Consecutive nos share two digits or similar correct Digits are re-used Ignore all else
Mark scheme (iii)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 4.2\)
B1
1.1
\(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \lt 4.2\) where \(\mu\) is mean height of trees (in the wood)
B1
2.5
\(\bar{X} \sim \mathrm{N}\left(4.2, \dfrac{0.8^2}{50}\right)\) and \(\bar{X} \lt 4.0\) or \(\bar{X} \leqslant 4.0\)
M1
3.3
\(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X} \lt 4.0) = 0.038549\ldots\) or 0.039
A1
3.4
Compare 0.02
A1
1.1
Do not reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\)
M1
2.2b
There is insufficient evidence that mean height of these trees in the wood is less than 4.2m.
A1f
3.5a
[7]
Notes
B1 B1: Allow other letters except \(X\) or \(\bar{X}\) One error, eg undefined \(\mu\) or 2-tail: B0B1
M1: Stated or implied Allow \(\bar{X} \gt 4.0\) or \(\bar{X} = 4.0\)
A1:BC Allow 0.038 NB 0.038... implies M1A1
A1: dep \(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X} \lt 4.0)\) attempted
M1: Allow Accept \(\mathrm{H}_0\) dep \(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X} \lt 4.0)\) attempted Can be implied by conclusion
A1f: In context, not definite; eg “Mean height not less than 4.2m”: A0
Alternatively: \(\Phi^{-1}(0.98)\ (= 2.054)\) \(4.2 - 2.054 \times \dfrac{0.8}{\sqrt{50}}\ (= 3.968)\) comp their 3.968 with 4.0
15 A personal trainer is investigating whether, in the general population, there is any association between resting pulse rate in beats per minute and mean hours per week spent running.
One week he collects a sample by asking 25 of his clients for the relevant data.
(a)
(i) State the name of the sampling technique used by the personal trainer. [1]
(ii) Explain why this sampling technique might introduce bias. [1]
A biologist researching the same topic collects a random sample of size 47. She represents the data using the scatter diagram shown below.
(b) Describe the association between resting pulse rate and mean hours per week spent running. [1]
(c) The biologist identifies two distinct regions on the scatter diagram. Identify these regions on the copy of the scatter diagram in the Printed Answer Booklet by drawing an appropriate vertical line between them. [1]
According to medical research, the normal resting pulse rate for an adult is between 60 and 110 beats per minute.
The biologist separates the data into a group to the left of the vertical line on the scatter diagram and a group to the right of the vertical line on the scatter diagram. She calculates Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient, \(r_s\), and the associated \(p\)-value for each group.
The results are shown in the table.
Group
\(r_s\)
\(p\)-value
To the left of the vertical line
0.209 36
0.419 98
To the right of the vertical line
–0.613 49
0.000 31
(d) With reference to the two groups identified by the biologist and to the values in the table, explain what may be inferred about the association between resting pulse rate and mean number of hours per week spent running. [6]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) opportunity (sampling)
B1
2.5
[1]
(ii) only people known to the personal trainer / his clients sampled oe so eg they are fitter than typical members of the population oe eg sample may not be representative oe
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
(i) B1: allow convenience (sampling) do not allow eg convenient sampling; eg opportunistic sampling
(ii) B1: allow so any eg which alludes to sample possibly giving unrepresentative values
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
negative (association)
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: ignore adjectives such as weak, strong etc allow eg as mean hours spent running increases, resting pulse rate decreases; eg negative relationship; do not allow eg (negative) correlation; eg as pulse rate increases, mean hours per week spent running decreases
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: approximately vertical line at about 2.5; B0 if more than one line
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
LH region 0.20936 is (fairly) small oe isw
B1
3.4
0.41998 is not close to 0 oe isw
M1
3.4
insufficient evidence to suggest association (between mean time spent running and resting pulse rate) oe
A1
2.2b
RH region –0.61349 is closer to –1 than 0 oe isw
B1
3.4
0.00031is close to 0 oe
M1
3.4
sufficient evidence to suggest (some) [negative] association (between mean time spent running and resting pulse rate) oe
A1
2.2b
[6]
Notes
B1: allow eg \(r_s\) is closer to 0 than to 1; eg low value of \(r_s\); eg allow \(r_s\) close to 0
M1: allow eg \(p\)-value \(\gt\) 0.05 (or 0.01 or 0.1) eg \(p\)-value not small do not allow eg \(p\)-value (relatively) large eg high \(p\)-value
A1: may infer no association
B1: allow eg \(r_s\) close to \(-1\) eg \(r_s\) is closer to –1 than 0; eg \(r_s\) is not small B0 for eg \(r_s\) is large oe
M1: allow eg \(p\)-value \(\lt\) 0.05 (or 0.01 or 0.10) allow eg \(p\)-value is (very) small/low
11 Apples are sold in packets of 4. Ling and Sam are investigating the frequency, \(f\), of the number of bruised apples in a packet, \(x\). They each collect a random sample of packets, note the number of bruised apples in each packet and draw a diagram to represent their data.
Ling’s results are shown in Table 11.1 and Fig. 11.1.
Table 11.1
\(x\)
0
1
2
3
4
\(f\)
19
2
0
2
2
Fig. 11.1
Sam’s results are shown in Table 11.2 and Fig. 11.2.
Table 11.2
\(x\)
0
1
2
3
4
\(f\)
39
1
0
3
7
Fig. 11.2
(a) Explain why Sam’s diagram is likely to be a better representation of the true distribution of the number of bruised apples in a packet than Ling’s diagram. [1]
(b) Calculate the mean number of bruised apples per packet for Sam’s data. [1]
Sam thinks that the distribution of bruised apples may be modelled by a binomial distribution.
(c) Use your answer to part (b) to calculate the value of \(p\), the probability that an apple selected at random is bruised, for Sam’s model. [1]
(d) Calculate the theoretical frequency distribution of the number of bruised apples per packet for Sam’s model, giving your answers correct to 2 decimal places. [3]
(e) Comment on whether Sam’s model appears to be a good fit for the data. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
because Sam used a larger sample oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: allow eg because he/she/they used more data eg the sample is bigger
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
0.76 or \(\frac{38}{50}\) oe BC
B1
1.1
[1]
Notes
B1: mark the final answer
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
0.19
B1
3.3
[1]
Notes
B1: FT \(\dfrac{\text{their } 0.76}{4}\)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(x\)
0
1
2
3
4
\(f\)
21.52
20.19
7.11
1.11
0.07
BC
B1 B1 B1
3.4 3.4 1.1
[3]
Notes
B1: for 1 correct frequency to 2 d.p.
B1: for 3 correct frequencies to 2 d.p.
B1: for all 5 correct to 2 d.p.
FT use of B(4, their 0.19); allow SC2 for all 5 frequencies awrt 22, 20, 7, 1, 0 or better allow SC1 for 3 of the above frequencies awrt nearest whole number or better if B0B0B0 allow SC1 for probabilities: 0.430467…, 0.403895…, 0.142111…, 0.022223…, 0.001303 given to 3 dp or more; FT use of B(4, their 0.19) with \(0 \lt p \lt 1\)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
by comparing theoretical and observed frequencies (or probabilities), the model is a (very) poor fit oe
B1
3.5a
[1]
Notes
B1: allow comparison of one pair of frequencies or one pair of probabilities;
10 The pre-release material contains information about life expectancy at birth for countries of the world at 10-year intervals from 1960 until 2020.
The life expectancy at birth of the population of Sudan for this period, together with a line of best fit, is shown in Fig. 10.1.
Fig. 10.1
The equation of the line of best fit is \(L = 0.275X - 490\), where \(X\) is the year and \(L\) is the life expectancy at birth, measured in years.
(a) Use the equation of the line of best fit to estimate the life expectancy at birth in Sudan in 1975. [1]
(b) Explain whether this estimate is likely to be close to the true value of life expectancy at birth in Sudan in 1975. [1]
(c) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to explain whether your answer to part (a) is likely to be a close approximation to the life expectancy at birth in the United Kingdom in 1975. [1]
The pre-release material also gives the median age of the population in countries of the world.
The table shows the median age of the population and the life expectancy at birth in 2020 for some countries in Africa.
Country
Median age
Life expectancy at birth 2020
Nigeria
18.6
55.02
Rwanda
19.7
69.33
Saint Helena, Ascension and Tristan da Cunha
43.2
#N/A
Sao Tome and Principe
19.3
70.58
Senegal
19.4
68.21
(d) Explain how the data in the table should be cleaned before these data can be included in a scatter diagram for life expectancy at birth against median age for the countries in Africa. [1]
Fig. 10.2 shows a scatter diagram for the cleaned data of life expectancy at birth against median age in 2020 for the countries in Africa. It also shows a line of best fit.
The product moment correlation coefficient for these data is 0.680.
Fig. 10.2
(e) A student decides to use the line of best fit to estimate the life expectancy at birth in 2020 for Saint Helena, Ascension and Tristan da Cunha.
Explain whether this estimate is likely to be reliable. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
53.125 rounded to 2 or more sf isw
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
likely to be close because oe allow eg linear model seems appropriate eg interpolation eg 1975 is within range eg points are approximately in a straight line
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: allow eg yes do not allow eg 53.125 is within range eg positive correlation eg follows the same trend eg the value for 1975 is between the values for 1970 and 1980
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
not likely to be close approximation because oe eg life expectancy generally higher in UK (or Europe) oe eg life expectancy generally lower in Sudan (or Africa) oe eg change of life expectancy over time different in UK oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: must refer to life expectancy; must refer to UK or Europe or Sudan or Africa; ignore superfluous speculation do not allow eg not likely to be close because data is different eg life expectancy varies between countries
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
remove / delete the row with #N/A or remove (the data for) Saint Helena, (Ascension and Tristan da Cunha) isw
B1
1.2
[1]
Notes
B1: do not allow “cell” or “entry” do not allow ignore instead of remove ignore superfluous comments
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
not reliable because oe eg it’s extrapolation eg 43.2 is outside the range of median ages eg \(r\) is not close to 1 eg scatter does not appear to be linear eg linear model is not a good fit for the data eg scatter not elliptical
8 At the end of the summer term all 120 Year 8 pupils at Oakmount College sit the same mathematics examination.
The marks obtained by the pupils in the 2024 examination are summarised in the table.
Mark
11–20
21–30
31–40
41–50
51–60
61–70
71–80
81–90
91–100
Frequency
8
12
24
17
23
16
10
7
3
Software is used to produce the cumulative frequency curve shown below.
(a) It is proposed that the 30 pupils with the best marks in the examination are placed in the top set in Year 9.
Use the copy of the cumulative frequency curve in the Printed Answer Booklet to determine an estimate of the lowest mark needed for a pupil to be placed in the top set. [2]
(b) The person who will teach the top set states that pupils will not manage in this class unless they obtain at least 75 marks in the examination.
Use the copy of the cumulative frequency curve in the Printed Answer Booklet to determine an estimate of how many pupils will be in the top set if the lowest mark is set at 75. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg horizontal line at cf = 90 or 91; eg curve marked at cf = 90 or 91 and mark stated eg vertical axis marked at 90 or 91 and mark stated eg horizontal axis marked between 60 and 65 and mark stated
M1
1.1
62, 63 or 64
A1
1.1
[2]
Notes
M1: allow if seen on diagram for part (b)
A1: if M0 allow B1 for 62, 63 or 64
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg vertical line from mark = 75 eg curve marked at \(x\) = 75 and cf stated eg horizontal axis marked at 75 and cf stated eg vertical axis marked at 104 – 106 and cf stated
15 Bottles of Fizzipop nominally contain 330 ml of drink. A consumer affairs researcher collects a random sample of 55 bottles of Fizzipop and records the volume of drink in each bottle.
Summary statistics for the researcher’s sample are shown in the table.
\(n\)
55
\(\sum x\)
18 535
\(\sum x^2\)
6 247 066.6
(a)
(i) Calculate the mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop. [1]
(ii) Show that the standard deviation of the volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is 3.78 ml. [1]
The researcher uses software to produce a histogram with equal class intervals, which is shown below.
(b) Explain why the researcher decides that the Normal distribution is a suitable model for the volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop. [2]
(c) Use your answers to parts (a) and (b) to determine the expected number of bottles which contain less than 330 ml in a random sample of 100 bottles. [3]
In order to comply with new regulations, no more than 1% of bottles of Fizzipop should contain less than 330 ml.
The manufacturer decides to meet the new regulations by adjusting the manufacturing process so that the mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is increased.
The standard deviation is unaltered.
(d) Determine the minimum mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop which should ensure that the new regulations are met. Give your answer to 3 significant figures. [3]
The mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is set to 340 ml. After several weeks the quality control manager suspects the mean volume may have reduced. She collects a random sample of 100 bottles of Fizzipop.
The mean volume of drink in a bottle in the sample is found to be 339.37 ml.
(e) Assuming the standard deviation is unaltered, conduct a hypothesis test at the 5% level to determine whether there is any evidence to suggest that the mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is less than 340 ml. [7]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(i) 337
B1
1.1
[1]
(ii) \(\sqrt{\frac{1}{54}\left(6247066.6 - 55 \times 337^2\right)}\)
B1
1.1
\(\approx 3.78\)
[1]
Notes
(ii) B1:NB \(\sqrt{14.289} = 3.7800\ldots\) may see \(\sqrt{\frac{6247066.6}{55} - 337^2} \times \sqrt{\frac{55}{54}}\) or \(\sqrt{\frac{6247066.6}{54} - \frac{55 \times 337^2}{54}}\) oe; AG must see substitution of at least three of 6247066.6, 337, 55 and 54
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
allow any two reasons eg distribution is (approximately) symmetrical eg distribution is (approximately) bell-shaped eg distribution is unimodal eg data is continuous
E1 E1
2.4 2.2b
[2]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\mathrm{P}(X \lt 330)\) found from N(their 337, \(3.78^2\))
M1
3.3
\(100 \times\) their 0.032
M1
3.4
awrt 3.2 www
A1
1.1
[3]
Notes
M1: may be implied by 0.032; allow a more precise value for 3.78 if found in part (a)(ii) NB eg N(−9E999,330,337,3.78); NB may see \(\sigma^2 = \frac{643}{45}\) or \(z = \frac{330-337}{3.78}\ (= -1.85\ldots)\)
A1: mark the final answer
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\((z =)\ \pm 2.3263\ldots\) seen
B1
3.1a
their \(z = \frac{330 - \mu}{3.78}\)
M1
2.1
\(338.79 \approx 339\)
A1
3.2a
[3]
Notes
B1: to 2 or more dp
A1: must be correct to 3 sf A0 for \(\mu \geqslant 339\) or \(\mu \gt 339\)
M1: allow slip in calculation if intent is clear; allow for any value between 338 and 338.78 inclusive must see correct distributions if probabilities are wrong
M1: allow for any value between 338.8 and 339.5 NB critical value is 338.79
A1: must be correct to 3 sf; A0 for \(\mu \geqslant 339\) or \(\mu \gt 339\)
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
H\(_0\): \(\mu = 340\) H\(_1\): \(\mu \lt 340\)
B1
1.1
\(\mu\) is the population mean (volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop)
B1
2.5
\(\mathrm{N}\left(340, \frac{3.78^2}{100}\right)\) oe seen
do not accept H\(_0\) or reject H\(_0\) or accept H\(_1\) or significant
A1FT
1.1
there is sufficient evidence at the 5% level to suggest that the mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is less than 340 ml oe
A1
3.5a
[7]
Notes
B1: do not allow \(\bar{X}\) or \(X\), but allow other symbol if defined as [population] mean volume; allow equivalent in words
M1*: may be implied by \(0.0477 - 0.048\) may see N\((340, 0.378^2)\) may see \(\sigma^2 = \frac{643}{4500}\)
A1: allow slip such as \(X\) for \(\bar{X}\) but do not allow \(\mu\)
A1: dependent on award of all other marks apart from second B1 do not allow eg conclude / prove / indicate or other assertive statement instead of suggest
Alternatively
Scheme
Marks
AO
H\(_0\): \(\mu = 340\) H\(_1\): \(\mu \lt 340\)
B1
1.1
\(\mu\) is the population mean (volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop)
B1
2.5
\(\mathrm{N}\left(340, \frac{3.78^2}{100}\right)\) oe seen
M1*
3.3
[critical region is \(\bar{X} \lt]\ 339.378 - 339.38\)
A1
3.4
339.37 correctly compared with their 339.378
M1dep*
3.4
do not accept H\(_0\) or reject H\(_0\) or accept H\(_1\) or significant
A1FT
1.1
there is sufficient evidence at the 5% level to suggest that the mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is less than 340 ml oe
A1
3.5a
B1: do not allow \(\bar{X}\) or \(X\), but allow other symbol if defined as [population] mean volume; allow equivalent in words
M1*: may be implied by \(339.378 - 339.38\) may see N\((340, 0.378^2)\) may see \(\sigma^2 = \frac{643}{4500}\)
A1: or [critical value is \(\bar{X} =]\ 339.378 - 339.38\); allow slip such as \(X\) for \(\bar{X}\) but do not allow \(\mu\)
M1dep*: allow eg so 339.37 is in the critical region if critical region explicitly identified
A1FT:A0 if \(339.37 \gt\) their 339.378
A1: dependent on award of all other marks apart from second B1 do not allow eg conclude / prove / indicate or other assertive statement instead of suggest
Alternatively, using standard Normal distribution
Scheme
Marks
AO
H\(_0\): \(\mu = 340\) H\(_1\): \(\mu \lt 340\)
B1
\(\mu\) is the population mean (volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop)
B1
\(\mathrm{N}\left(340, \frac{3.78^2}{100}\right)\) oe seen
M1*
\([z =]\ -1.667\)
A1
their \(z\) correctly compared with \(-1.64485\) to 2 or more dp oe; must come from N\((340, \sigma)\)
M1dep*
do not accept H\(_0\) or reject H\(_0\) or accept H\(_1\) or significant
A1FT
there is sufficient evidence at the 5% level to suggest that the mean volume of drink in a bottle of Fizzipop is less than 340 ml oe
A1
B1: do not allow \(\bar{X}\) or \(X\), but allow other symbol if defined as [population] mean volume; allow equivalent in words
M1*: may be implied by \(z = -1.667\) may see N\((340, 0.378^2)\) may see \(\sigma^2 = \frac{643}{4500}\)
A1FT:A0 if their \(z \gt -1.64485\)
A1: dependent on award of all other marks apart from second B1 do not allow eg conclude / prove / indicate or other assertive statement instead of suggest
14 The pre-release material contains medical data for 103 women and 97 men.
The boxplot represents the weights in kg of 101 of the women from the pre-release material.
(a) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to give a reason why the weights of all 103 women were not included in the diagram. [1]
(b) Determine the range of values in which any outliers lie. [3]
(c) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to explain whether these outliers should be removed from any further analysis of the data. [1]
(d) The median weight of men in the sample was found to be 79.9 kg. Explain what may be inferred by comparing the median weight of men with the median weight of women. [1]
Further analysis of the weights of both men and women is carried out. The table shows some of the results.
mean
standard deviation
men
82.69 kg
19.98 kg
women
72.5 kg
19.95 kg
(e) Use the information in the table to make two inferences about the distribution of the weights of men compared with the distribution of the weights of women. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
not all the data were available
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: LDS advantage must refer to data not being available or reference to #N/A
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(57.7 - 1.5 \times (82.05 - 57.7)\) or \(82.05 + 1.5 \times (82.05 - 57.7)\) seen
M1
1.1
outliers \(\lt 21.175\) or outliers \(\gt 118.575\)
A1
2.2a
(hence all outliers in interval) (118.575,132.2] (since no outliers in lower tail)
A1
2.2a
[3]
Notes
A1: given correct to 1 dp or better; both regions needed; allow non-strict inequalities
A1: allow eg between 118.6 and 132.2 allow strict or non-strict inequalities
if M0 allow SCB1 for both regions outliers \(\lt 21.175\) or outliers \(\gt 118.575\) unsupported; allow SCB2 for all outliers in (118.575,132.2] unsupported
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
should not be removed since no reason to eg doubt that it’s genuine data eg suspect it’s been misrecorded eg doubt since from (US) government
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: LDS advantage
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
a typical man is heavier than a typical woman, [since \(79.9 \gt 69.5\)]
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: allow eg an average man is heavier than an average woman
do not allow eg men are heavier than women on average
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
mean weight for men is greater than mean weight for women, so distribution for men is located further along the number line than the distribution for women (by about 10 kg) oe
B1
2.4
standard deviations (or variances) are approximately equal, so similar dispersion about the mean / variation in weights for men and women oe
B1
2.2a
[2]
Notes
B1: allow mean weight for men greater than mean weight for women, so men are heavier than women (by about 10 kg) oe must refer to mean or average
9 A teacher is investigating how pupils travel to and from school each day. Pupils can either travel by bus, train, car, bicycle or walk.
The teacher decides to collect a sample of size 60 for the investigation.
(a) The teacher lives in a village 10 miles away from the school. Explain how collecting a sample which just consists of pupils who live in the same village as the teacher might introduce bias. [1]
The table below shows how many students there are in each year.
Year 7
Year 8
Year 9
Year 10
Year 11
86
105
107
101
101
(b) The teacher decides to use the method of proportional stratified sampling. Calculate the number of pupils in the sample who are in Year 9. [2]
The teacher generates a sample of 10 pupils from the 86 in Year 7 by listing them in alphabetical order and selecting the first name on the list and every ninth name thereafter.
(c) Explain whether this method will generate a simple random sample of the pupils who travel in Year 7. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(probably) wouldn’t include any pupils who eg cycle or eg walk to school (and hence biased towards certain methods of transport) oe
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: must refer to at least one of the given modes of transport
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\frac{107}{500} \times 60\)
M1
1.1
13
A1
1.1
[2]
Notes
M1: allow slip in calculation of 500 if clearly their sum of all pupils; may be implied by 12.84 or 12.8
A1:B2 for 13 unsupported
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
not simple random sampling because every possible sample does not have an equal probability of being selected oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: allow eg no because not possible to select every possible sample eg not simple random sampling because every pupil not equally likely to be selected
do not allow eg not simple random sampling because it’s systematic sampling
18 Riley is investigating the daily water consumption, in litres, of his household. He records the amount used for a random sample of 120 days from the previous twelve-month period.
The daily water consumption, in litres, is denoted by \(x\).
Summary statistics for Riley’s sample are given below.
\(\sum x = 31164.7 \quad \sum x^2 = 8\,101\,050.91 \quad n = 120\)
(a) Calculate the sample mean giving your answer correct to 3 significant figures. [1]
Riley displays the data in a histogram.
(b) Find the number of days on which between 255 and 260 litres were used. [1]
(c) Give two reasons why a Normal distribution may be an appropriate model for the daily consumption of water. [2]
Riley uses the sample mean and the sample variance, both correct to 3 significant figures, as parameters of a Normal distribution to model the daily consumption of water.
(d) Use Riley’s model to calculate the probability that on a randomly chosen day the household uses less than 255 litres of water. [2]
(e) Calculate the probability that the household uses less than 255 litres of water on at least 5 days out of a random sample of 28 days. [2]
The company which supplies the water makes charges relating to water consumption which are shown in the table below.
Standing charge per day in pence
7.8
Charge per litre in pence
0.18
(f) Adapt Riley’s model for daily water consumption to model the daily charges for water consumption. [3]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
260 cao
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
31 cao
B1
1.1
[1]
Notes
B1: mark the final answer
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
any 2 distinct reasons eg (approximately) symmetrical (about the mean)
B1
3.5a
eg approximately bell-shaped / unimodal eg data is continuous
B1
3.5a
[2]
Notes
B1: ignore extra comments unless they contradict an otherwise correct answer
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
[variance is] awrt 62.2 or [sd is] 7.89 seen BC
M1
3.3
\(0.26287 - 0.263134\) or 0.26
A1
3.4
[2]
Notes
M1:NB 62.15567…may be implied by sd = 7.88 or 7.89 NB 0.263047…from \(\sqrt{62.2}\) or 0.263133… from 7.89 NB 0.262871… from 7.88, 0.262973…from unrounded sd
A1: allow B2 for correct answer unsupported
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
B(28, \(p\)) used, where \(p\) is value calculated in (d)
M1
3.1a
\(0.888 \leqslant p < 0.896\)
A1
1.1
[2]
Notes
A1: may be given to 2 sf; allow B2 for correct answer unsupported
9 The pre-release material contains information concerning the median income of taxpayers in different areas of London. Some of the data for Camden is shown in the table below. The years quoted in this question refer to the end of the financial years used in the pre-release material. For example, the year 2004 in the table refers to the year 2003/04 in the pre-release material.
Year
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Median Income in £
21 300
23 200
24 200
25 900
26 900
#N/A
28 400
29 400
(a) Explain whether these data are a sample or a population of Camden taxpayers. [1]
A time series for the data is shown below.
The LINEST function on a spreadsheet is used to formulate the following model for the data:
\(I = 1115Y - 2\,212\,950\), where \(I =\) median income of taxpayers in £ and \(Y =\) year.
(b) Use this model to find an estimate of the median income of taxpayers in Camden in 2009. [1]
(c) Give two reasons why this estimate is likely to be close to the true value. [2]
The median income of taxpayers in Croydon in 2009 is also not available.
(d) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to explain whether the model used in part (b) would give a reasonable estimate of the missing value for Croydon. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg sample, since only some data used oe eg sample, since data for 2009 not used oe
B1
2.2a
[1]
Notes
B1: sample, since not all data used; ignore further reasoning unless contradictory
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
£27 085 or £27 100 or £27 000
B1
3.4
[1]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
it’s interpolation oe eg because we use 2009 oe which is between 2008 and 2010
B1
2.2a
eg a straight line model appears to be justified eg relationship seems to be linear eg median income seems to be directly proportional to time eg positive correlation [between median income and year]
B1
2.2b
[2]
Notes
B1: do not allow eg 27085 lies between 2008 and 2010 eg 27085 lies between the values for 2008 and 2010
B1: do not allow eg positive association eg positive relationship
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
not reasonable oe since eg (median taxable) income varies considerably across different regions of London eg (median) income different in Croydon and Camden eg (median) income lower in Croydon (than Camden) eg pattern of change in income over time different in Camden to Croydon
8 A garden centre stocks coniferous hedging plants. These are displayed in 10 rows, each of 120 plants. An employee collects a sample of the heights of these plants by recording the height of each plant on the front row of the display.
(a) Explain whether the data collected by the employee is a simple random sample. [1]
The data are shown in the cumulative frequency curve below.
The owner states that at least 75% of the plants are between 40 cm and 80 cm tall.
(b) Show that the data collected by the employee supports this statement. [4]
(c) Explain whether all samples of 120 plants would necessarily support the owner’s statement. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
not a simple random sample since each possible sample does not have an equal probability of being selected
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: allow “not a simple random sample since each plant does not have an equal probability of being selected” ignore further comments unless contradictory the essential elements of the comment are in bold
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
18 (shorter than 40 cm) seen
B1
2.1
110 (shorter than 80 cm) or 10 (taller than 80 cm) seen
B1
1.1
\(\frac{92}{120}\) oe or \(\frac{28}{120}\) oe
M1
1.1
awrt 77% > 75% oe so this supports the (owner’s) statement
A1
2.2a
[4]
Notes
B1: may be embedded in calculation
B1: may be embedded in calculation
M1:FT their 18 and their 110; allow M1 for \(\frac{91}{120}\) or \(\frac{29}{120}\) oe or \(\frac{75}{100} \times 120 = 90\) oe
A1:or 92 > 90 so this supports the (owner’s) statement; need comparison and comment
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
must refer to sample in answer eg since different samples give different results, not all samples would necessarily support owner’s statement eg no since another sample may contain all the tallest plants (and/or shortest) eg no since the heights in other samples may be different
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: ignore superfluous comments referring to eg growing conditions, soil type etc do not allow eg no, conditions different for other plants eg no, different plants on different rows eg no, might be biggest and smallest plants on other rows eg the first sample is not representative
9 At the beginning of the academic year, all the pupils in year 12 at a college take part in an assessment. Summary statistics for the marks obtained by the 2021 cohort are given below.
Marks may only be whole numbers, but the Head of Mathematics believes that the distribution of marks may be modelled by a Normal distribution.
(a) Calculate
The mean mark
The variance of the marks
[2]
(b) Use your answers to part (a) to write down a possible Normal model for the distribution of marks. [2]
One candidate in the cohort scored less than 105.
(c) Determine whether the model found in part (b) is consistent with this information. [3]
(d) Use the model to calculate an estimate of the number of candidates who scored 115 marks. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
mean 112.4 isw or 112 isw
B1
1.1
variance 8.8 or \(\sqrt{8.8^2}\) cao isw
B1
1.1
[2]
Notes
B1:B0 for 8.757 explicitly rounded to 8.8
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(\mathrm{N}(\)their 112.4, their 8.8\()\)
M1
3.3
\(\mathrm{N}(a, b)\)
A1
1.1
[2]
Notes
M1: allow M1 for \(8.8^2\) or \(\sqrt{8.8}\)
A1: \(a = 112.4\) or 112 and \(b = 8.8\) or \(2.97^2\)
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
P(mark \(\lt 104.5\)) or P(mark \(\lt 105\)) found from their distribution in part (b)
M1
3.4
\(205 \times\) their non-zero 0.00387
M1
3.1a
0.79 to 0.794 or 1.17 to 1.175 so consistent oe
A1
3.5a
[3]
Notes
M1: may see \(\mathrm{N}(-\infty, 104.5, 112.4, \sqrt{8.8})\) NB 0.00387 or 0.0063(06) implies M1 NB 0.00573 or 0.00914 implies M1 NB 0.00379(69..) or 0.00619(81…) may imply M1 FT use of variance = 8.757 NB 0.200(199…) and 0.184(665…) may imply M1 FT use of sd = 8.8 if probability is correctly found to be 0 eg from use of \(\mathrm{N}\left(112.4, \frac{8.8}{205}\right)\) allow M1 only – no further marks available
M1:or compare \(\frac{1}{205}\ (\approx 0.00488)\) with their non-zero 0.00387
A1:or probabilities similar so consistent oe
Alternatively
Scheme
Marks
\(\mathrm{InvNorm}\left(\frac{1}{205}, 112.4, \sqrt{8.8}\right)\) or \(\mathrm{InvNorm}\left(\frac{1}{205}, 112, \sqrt{8.8}\right)\) used to find their mark
M1
compares their mark with 105
M1
104.7 or 104.3 is close to 105 so good fit
A1
M1:FT their distribution
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
P(mark between 114.5 and 115.5) found
M1
3.4
18.75 to 18.77 so allow 18 or 19 or 16.5 to 16.534 so allow 16 or 17
8 Ali conducted an investigation into the distances ridden by those members of a cycling club who rode at least 120 km in a training week. She grouped all the distances into intervals of length 10 km and then constructed a cumulative frequency diagram, which is shown below.
(a) Explain whether the data Ali used is a sample or a population. [1]
The club is taking part in a competition. Eight team members and one reserve are to be selected. The club captain decides that the team members should be those cyclists who rode the furthest during the training week, and that the reserve should be the cyclist who rode the next furthest.
(b) Use the graph to estimate the shortest distance cycled by a team member. [1]
The captain’s best friend rode 156 km in the training week and was selected as reserve. Ali complained that this was unjustifiable.
(c) Explain whether there is sufficient evidence in the diagram to support Ali’s complaint. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
population since all distances of at least 120 km are used oe
B1
1.2
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
161-163 km
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
we need to see two elements: Ali’s complaint is justified oe and correct numerical reasoning with reference to upper tail
B1
2.2a
[1]
Notes
B1: eg 10 riders rode more than 160 km or 14 rode 156 km or more or the reserve should have ridden (approximately) 161 km so (Ali’s complaint is) justified oe
M1: allow one incorrect frequency density and/or one incorrect class width NB 8 + 13 + 18 + 20 + 12 soi with four of five correct implies M1 may be implied by 71
A1: if M0 allow SC1 for 8, 13, 18, 20, 12 and no others seen
13 At a certain factory Christmas tree decorations are packed in boxes of 10.
The quality control manager collects a random sample of 100 boxes of decorations and records the number of decorations in each box which are damaged.
His results are displayed in Fig. 13.1.
Number of damaged decorations
0
1
2
3
4
5 or more
Number of boxes
19
35
28
13
5
0
Fig. 13.1
(a) Calculate
the mean number of damaged decorations per box,
the standard deviation of the number of damaged decorations per box.
[2]
It is believed that the number of damaged decorations in a box of 10, \(X\), may be modelled by a binomial distribution such that \(X \sim \mathrm{B}(n, p)\).
(b) State suitable values for \(n\) and \(p\). [1]
(c) Use the binomial model to complete the copy of Fig. 13.2 in the Printed Answer Booklet, giving your answers correct to 1 decimal place. [3]
Number of damaged decorations
0
1
2
3
4
5 or more
Observed number of boxes
19
35
28
13
5
0
Expected number of boxes
Fig. 13.2
(d) Explain whether the model is a good fit for these data. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
mean = 1.5 BC
B1
1.1
sd = 1.1, 1.10 or awrt 1.096 BC
B1
1.1
[2]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(n = 10\) and \(p = 0.15\)
B1
3.3
[1]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
N
0
1
2
3
4
5 +
O
19
35
28
13
5
0
E
19.7
34.7
27.6
13.0
4.0
1.0
M1 M1 A1
3.4 3.4 1.1
[3]
Notes
M1: use of \(\mathrm{B}(10, p)\) FT their \(p\) to find at least 2 probabilities; may be unsimplified must see at least 2 probabilities for M1
M1: multiplying their binomial probabilities by 100 must see at least 2 expected values calculated for M1
A1: all correct to 1 dp or better; must add up to 100
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
close match between theoretical (or expected) and observed frequencies so model is a good fit
B1
3.5a
[1]
Notes
B1: FT dependent on award of M1M1 in (c) and all frequencies calculated
12Fig. 12.1 shows an excerpt from the pre-release material.
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
1
Sex
Age
Marital
Weight
Height
BMI
Waist
Pulse
2
Female
34
Married
60.3
173.4
20.05
82.5
74
3
Female
85
Widowed
64.7
161.2
24.9
#N/A
#N/A
4
Female
48
Divorced
100.6
171.4
34.24
105.6
92
5
Male
61
Married
70.9
169.5
24.68
92.2
70
6
Male
68
Divorced
96.8
181.6
29.35
112.9
68
Fig. 12.1
There was no data available for cell H3.
(a) Explain why #N/A is used when no data is available. [1]
Fig. 12.2 shows a scatter diagram of pulse rate against BMI (Body Mass Index) for females. All the available data was used.
Fig. 12.2
There are two outliers on the diagram.
(b) On the copy of Fig. 12.2 in the Printed Answer Booklet, ring these outliers. [1]
(c) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to explain whether either of these outliers should be removed. [2]
(d) State whether the diagram suggests there is any correlation between pulse rate and BMI. [1]
The product moment correlation coefficient between waist measurement, \(w\), in cm and BMI, \(b\), for females was found to be 0.912. All the available data was used.
(e) Explain why a model of the form \(w = mb + c\) for the relationship between waist measurement and BMI is likely to be appropriate. [1]
The LINEST function on a spreadsheet gives \(m = 2.16\) and \(c = 33.0\).
(f) Calculate an estimate of the value for cell G3 in Fig. 12.1. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
#N/A is used to stop the software reading the entry as zero
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: allow so that the cell is ignored oe or the software interprets #N/A as no data oe advantage
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(30.6, 128) and (1.3,88) ringed
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
outlier on extreme left oe should be removed as nobody could have a BMI this low oe
B1
2.4
outlier with (very) high pulse rate oe should not be removed as it is plausible oe
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
B1: need to refer to BMI being implausible advantage
B1: advantage
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
no correlation
B1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
B1: ignore other comments unless contradictory
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
because the value of pmcc is close to 1 or because there is strong correlation oe
For many years he has identified, at the start of the year, 32 days on which he will spend an hour counting the number of birds he sees in his garden.
He divides the year into four using the Meteorological Office definition of seasons. Each year he uses stratified sampling to identify the 32 days on which he will count the birds in his garden, drawn equally from the four seasons.
Ben’s data for 2019 are shown in the stem and leaf diagram in Fig. 10.1.
0
3 5 9 9 9
1
0 0 1 1 2 4 5 6 7 8 9
2
0 1 4 6 7 8 9
3
0 0 2 3
4
0 3 6
5
1
6
0
Fig. 10.1
(a) Suggest a reason why Ben chose to use stratified sampling instead of simple random sampling. [1]
(b) Describe the shape of the distribution. [1]
(c) Explain why the mode is not a useful measure of central tendency in this case. [1]
(d) For Ben’s sample, determine
the median,
the interquartile range.
[3]
Ben found a boxplot for the sample of size 32 he collected using stratified sampling in 2015.
The boxplot is shown in Fig. 10.2.
Fig. 10.2
In 2016 Ben replaced his hedge with a garden fence. Ben now believes that
he sees fewer birds in his garden,
the number of birds he sees in his garden is more variable.
(e) With reference to Fig. 10.2 and your answer to part (d), comment on whether there is any evidence to support Ben’s belief. [2]
Jane says she can tell that the data for 2015 is definitely uniformly distributed by looking at the boxplot.
(f) Explain why Jane is wrong. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
to account for seasonal variation in birds oe
or to account for different weather conditions which affects what birds are seen oe
B1
2.2b
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
positive skew cao
B1
1.2
[1]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg in lower quartile (or lower tail) eg much lower than median (or middle) oe eg frequency of 3 and others have frequency of 2 eg distribution is skewed (so median more appropriate)
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: NB mode is 9
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
median is 19.5
B1
1.1
LQ is between 8th and 9th value or UQ is between 24th and 25th value soi
M1
1.1
IQR = 30 – 11 = 19
A1
1.1
[3]
Notes
M1: allow for sight of 11 or 30
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
2015: \(32 \leqslant\) median \(\leqslant 34\), much bigger than (their 19.5) in 2019 which supports Ben’s first statement oe
B1
2.2b
2015: \(31 \leqslant\) IQR \(\leqslant 34\) was (much) bigger than (their 19) in 2019 which does not support Ben’s second statement oe
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
if B0B0 allow SC1 for true – median smaller in 2019 oe and false – IQR smaller in 2019 oe
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg other distributions are symmetrical (so could be eg Normal) oe
eg can’t tell how values distributed in each quartile oe
9 A company supplies computers to businesses. In the past the company has found that computers are kept by businesses for a mean time of 5 years before being replaced. Claud, the manager of the company, thinks that the mean time before replacing computers is now different.
(a) Describe how Claud could obtain a cluster sample of 120 computers used by businesses the company supplies. [1]
Claud decides to conduct a hypothesis test at the 5% level to test whether there is evidence to suggest that the mean time that businesses keep computers is not 5 years. He takes a random sample of 120 computers. Summary statistics for the length of time computers in this sample are kept are shown in Fig. 9.
Statistics
n
120
Mean
4.8855
σ
2.6941
s
2.7054
Σx
586.2566
Σx2
3735.1475
Min
0.1213
Q1
2.5472
Median
4.8692
Q3
7.0349
Max
9.9856
Fig. 9
(b)In this question you must show detailed reasoning.
State the hypotheses for this test, explaining why the alternative hypothesis takes the form it does.
Use a suitable distribution to carry out the test.
[8]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg randomly select \(N\) different businesses and then randomly select \(P\) computers from each business; may be implied by correct description
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: \(N \times P = 120\) where \(N\) and \(P\) are integers greater than 1. eg 20 and 6 or 15 and 8
\(\mathrm{H_1}\) takes this form as Claud is testing whether the mean length of time is different to 5 oe
B1
2.4
\(\mu\) is the population mean time for which computers are kept before being replaced
B1
2.5
use of \(\mathrm{N}\left(5, \frac{2.7054^2}{120}\right)\) to find \(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X} < 4.8855)\) or \(\mathrm{invNorm}\left(p, 5, \frac{2.7054}{\sqrt{120}}\right)\) where \(p = 0.025\) or 0.05; may be implied by 0.3215 or 4.51595… or 4.59377…
M1
3.3
\(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X} < 4.8855) =\) awrt 0.32
A1
1.1
\(0.32 > 0.025\) or \(4.8855 > 4.5(2)\)
M1
3.4
not significant or accept \(\mathrm{H_0}\) or do not reject \(\mathrm{H_0}\) or reject \(\mathrm{H_1}\)
A1FT
1.1
insufficient evidence to suggest (at 5% level) that the (population) mean length of time (computers are kept) is not 5 years
A1FT
2.2b
[8]
Notes
B1: allow any parameter apart from \(\bar{x}\) for population mean as long as clearly defined as (population) mean
after B marks M1A1M1A1A1 may be earned if working with 2.7054 rounded to 2 or more sf
M1: condone use of 2.6941 (may be rounded) instead of 2.7054 for M1, may be implied by 0.32076 or CR is \(\bar{X} < 4.51797\ldots\), but A1 not available or \(z = \dfrac{4.8855 - 5}{\frac{2.7054}{\sqrt{120}}}\) for M1
A1: or CR is \((\bar{X}) < 4.5 - 4.6\) awrt \(-0.46\) A1 (may be implied by \(-0.466\) or \(-0.465567\ldots\) if 2.6941 used)
M1: comparison of their probability with 0.025 or comparison of 4.8855 with their critical value from use of 0.025, as long as previous M1 awarded their \(-0.4636 > -1.96\) oe (corrected from the printed mark scheme: printed as \(-0.4436\)) M1 dep on award of previous M1
A1FT: may be embedded in conclusion in context
A1FT: do not allow eg conclude / prove / indicate or other assertive statement instead of suggest; A0 if answer spoiled
8 Rosella is carrying out an investigation into the age at which adults retire from work in the city where she lives. She collects a sample of size 50, ensuring this comprises of 25 randomly selected retired men and 25 randomly selected retired women.
(a) State the name of the sampling method she uses. [1]
Fig. 8.1 shows the data she obtains in a frequency table and Fig. 8.2 shows these data displayed in a histogram.
Age in years at retirement
45 –
50 –
55 –
60 –
65 –
70 –
75 – 80
Frequency density
0.4
1.8
2.4
2.2
1.8
1.2
0.2
Fig. 8.1
Fig. 8.2
(b) How many people in the sample are aged between 50 and 55? [1]
Rosella obtains a list of the names of all 4960 people who have retired in the city during the previous month.
(c) Describe how Rosella could collect a sample of size 200 from her list using
systematic sampling such that every item on the list could be selected,
simple random sampling.
[4]
Rosella collects two simple random samples, one of size 200 and one of size 500, from her list. The histograms in Fig. 8.3 show the data from the sample of size 200 on the left and the data from the sample of 500 on the right.
Fig. 8.3
(d) With reference to the histograms shown in Fig. 8.2 and Fig. 8.3, explain why it appears reasonable to model the age of retirement in this city using the Normal distribution. [1]
Summary statistics for the sample of 500 are shown in Fig. 8.4.
Statistics
n
500
Mean
60.0515
σ
6.5717
s
6.5783
Σx
30025.7601
Σx2
1824686.322
Min
36.0793
Q1
55.2573
Median
59.9202
Q3
64.4239
Max
81.742
Fig. 8.4
(e) Use an appropriate Normal model based on the information in Fig. 8.4 to estimate the number of people aged over 65 who retired in the city in the previous month. [4]
(f) Identify a limitation in using this model to predict the number of people aged over 65 retiring in the following month. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Quota sampling
B1
1.2
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
9
B1
1.1
[1]
Notes
B1: from \(5 \times 1.8\)
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
Systematic: select every 24th number on the list
M1
2.4
start randomly between \(n = 1\) and \(n \geqslant 184\) and stop when 200 have been selected (if \(n > 184\), must cycle through list)
A1
1.1
Simple random sampling: assign each item in the list a unique number (eg from 1 to 4960)
E1
2.4
generate random numbers until a sample of 200 has been selected soi
E1
1.1
[4]
Notes
M1:alternatively select every 25th number on the list alternatively select every 24.8th value on list, rounding as appropriate
A1:alternatively start randomly between \(n = 1\) and \(n \geqslant 25\), and cycle through the list again, stopping when 200 have been selected alternatively start randomly with any value on list. Cycle through the list repeatedly until 200 items have been selected
E1:alternatively allow any process where each member of the population has an equal chance of being selected
E1: allow any process where each possible sample has an equal chance of being selected
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
as the size of the sample increases, the shape of the distribution appears more and more “Normal” oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: must refer to shape and closer to Normal shape for larger sample
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
use of \(\mathrm{N}(60.0515,\ 6.5783^2)\) to find \(\mathrm{P}(X > 65)\)
M1
3.3
awrt 0.23
A1
3.4
\(4960 \times\) their 0.226
M1
3.1b
1121 or 1120 or 1119
A1
3.5a
[4]
Notes
M1: condone use of \(6.5717^2\) or parameters rounded to 3 sf M0 if continuity correction used or eg \(\mathrm{P}(X > 64)\) found
Mark scheme (f)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg there may be seasonal fluctuations such as teachers retiring in August
B1
3.5b
[1]
Notes
B1: allow any sensible reason in context do not allow eg mean and sd may be different
4 Fig. 4 shows a cumulative frequency diagram for the time spent revising mathematics by year 11 students at a certain school during a week in the summer term.
Fig. 4
(a) Use the diagram to estimate the median time spent revising mathematics by these students. [1]
A teacher comments that 90% of the students spent less than an hour revising mathematics during this week.
(b) Determine whether the information in the diagram supports this comment. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(23 \leqslant m \leqslant 29\)
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
no, \(p\)% spent less than an hour revising maths; or no, 90% spent less than m minutes revising maths
B1
2.4
[1]
Notes
B1: \(75 \leqslant p \leqslant 85\) \(75 \leqslant m \leqslant 100\) Allow eg \(x\) out of 200 is not 90% or 0.9 oe where \(150 \leqslant x \leqslant 170\)
14 The pre-release material includes data concerning crude death rates in different countries of the world. Fig. 14.1 shows some information concerning crude death rates in countries in Europe and in Africa.
Europe
Africa
\(n\)
48
56
minimum
6.28
3.58
lower quartile
8.50
7.31
median
9.53
8.71
upper quartile
11.41
11.93
maximum
14.46
14.89
Fig. 14.1
(a) Use your knowledge of the large data set to suggest a reason why the statistics in Fig. 14.1 refer to only 48 of the 51 European countries. [1]
(b) Use the information in Fig. 14.1 to show that there are no outliers in either data set. [3]
The crude death rate in Libya is recorded as 3.58 and the population of Libya is recorded as 6 411 776.
(c) Calculate an estimate of the number of deaths in Libya in a year. [1]
The median age in Germany is 46.5 and the crude death rate is 11.42. The median age in Cyprus is 36.1 and the crude death rate is 6.62.
(d) Explain why a country like Germany, with a higher median age than Cyprus, might also be expected to have a higher crude death rate than Cyprus. [1]
Fig. 14.2 shows a scatter diagram of median age against crude death rate for countries in Africa and Fig. 14.3 shows a scatter diagram of median age against crude death rate for countries in Europe.
Fig. 14.2Fig. 14.3
The rank correlation coefficient for the data shown in Fig. 14.2 is \(-0.281\,206\).
The rank correlation coefficient for the data shown in Fig. 14.3 is \(0.335\,215\).
(e) Compare and contrast what may be inferred about the relationship between median age and crude death rate in countries in Africa and in countries in Europe. [2]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
the data was not available for all countries oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
use of \(Q_1 - 1.5 \times (Q_3 - Q_1)\) and \(Q_3 + 1.5 \times (Q_3 - Q_1)\) seen for either set
M1
3.1b
\(4.135 < 6.28\) and \(15.775 > 14.46\)
A1
1.1
\(0.38 < 3.58\) and \(18.86 > 14.89\)
A1
1.1
[3]
Notes
if A0A0 allow SC1 for 4.135, 15.775, 0.38 and 18.86 all seen
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
22 954 isw
B1
3.1b
[1]
Notes
B1: allow 22 955, 22 950 or 23 000 NB \(6411776 \times \frac{3.58}{1000}\)
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
AO
there are almost certainly more “old” people in the population oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
AO
in African countries there is a negative association / relationship between (or negative correlation between the ranks of) median age and crude death rate, but in Europe there seems to be a positive association / relationship between (or positive correlation between the ranks of) median age and crude death rate
B1
2.4
the “association” / “relationship between” or “correlation between the ranks of” median age and crude death rate (appears to be) stronger in Europe
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
B1: do not allow “negative correlation” and / or “positive correlation”
B1: allow B1 both relationships are weak oe
comment comparing and contrasting type of relationship in both continents for B1, and one comment comparing and contrasting strength of relationship in both continents for B1 allow equivalent explanations in words eg as median age increases crude death rates decrease in Africa and similar for Europe
5 Fig. 5 shows the number of times that students at a sixth form college visited a recreational mathematics website during the first week of the summer term.
Number of visits to website
0
1
2
3
4
5
Number of students
24
38
17
12
4
2
Fig. 5
(a) State the value of the mid-range of the data. [1]
3 Fig. 3 shows the time Lorraine spent in hours, \(t\), answering e-mails during the working day. The data were collected over a number of months.
Time in hours, \(t\)
\(0 \leqslant t < 1\)
\(1 \leqslant t < 2\)
\(2 \leqslant t < 3\)
\(3 \leqslant t < 4\)
\(4 \leqslant t < 6\)
\(6 \leqslant t < 8\)
Number of days
28
36
42
31
24
12
Fig. 3
(a) Calculate an estimate of the mean time per day that Lorraine spent answering e-mails over this period. [1]
(b) Explain why your answer to part (a) is an estimate. [1]
When Lorraine accepted her job, she was told that the mean time per day spent answering e-mails would not be more than 3 hours.
(c) Determine whether, according to the data in Fig. 3, it is possible that the mean time per day Lorraine spends answering e-mails is in fact more than 3 hours. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
AO
2.8 to 2.81 BC
B1
1.1
[1]
Notes
NB 2.8063583815029..
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg the data is already grouped oe eg we do not have the original raw data oe eg we are using the mid-point of the intervals eg we are assuming the data are uniformly distributed across each interval oe
B1
2.4
[1]
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
AO
eg using upper class limit in each case gives mean is 3.4…so it is possible that mean is more than 3
B1
2.3
[1]
Notes
B1: or eg need 520 or more and using the upper limits gives 590 simply stating eg the mean could be 3.4 is insufficient
14 The pre-release material includes data on unemployment rates in different countries. A sample from this material has been taken. All the countries in the sample are in Europe. The data have been grouped and are shown in Fig 14.1.
Unemployment rate
0–
5–
10–
15–
20–
35–50
Frequency
15
21
5
5
2
2
Fig. 14.1
A cumulative frequency curve has been generated for the sample data using a spreadsheet. This is shown in Fig. 14.2.
Fig. 14.2
Hodge used Fig. 14.2 to estimate the median unemployment rate in Europe. He obtained the answer 5.0. The correct value for this sample is 6.9.
(i)
(A) There is a systematic error in the diagram.
Identify this error.
State how this error affects Hodge’s estimate.
[2]
(B) There is another factor which has affected Hodge’s estimate.
Identify this factor.
State how this factor affects Hodge’s estimate.
[2]
(ii) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to give another reason why any estimation of the median unemployment rate in Europe may be unreliable. [1]
(iii) Use your knowledge of the pre-release material to explain why it is very unlikely that the sample has been randomly selected from the pre-release material. [1]
The scatter diagram shown in Fig. 14.3 shows the unemployment rate and life expectancy at birth for the 47 countries in the sample for which this information is available.
Fig. 14.3
The product moment correlation coefficient for the 47 items in the sample is \(-0.2607\). The \(p\)-value associated with \(r = -0.2607\) and \(n = 47\) is 0.0383.
(iv) Does this information suggest that there is an association between unemployment rate and life expectancy at birth in countries in Europe? [2]
Hodge uses the spreadsheet tools to obtain the equation of a line of best fit for this data.
(v) The unemployment rate in Kosovo is 35.3, but there is no data available on life expectancy. Is it reasonable to use Hodge’s line of best fit to estimate life expectancy at birth in Kosovo? [1]
Mark scheme (i)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(A) the cumulative frequencies have been plotted against the mid-points of the class intervals,
B1
2.4
mis-plotting [at centre of each class] reduces estimate (by 2.5) oe
B1
2.4
[2]
(B) grouped data has been used
B1
2.4
grouping has slightly reduced the error introduced by misplotting (because the error is less than 2.5)
B1
2.4
[2]
Notes
(B)
B1: or eg Hodge used the graph (instead of the raw data)
Mark scheme (ii)
Scheme
Marks
AO
percentage unemployment is often estimated oe
E1
2.4
[1]
Notes
E1: allow data (on percentage unemployment) is not available for all countries in Europe oe
Mark scheme (iii)
Scheme
Marks
AO
there are many other countries in the pre-release material; it is very unlikely that a random sample would only include European countries.
E1
2.4
[1]
Mark scheme (iv)
Scheme
Marks
AO
negative correlation / association (may be embedded)
B1
2.2b
comparison of \(p\)-value with 0.05 or 0.01 or other appropriate significance level and supporting comment
B1
2.2b
[2]
Notes
if B0B0 allow SC2 for eg comment on no significant association justified by comparison of \(p\)-value with appropriate significance level (eg 0.025)
Mark scheme (v)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(even though this is interpolation), the scatter / weak correlation / presence of an outlier would suggest that the use of a line of best fit is inappropriate
E1
2.2b
[1]
Notes
E1: allow explanation based on the value for Kosovo being an outlier or on it lying in the (large) gap in the scatter
9 At the end of each school term at North End College all the science classes in year 10 are given a test. The marks out of 100 achieved by members of set 1 are shown in Fig. 9.
3
5
4
0 9
5
2 3 6
6
0 1 3 5 6
7
0 1 2 5 6 8 9 9
8
3 4 6 6 8 8 9
9
5 5 5 6 7
Key 5 | 2 represents a mark of 52
Fig. 9
(i) Describe the shape of the distribution. [1]
(ii) The teacher for set 1 claimed that a typical student in his class achieved a mark of 95. How did he justify this statement? [1]
(iii) Another teacher said that the average mark in set 1 is 76. How did she justify this statement? [1]
Benson’s mark in the test is 35. If the mark achieved by any student is an outlier in the lower tail of the distribution, the student is moved down to set 2.
(iv) Determine whether Benson is moved down to set 2. [2]
Mark scheme (i)
Scheme
Marks
AO
negative skew
B1
1.2
[1]
Mark scheme (ii)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(used) the mode
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (iii)
Scheme
Marks
AO
(used) the median
B1
1.1
[1]
Mark scheme (iv)
Scheme
Marks
AO
\(61 - 1.5 \times (88 - 61)\)
M1
2.1
\(20.5 < 35\) [so 35 is not an outlier] so he does not move to set 2
A1
2.2b
[2]
Notes
Alternatively, \(73.61 - 2 \times 17.03\) \(39.6 > 35\) [so 35 is an outlier] so he moves to set 2
allow eg only marks below 20.5 (or 39.6) would lead to a move down plus correct conclusion
5. Huw investigates the opinion of the public about their local primary schools. He visits his town centre and administers a questionnaire to 120 people over the course of several days.
(a) What type of sampling is this? [1]
(b) How could Huw’s sampling be improved? [1]
Huw wishes to investigate the relationship between the population and the number of primary schools in a county. He searches the internet for data and selects a random sample of 24 counties from the UK. He produces the following scatter diagram.
The equation of the regression line for this dataset is given by
\[\text{Number of Primary Schools}=22{\cdot}7+0{\cdot}2406\times\text{County Population (in 1000s)}.\]
(c) State a limitation of this regression line. [1]
(d) Calculate an estimate for the number of primary schools in a county with a population of 889 000. [2]
(e) Statisticians often say, “Correlation does not imply causation”. Comment on this statement in this context. [1]
Mark scheme (a)
Scheme
Marks
Comments
Opportunity sampling.
B1
Mark scheme (b)
Scheme
Marks
Comments
Valid comment. eg. Go to different areas, as this is a biased sample. Many of his responders will be from the same community.
B1
Mark scheme (c)
Scheme
Marks
Comments
Appropriate statement. eg. The line is only valid for predicting the number of primary schools in counties with populations between approximately 100,000 and 2,800,000.
E1
Allow: The model predicts that a county with a population of 0 has about 23 primary schools
Mark scheme (d)
Scheme
Marks
Comments
\(\text{No. of Primary Schools}=22.7+0.2406\times889\)
M1
M0 for using 889,000
\(=237\text{ schools}\)
A1
A0 for 236.5934
Mark scheme (e)
Scheme
Marks
Comments
Appropriate comment. eg. It is likely that number of primary schools IS caused by a greater population (because local authorities are obliged to provide education).
Closing a school doesn’t automatically decrease the county population (as pupils would be absorbed into other local schools)
Increasing the county population doesn’t automatically increase the number of schools, (but they are clearly related)
E1
Do not accept a categorical statement of causation
We'd like to use Google Analytics cookies to count visits and see which pages help most. They're optional, and the site works exactly the same either way. Privacy policy