Your progress
Ticks are kept only in this browser: clearing your browsing data or changing device loses them. · ·

June 2018 Paper 1 Q14

AQACurrent spec7 marksProofTrigonometry

14 Some students are trying to prove an identity for \(\sin(A + B)\).

They start by drawing two right-angled triangles \(ODE\) and \(OEF\), as shown.

Right-angled triangle ODE with the right angle at D, and right-angled triangle OEF with the right angle at E drawn on OE; angle DOE = A and angle EOF = B at O; R on OD directly below F, with the dashed vertical line FR crossing OE at Q, and P on FR level with E, joined to E by a dashed line

The students’ incomplete proof continues,

Let angle \(DOE = A\) and angle \(EOF = B\).

In triangle \(OFR\),

Line 1\(\sin(A + B) = \dfrac{RF}{OF}\)
Line 2\(= \dfrac{RP + PF}{OF}\)
Line 3\(= \dfrac{DE}{OF} + \dfrac{PF}{OF}\) since \(DE = RP\)
Line 4\(= \dfrac{DE}{\ldots\ldots} \times \dfrac{\ldots\ldots}{OF} + \dfrac{PF}{EF} \times \dfrac{EF}{OF}\)
Line 5\(= \ldots\ldots\ldots\ldots + \cos A\sin B\)
(a) Explain why \(\dfrac{PF}{EF} \times \dfrac{EF}{OF}\) in Line 4 leads to \(\cos A\sin B\) in Line 5 [2 marks]
(b) Complete Line 4 and Line 5 to prove the identity
Line 4\(= \dfrac{DE}{\ldots\ldots} \times \dfrac{\ldots\ldots}{OF} + \dfrac{PF}{EF} \times \dfrac{EF}{OF}\)
Line 5\(= \ldots\ldots\ldots\ldots\ldots\ldots\ldots\ldots + \cos A\sin B\)
[1 mark]
(c) Explain why the argument used in part (a) only proves the identity when \(A\) and \(B\) are acute angles. [1 mark]
(d) Another student claims that by replacing \(B\) with \(-B\) in the identity for \(\sin(A + B)\) it is possible to find an identity for \(\sin(A - B)\).

Assuming the identity for \(\sin(A + B)\) is correct for all values of \(A\) and \(B\), prove a similar result for \(\sin(A - B)\). [3 marks]