June 2023 Unit 4 Q7
7. A rod \(AB\), of mass 20 kg and length 3·2 m, is resting horizontally in equilibrium on two smooth supports at points \(X\) and \(Y\), where \(AX=0{\cdot}4\) m and \(AY=2{\cdot}4\) m. A particle of mass 8 kg is attached to the rod at a point \(C\), where \(BC=0{\cdot}2\) m. The reaction of the support at \(Y\) is four times the reaction of the support at \(X\).
You may not assume that the rod \(AB\) is uniform.
(a)
(i) Find the magnitude of each of the reaction forces exerted on the rod at \(X\) and \(Y\).
(ii) Show that the weight of the rod acts at the midpoint of \(AB\). [7]
(b) Is it now possible to determine whether the rod is uniform or non-uniform? Give a reason for your answer. [1]

| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (i) Resolve vertically \(R_X+R_Y=20g+8g\) \((=196+78{\cdot}4=274{\cdot}4)\) | M1 | Dim. correct, all forces/terms |
| \(R_X+4R_X=28g\) OR \(\frac{1}{4}R_Y+R_Y=28g\) | A1 | cao |
| \(R_X=\frac{28}{5}g=5{\cdot}6g\ \text{(N)}\ =54{\cdot}88\ \text{(N)}\) \(R_Y=4\times\frac{28}{5}g=22{\cdot}4g\ \text{(N)}\ =219{\cdot}52\ \text{(N)}\) | A1 | cao, both values |
| (ii) Moments about \(X\) | M1 | Dim. correct equation attempted, oe, no missing forces |
| \(20g\times x+8g\times 2{\cdot}6=R_Y\times 2\) | A1 | Correct equation with unknown distance, FT \(R_Y\) (if substituted) |
| \(196\times x+78{\cdot}4\times 2{\cdot}6=R_Y\times 2\) \(196\times x+203{\cdot}84=R_Y\times 2\) | B1 | Any correct moment with pivot clearly indicated |
| \(x=1{\cdot}2\) \(\therefore\ 0{\cdot}4+1{\cdot}2=1{\cdot}6\ \text{(m)}=\text{midpoint}\) | A1 | cao, convincing |
| [7] |
Further Notes: Alternative Moments Solutions
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Alternative Moments Solutions | B1 | Any correct moment with pivot clearly indicated |
| Moments about \(A\) | M1 | Dim. correct equation, oe, no missing forces |
| \(R_X\times 0{\cdot}4+R_Y\times 2{\cdot}4=20g\times x^{\prime}+8g\times 3\) | A1 | Correct equation with unknown distance FT \(R_i\) (if substituted) |
| Substitution of both \(R_X\) and \(R_Y\) leading to correct midpoint \(x^{\prime}=1{\cdot}6\) | A1 | Nothing to add in this case so bod |
| Moments about \(Y\) | M1 | Dim. correct equation, oe, no missing forces |
| \(R_X\times 2+8g\times 0{\cdot}6=20g\times x^{\prime}\) | A1 | Correct equation with unknown distance FT \(R_i\) (if substituted) |
| Substitution of \(R_X\) leading to correct midpoint \(x^{\prime}=0{\cdot}8\qquad\text{midpoint}=0{\cdot}8+0{\cdot}8=1{\cdot}6\) | A1 | |
| Moments about \(B\) | M1 | Dim. correct equation, oe, no missing forces |
| \(R_X\times 2{\cdot}8+R_Y\times 0{\cdot}8=20g\times x^{\prime}+8g\times 0{\cdot}2\) | A1 | Correct equation with unknown distance FT \(R_i\) (if substituted) |
| Substitution of both \(R_X\) and \(R_Y\) leading to correct midpoint \(x^{\prime}=1{\cdot}6\) | A1 | Nothing to add in this case so bod |
| Moments about \(C\) | M1 | Dim. correct equation, oe, no missing forces |
| \(R_X\times 2{\cdot}6+R_Y\times 0{\cdot}6=20g\times x^{\prime}\) | A1 | Correct equation with unknown distance FT \(R_i\) (if substituted) |
| Substitution of both \(R_X\) and \(R_Y\) leading to correct midpoint \(x=1{\cdot}4\qquad\text{midpoint}=1{\cdot}4+0{\cdot}2=1{\cdot}6\) | A1 | |
| Moments about Centre of mass | M1 | Dim. correct equation, oe, no missing forces |
| \(R_X\times x^{\prime}+8g\times(2{\cdot}6-x^{\prime})=R_Y\times(2-x^{\prime})\) | A1 | Correct equation with unknown distance FT \(R_i\) (if substituted) |
| Substitution of both \(R_X\) and \(R_Y\) leading to correct midpoint \(x^{\prime}=1{\cdot}2\) | A1 |
Corrected by Westie's Workshop
- The board's mark scheme printed “\(x'=0\)”. Changed to “\(x'=1{\cdot}2\)” because solving the printed equation gives \(x'=1{\cdot}2\), the distance of the centre of mass from \(X\) (\(0{\cdot}4+1{\cdot}2=1{\cdot}6\), the midpoint).
Original: see the board's mark scheme PDF (link above).
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Not possible and Reason: Weight may act at the centre of a non-uniform rod | E1 | |
| [1] | ||
| Total for Question 7 | 8 |