June 2023 Unit 4 Q4
4. A bakery produces large loaves with masses, in grams, that are normally distributed with mean \(\mu\) and variance \(\sigma^2\).
It is found that 11% of the large loaves weigh more than 805 g and that 20% of the large loaves weigh less than 795 g.
The bakery also produces small loaves with masses, in grams, that are normally distributed with mean 400 and standard deviation 9.
Following a change of management at the bakery, a customer suspects that the mean mass of the small loaves has decreased. The customer weighs the next 15 small loaves that he purchases and calculates their mean mass to be 397 g.
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Sight of \(\frac{805-\mu}{\sigma}\) or \(\frac{795-\mu}{\sigma}\) | M1 | Attempt at standardising. May be implied by either correct equation. |
| \(P\left(Z\geqslant\frac{805-\mu}{\sigma}\right)=0.11\) OR \(P\left(Z\leqslant\frac{805-\mu}{\sigma}\right)=0.89\) OR \(P\left(Z\leqslant\frac{795-\mu}{\sigma}\right)=0.2\) | m1 | m1 for at least one correct probability statement. May be implied by either correct equation. |
| Sight of \(1.2265\) AND \(-0.8416\) | B1 | CAO May be implied by both correct equations. |
| \(\dfrac{805-\mu}{\sigma}=1.2265\) | A1 | 1.227 from tables |
| \(\dfrac{795-\mu}{\sigma}=-0.8416\) | A1 | –0.842 from tables |
| \(\dfrac{795-\mu}{-0.8416}=\dfrac{805-\mu}{1.2265}\) | m1 | m1 for eliminating one variable Dependent on M1 |
| OR \(805-1.2265\sigma=795+0.8416\sigma\) | (m1) | |
| \(\mu=799\) | A1 | CAO Accept awrt 799.0 or 799.1 (when rounding to 1dp) |
| \(\sigma=4.84\) | A1 | CAO Accept awrt 4.8 or 4.9 (when rounding to 1dp) Correct answers with no working throughout earn no marks. |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (Let \(\mu\) be the population mean mass of the loaves in grams) | Note: A two tailed test can score B0B1M1A1m1A0. | |
| \(H_0:\mu=400\qquad H_1:\mu\lt 400\) | B1 | Allow other letters if defined. Allow worded hypotheses (must refer to population) B0 for \(H_0:\text{mean}=400\), must imply/refer to population. B0 for omission of \(\mu\), or \(\bar{x}\) in place of \(\mu\). B0 for a non-strict inequality in \(H_1\). |
| \(\bar{X}\sim\mathrm{N}(400,\frac{9^2}{15})\) (under \(H_0\)) | B1 | Distribution of \(\bar{X}\) si. FT their hypotheses for 2nd B1 only. |
| Method 1 (\(p\)-value with calculator): \(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X}\lt 397|H_0)\) | M1 | M1 for attempt to find \(P(\bar{X}\lt 397)\) with correct mean and variance for \(\bar{X}\). Condone omission of given \(H_0\). |
| \(=0.098352\) | A1 | Condone 0.098. |
| Since \(0.0983\gt 0.05\) there is insufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | m1 | Dependent on M1. Correct comparison required. Context may imply do not reject \(H_0\). NOTE: the \(p\)-value for a 2-tailed test is 0.1967, or may see 0.098352 compared with 0.025. Do not allow comparison with 0.025 if using a one-tailed test. |
| There is insufficient evidence to suggest that the mean mass of the loaves has decreased. | A1 | CSO. Do not allow categorical statements (condone categorical statements if “insufficient evidence” seen in m1 statement). Allow equivalent statements, e.g. there is insufficient evidence to support the customer’s suspicion. Condone weight in place of mass. A0 for conclusion not in context (e.g. mean has decreased). A0 for a two-tailed conclusion (e.g. mass has not changed). |
Alternative (Method 2: \(p\)-value with standardising)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| \(\mathrm{P}\left(Z\lt\dfrac{397-400}{\frac{9}{\sqrt{15}}}\right)=\mathrm{P}(Z\lt -1.29)\) | (M1) | M1 for either probability statement seen. Sight of -1.29 earns M1 only if using the p-value method. Must use \(\sigma_{\bar X}=9/\sqrt{15}\) for M1. |
| \((=1-0.90147)\) \(=0.09853\) | (A1) | May evaluate \(P\left(Z\lt -\frac{\sqrt{15}}{3}\right)=0.098352\) using the calculator. |
| Since \(0.0985\gt 0.05\) there is insufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | (m1) | Dependent on M1. Correct comparison required. Context may imply do not reject \(H_0\). NOTE: the \(p\)-value for a 2-tailed test is 0.19706, or may see 0.09853 compared with 0.025. Do not allow comparison with 0.025 if using a one-tailed test. |
Alternative (Method 3: critical value with calculator)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| CV = 396.18 (CR is \(\bar{X}\lt 396.18\)) | (M1A1) | M1 implied by correct answer from calculator or for correctly standardising: \(\dfrac{\mathrm{CV}-400}{\frac{9}{\sqrt{15}}}=-1.645\). Must use \(\sigma_{\bar X}=9/\sqrt{15}\) for M1. |
| Since \(397\gt 396.18\) there is insufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | (m1) | Dependent on M1. FT their CV. Correct comparison required. NOTE: the CVs for a 2-tailed test are 395.45 and 404.55 |
Alternative (Method 4: critical value with standardising)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| \(\mathrm{TS}=\dfrac{397-400}{\frac{9}{\sqrt{15}}}\) | (M1) | Must use \(\sigma_{\bar X}=9/\sqrt{15}\) for M1. |
| \(=-1.29\) | (A1) | \(-1.29\) earns M1A1 if used as a TS. |
| Since \(-1.29\gt -1.645\) there is insufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | (m1) | Dependent on M1. FT their TS. Correct comparison required. NOTE: for a 2-tailed test, comparison with \(-1.96\) is required |
Corrected by Westie's Workshop
- The board's mark scheme printed “0.09352”. Changed to “0.098352” because the one-tailed p-value for Method 1 is 0.098352 (printed above; doubled it is 0.1967).
Original: see the board's mark scheme PDF (link above).
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Valid assumption. e.g. Assume that the 15 loaves constitute a random sample. e.g. Assume the 15 loaves are independent. e.g. There wasn’t a fault in production. | E1 | Ignore spurious comments. Condone “the masses of the loaves are (still) normally distributed”. Comments such as “this isn’t a bad batch” or “this isn’t a faulty batch” are considered equivalent to “constitute a random sample”, and earn E1. E0 for “weighed correctly” E0 for “uses the same ingredients” or “uses the same recipe” (E0 for any comment that implies the methodology remains the same) E0 for “all loaves made by new management” E0 for “they calculated the mean correctly” |
| Total [15] |