June 2022 Unit 4 Q4
4. In a driving simulator, the stopping distances, in metres, for cars travelling at 20 mph and 30 mph can be modelled by normal distributions with means and standard deviations shown in the table below.
| Stopping distance (metres) | ||
|---|---|---|
| Travelling at | Mean | Standard deviation |
| 20 mph | 12 | 3·5 |
| 30 mph | 23 | 3·8 |
A campaigner for keeping the speed limit at 30 mph rather than reducing it to 20 mph in built-up areas claims that stopping distances are less than those stated above. He takes a random sample of 40 first-year university students and finds their mean stopping distance is 21·5 metres at 30 mph.
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (Let the random variable \(W\) be the stopping distance in metres of a car travelling at 30mph.) \(W\sim\mathrm{N}(23,3.8^2)\) \(\mathrm{P}(W\lt 30)=0.96727\) | M1A1 | M1 implied by correct answer from calculator or for correctly standardising \(Z=\frac{30-23}{3.8}=1.84\). Gives 0.96712 from tables. 3sf required (0.97 earns M1A0). |
Part (a) Total | [2] |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (Let the random variable \(X\) be the stopping distance in metres of a car travelling at 20mph.) \(X\sim\mathrm{N}(12,3.5^2)\) \(\mathrm{P}(X\gt 20)=0.011135\) | M1 | Either method correct (see note above). M1 for 2.29 or -0.79 if standardised. |
| \(\mathrm{P}(W\gt 20)=0.78508\) | A1 | A1 for both probabilities, with at least one probability to 3sf. |
| \(\dfrac{0.78508}{0.011135}\) | M1 | Alternatively, \(\frac{0.78508}{50}\) or \(0.011135\times 50\). FT their probabilities. Condone division of \(P(X\lt 20)\) by \(P(W\lt 20)\) that leads to 4.6. |
| Appropriate conclusion with a valid justification, e.g., You’re about 70 times more likely to collide travelling at 30mph than 20mph, so Dafydd is incorrect. | A1 | Allow e.g., \(0.0157016\neq 0.011135\) or \(0.55675\neq 0.78508\) so Dafydd is incorrect. FT their calculation for possible M1A1. |
Part (b) Total | [4] |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (Let \(\mu\) be the population mean stopping distances for cars travelling at 30mph) \(H_0:\mu=23\) \(H_1:\mu\lt 23\) | B1 | Allow other letters if defined. Allow worded hypotheses. B0 for \(H_0\): mean \(=23\), must imply or refer to population. B0 for omission of \(\mu\) or use of \(\bar{x}\) B0 for a non-strict inequality in \(H_1\). |
| \(\bar{X}\sim\mathrm{N}\left(23,\frac{3.8^2}{40}\right)\) under \(H_0\) | B1 | Distribution of \(\bar{X}\) si (condone if used correctly). FT their hypotheses for 2nd B1 only |
| \(\mathrm{P}(\bar{X}\lt 21.5\mid H_0)\) | M1 | M1 for \(\mathrm{P}\left(Z\lt\dfrac{21.5-23}{\frac{3.8}{\sqrt{40}}}\right)=\mathrm{P}(Z\lt -2.50)\), \(-2.50\) scores M1 only if using the p-value method |
| \(=0.0062706\ldots\) | A1 | 0.00621 from tables, M0A0 for use of 21.5 and 23 the wrong way around. |
| Since \(0.00627\lt 0.01\), there is sufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | m1 | Dependent on previous M1. FT their p-value. m0 for incorrect comparison such as p-value is in the critical region. |
| There is sufficient evidence to suggest that stopping distances are less than previously thought. | A1 | CSO (correct solution only). Do not allow categorical statements (condone categorical if “sufficient evidence” seen in m1 statement). Allow equivalent statements, e.g., there is sufficient evidence to support the claim. |
Part (c) Total | [6] |
Notes
The scheme prints two alternatives for the M1, A1 and m1 marks (in place of the p-value method); the B1 B1 marks and the final A1 are as in the main table.
Alternative 1
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| CV = 21.602 | (M1A1) | M1 implied by correct answer from calculator or for correctly standardising \(\dfrac{\mathrm{CV}-23}{\frac{3.8}{\sqrt{40}}}=-2.3263\) |
| Since \(21.5\lt 21.602\), there is sufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | (m1) | Dependent on previous M1. FT their CV. m0 for incorrect comparison such as CV is less than significance level. |
Alternative 2
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| TS = \(\dfrac{21.5-23}{\frac{3.8}{\sqrt{40}}}\) | (M1) | |
| \(=-2.50\) | (A1) | \(-2.50\) scores M1A1 if used as a TS |
| Since \(-2.50\lt -2.326\), there is sufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\). | (m1) | Dependent on previous M1. FT their TS. m0 for incorrect comparison such as the TS is less than significance level. Condone accept \(H_1\). |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Valid limitation, e.g. These are likely to be mostly young people which may mean they have a faster reaction time than average. | E1 | Must address (young people having) faster reaction times. Condone reference to bias in the sample. Minimum response condoned “Only first year students used” or “Inexperienced drivers”. Do not allow reference to sample size. Do not allow reference to driving slower. |
Part (d) Total | [1] | |
| Total for Question 4 | 13 |