SMC 2017 Q17
17. Amy, Beth and Claire each has some sweets. Amy gives one third of her sweets to Beth. Beth gives one third of all the sweets she now has to Claire. Then Claire gives one third of all the sweets she now has to Amy. All the girls end up having the same number of sweets.
Claire begins with 40 sweets. How many sweets does Beth have originally?
- A 20
- B 30
- C 40
- D 50
- E 60
Senior Mathematical Challenge 2017, Question 17. © UK Mathematics Trust. Original paper on ukmt.org.uk
Answer: D 50
Amy's number of sweets is a multiple of 3, so let her start with \(3a\) sweets. Once Amy has passed on \(a\) of them, Beth's number of sweets must be a multiple of 3. Likewise, after Beth passes on sweets to Claire, Claire's number of sweets must become a multiple of 3. Since \(40 = 3 \times 13 + 1\), Beth must pass on \(3b - 1\) sweets for some \(b\). So Beth must have had \(9b - 3\) sweets after receiving the \(a\) sweets from Amy and hence \(9b - 3 - a\) to start with. This allows us to fill in the table:
| Amy | Beth | Claire | |
| originally | \(3a\) | \(9b - 3 - a\) | 40 |
| after Amy's gift to Beth | \(2a\) | \(9b - 3\) | 40 |
| after Beth's gift to Claire | \(2a\) | \(6b - 2\) | \(3b + 39\) |
| after Claire's gift to Amy | \(2a + b + 13\) | \(6b - 2\) | \(2b + 26\) |
As the girls end up with the same number of sweets, \(6b - 2 = 2b + 26\) and so \(b = 7\). As \(6 \times 7 - 2\) and \(2 \times 7 + 26\) both equal 40, the girls each have 40 sweets at the end. Hence Amy's finishing number \(2a + 7 + 13 = 40\) so \(a = 10\). Then Beth's original number is \(9 \times 7 - 10 - 3 = 50\).
Solution © UK Mathematics Trust, from the SMC 2017 solutions. Longer versions with investigations: Solutions and investigations (PDF).