M1 June 2006 Q5
5.

A steel girder \(AB\) has weight 210 N. It is held in equilibrium in a horizontal position by two vertical cables. One cable is attached to the end \(A\). The other cable is attached to the point \(C\) on the girder, where \(AC = 90\) cm, as shown in Figure 3. The girder is modelled as a uniform rod, and the cables as light inextensible strings.
Given that the tension in the cable at \(C\) is twice the tension in the cable at \(A\), find
A small load of weight \(W\) newtons is attached to the girder at \(B\). The load is modelled as a particle. The girder remains in equilibrium in a horizontal position. The tension in the cable at \(C\) is now three times the tension in the cable at \(A\).

| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| \(R + 2R = 210 \;\Rightarrow\; R = 70\) N | M1 A1 |
| (2) |
Notes
Note that they can take moments legitimately about many points
(a) M1 for a valid method to get \(R\) (almost always resolving!)
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| e.g. M(\(A\)): \(140 \times 90 = 210 \times d\) | M1 A1ft |
| \(\Rightarrow d = 60 \;\Rightarrow\; AB = 120\) cm | M1 A1 |
| (4) |
Notes
(b) 1st M1 for a valid moments equation
2nd M1 for complete solution to find \(AB\) (or verification)
Allow ‘verification’, e.g. showing \(140 \times 90 = 210 \times 60\) M1 A1
\(1260 = 1260\) QED M1 A1

| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| \(4S = 210 + W\) | M1 A1 |
| e.g. M(\(B\)): \(S \times 120 + 3S \times 30 = 210 \times 60\) | M1 A2,1,0 |
| Solve \(\rightarrow\) (\(S = 60\) and) \(W = 30\) | M1 A1 |
| (7) | |
| (13 marks) |
Notes
(c) In both equations, allow whatever they think \(S\) is in their equations for full marks (e.g. if using \(S = 70\)).
2nd M1 A2 is for a moments equation (which may be about any one of 4+ points!)
1st M1 A1 is for a second equation (resolving or moments)
If they have two moments equations, given M1 A2 if possible for the best one
2 M marks only available without using \(S = 70\).
If take mass as 210 (hence use \(210g\)) consistently: treat as MR, i.e. deduct up to two A marks and treat rest as f.t. (Answers all as given \(= 9.8\)). But allow full marks in (b) (\(g\)’s should all cancel and give correct result).