C2 June 2015 Q9
9. A solid glass cylinder, which is used in an expensive laser amplifier, has a volume of \(75\pi\) cm3.
The cost of polishing the surface area of this glass cylinder is £2 per cm2 for the curved surface area and £3 per cm2 for the circular top and base areas.
Given that the radius of the cylinder is \(r\) cm,
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| Either: (Cost of polishing top and bottom (two circles) is )\(3 \times 2\pi r^2\) or (Cost of polishing curved surface area is) \(2 \times 2\pi rh\) or both - just need to see at least one of these products | B1 |
| Uses volume to give \((h =)\dfrac{75\pi}{\pi r^2}\) or \((h =)\dfrac{75}{r^2}\) (simplified) (if \(V\) is misread – see below) | B1ft |
| \((C) = 6\pi r^2 + 4\pi r\left(\dfrac{75}{r^2}\right)\) Substitutes expression for \(h\) into area or cost expression of form \(Ar^2 + Brh\) | M1 |
| \(C = 6\pi r^2 + \dfrac{300\pi}{r}\) * | A1* |
| (4) |
Notes
(a) B1: States \(3 \times 2\pi r^2\) or states \(2 \times 2\pi rh\)
B1ft: Obtains a correct expression for \(h\) in terms of \(r\) (ft only follows misread of \(V\))
M1: Substitutes their expression for \(h\) into area or cost expression of form \(Ar^2 + Brh\)
A1*: Had correct expression for \(C\) and achieves given answer in part (a) including “\(C\) =” or “Cost=” and no errors seen such as \(C\) = area expression without multiples of (£)3 and (£)2 at any point. Cost and area must be perfectly distinguished at all stages for this A mark.
N.B. Candidates using Curved Surface Area \(= \dfrac{2V}{r}\) - please send to review
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| \(\left\{\dfrac{\mathrm{d}C}{\mathrm{d}r} =\right\}\ 12\pi r - \dfrac{300\pi}{r^2}\) or \(12\pi r - 300\pi r^{-2}\) (then isw) | M1 A1 ft |
| \(12\pi r - \dfrac{300\pi}{r^2} = 0\) so \(r^k =\) value where \(k = \pm 2, \pm 3, \pm 4\) | dM1 |
| Use cube root to obtain \(r = \left(\textit{their } \tfrac{300}{12}\right)^{\frac{1}{3}}\) \((= 2.92)\)- allow \(r = 3\), and thus \(C =\) | ddM1 |
| Then \(C\) = awrt 483 or 484 | A1cao |
| (5) |
Notes
(b) M1: Attempts to differentiate as evidenced by at least one term differentiated correctly
A1ft: Correct derivative – allow \(12\pi r - 300\pi r^{-2}\) then isw if the power is misinterpreted (ft only for misread)
dM1: Sets their \(\dfrac{\mathrm{d}C}{\mathrm{d}r}\) to 0, and obtains \(r^k =\) value where \(k\) = 2, 3 or 4 (needs correct collection of powers of \(r\) from their original derivative expression – allow errors dividing by 12π)
ddM1: Uses cube root to find \(r\) or see \(r\) = awrt 3 as evidence of cube root and substitutes into correct expression for \(C\) to obtain value for \(C\)
A1: Accept awrt 483 or 484
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| \(\left\{\dfrac{\mathrm{d}^2C}{\mathrm{d}r^2} =\right\}\ 12\pi + \dfrac{600\pi}{r^3} \gt 0\) so minimum | B1ft |
| (1) | |
| [10] |
Notes
(c) B1ft: Finds correct expression for \(\dfrac{\mathrm{d}^2C}{\mathrm{d}r^2}\) and deduces value of \(\dfrac{\mathrm{d}^2C}{\mathrm{d}r^2} \gt 0\) so minimum (\(r\) may have been wrong)
OR checks gradient to left and right of 2.92 and shows gradient goes from negative to zero to positive so minimum
OR checks value of \(C\) to left and right of 2.92 and shows that \(C\) > 483 so deduces minimum ( i.e. uses shape of graph) Only ft on misread of \(V\) for each ft mark (see below)
Misread of the volume
N..B. Some candidates have misread the volume as 75 instead of \(75\pi\).
Following this misread candidates cannot legitimately obtain the printed answer in part (a). Either they obtain \(C = 6\pi r^2 + \dfrac{300}{r}\) or they “fudge” their working to appear to give the printed answer.
The policy for a misread is to subtract 2 marks from A or B marks. In this case the A mark is to be subtracted from part (a) and the final A mark is to be subtracted from part (b)
The maximum mark for part (a) following this misread is 3 marks. The award is B1 B1 M1 A0 as a maximum.
(a) B1: as before
B1: Uses volume to give \((h =)\dfrac{75}{\pi r^2}\)
M1: \((C) = 6\pi r^2 + 4\pi r\left(\dfrac{75}{\pi r^2}\right)\)
A0: Printed answer is not obtained without error
Most Candidates may then adopt the printed answer and gain up to full marks for the rest of the question so 9 of the 10 marks maximum in all.
Any candidate who proceeds with their answer \(C = 6\pi r^2 + \dfrac{300}{r}\) may be awarded up to 4 marks in part (b). These are M1A1dM1ddM1A0 and then the candidate may also be awarded the B1 mark in part (c). So 8 of the 10 marks maximum in all.
(b) M1 A1: \(\left\{\dfrac{\mathrm{d}C}{\mathrm{d}r} =\right\}\ 12\pi r - \dfrac{300}{r^2}\) or \(12\pi r - 300r^{-2}\) (then isw)
dM1: \(12\pi r - \dfrac{300}{r^2} = 0\) so \(r^k =\) value where \(k\) = 2, 3 or 4 or \(12\pi r - \dfrac{300}{r^2} = 0\) so \(r^k =\) value
ddM1: Use cube root to obtain \(r = \left(\textit{their } \tfrac{300}{12\pi}\right)^{\frac{1}{3}}\) \((= 1.996)\)- allow \(r = 2\), and thus \(C = \ldots\) must use \(C = 6\pi r^2 + \dfrac{300}{r}\)
A0: Cannot obtain \(C\) = 483 or 484
(c) B1: \(\left\{\dfrac{\mathrm{d}^2C}{\mathrm{d}r^2} =\right\}\ 12\pi + \dfrac{600}{r^3} \gt 0\) so minimum OR checks gradient to left and right of 1.996 and shows gradient goes from negative to zero to positive so minimum
OR checks value of \(C\) to left and right of 1.996 and shows that \(C\) > 225.4 so deduces minimum ( i.e. uses shape of graph)
(corrected from the printed mark scheme, which gives 1.966 twice in (c))
There is an example in Practice of this misread.