C1 January 2013 Q9
9. The equation\[(k + 3)x^2 + 6x + k = 5, \quad \text{where } k \text{ is a constant,}\]has two distinct real solutions for \(x\).
Method 1
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| Attempts \(b^2 - 4ac\) for \(a = (k + 3)\), \(b = 6\) and their \(c\). \(c \neq k\) | M1 |
| \(b^2 - 4ac = 6^2 - 4(k + 3)(k - 5)\) | A1 |
| \((b^2 - 4ac =) \quad -4k^2 + 8k + 96\) or \(-(b^2 - 4ac =) \quad 4k^2 - 8k - 96\) (with no prior algebraic errors) | B1 |
| As \(b^2 - 4ac > 0\), then \(-4k^2 + 8k + 96 > 0\) and so, \(k^2 - 2k - 24 < 0\) | A1 * |
| (4) |
Notes
Method 1: M1: Attempts \(b^2 - 4ac\) for \(a = (k + 3)\), \(b = 6\) and their \(c\). \(c \neq k\) or uses quadratic formula and has this expression under square root. (ignore > 0, < 0 or = 0 for first 3 marks)
A1: Correct expression for \(b^2 - 4ac\) - need not be simplified (may be under root sign)
B1: Uses algebra to manipulate result without error into one of these three term quadratics. Again may be under root sign in quadratic formula. If inequality is used early in “proof” may see \(4k^2 - 8k - 96 < 0\) and B1 would be given for \(4k^2 - 8k - 96\) correctly stated.
A1: Applies \(b^2 - 4ac > 0\) correctly ( or writes \(b^2 - 4ac > 0\) ) to achieve the result given in the question. No errors should be seen. Any incorrect line of argument should be penalised here. There are several ways of reaching the answer; either multiplication of both sides of inequality by −1, or taking every term to other side of inequality. Need conclusion i.e. printed answer.
Method 2
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| Considers \(b^2 > 4ac\) for \(a = (k + 3)\), \(b = 6\) and their \(c\). \(c \neq k\) | M1 |
| \(6^2 > 4(k + 3)(k - 5)\) | A1 |
| \(4k^2 - 8k - 96 < 0\) or \(-4k^2 + 8k + 96 > 0\) or \(9 > (k + 3)(k - 5)\) (with no prior algebraic errors) | B1 |
| and so, \(k^2 - 2k - 24 < 0\) following correct work | A1 * |
Method 2: M1: Allow \(b^2 > 4ac\), \(b^2 < 4ac\) or \(b^2 = 4ac\) for \(a = (k + 3)\), \(b = 6\) and their \(c\). \(c \neq k\)
A1: Correct expressions on either side (ignore >, < or =).
B1: Uses algebra to manipulate result into one of the two three term quadratics or divides both sides by 4 again without error
A1: Produces result with no errors seen from initial consideration of \(b^2 > 4ac\) .
Special case : In part (a) uses \(c = k\) instead of \(k - 5\) - scores 0 . Allow \(k + 5\) for method marks
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| Attempts to solve \(k^2 - 2k - 24 = 0\) to give \(k =\) (\(\Rightarrow\) Critical values, \(k = 6,\ -4\).) | M1 |
| \(k^2 - 2k - 24 < 0\) gives \(-4 < k < 6\) | M1 A1 |
| (3) | |
| (7 marks) |
Notes
M1: Uses factorisation, formula, completion of square method to find two values for \(k\), or finds two correct answers with no obvious method
M1: Their Lower Limit \(< k <\) Their Upper Limit. Allow the M mark mark for \(\leqslant\) . (Allow \(k <\) upper and \(k >\) lower)
A1: \(-4 < k < 6\) Lose this mark for \(\leqslant\) Allow \((-4, 6)\) [not square brackets] or \(k > -4\) and \(k < 6\) (must be and not or) Can also use intersection symbol \(\cap\) NOT \(k > -4,\ k < 6\) (M1A0)
Special Case: In part (b) Obtaining \(-6 < k < 4\) This is a common wrong answer. Give M1 M1 A0 special case.
Special Case: In part (b) Use of \(x\) instead of \(k\) – M1M1A0
Special Case: \(-4 < k < 6\) and \(k < -4,\ k > 6\) both given is M0A0 for last two marks. Do not treat as isw.