June 2025 Paper 1 Q4
4. The circle \(C\) has equation\[x^2 + y^2 + 10x - 4y + 1 = 0\]
The line with equation \(y = k\), where \(k\) is a constant, cuts \(C\) at two distinct points.
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \(x^2 + y^2 + 10x - 4y + 1 = 0\) | ||
| (a)(i) \((x+5)^2 + (y-2)^2\) | M1 | 1.1b |
| Centre \((-5,\ 2)\) | A1 | 1.1b |
| (a)(ii) Radius is \(\sqrt{28}\) | A1 | 1.1b |
| (3) |
Notes
Condone mislabelled parts e.g. labelled as (a), (b) and (c) not (a)(i), (a)(ii), (b)
M1: Attempts to complete the square by halving both \(x\) and \(y\) terms.
Award for sight of \((x \pm 5)^2 \ldots (y \pm 2)^2\) or \((x \pm 5)^2\) and \((y \pm 2)^2\) seen separately.
May be implied by a centre of \((\pm 5,\ \pm 2)\)
A1: Correct coordinates \((-5,\ 2)\) or e.g. \(x = -5,\ y = 2\) and condone e.g. \(-5,\ 2\)
A1: \(\sqrt{28}\) \(\left(\text{or } 2\sqrt{7}\right)\)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \(2+2\sqrt{7}\) or \(2-2\sqrt{7}\) seen | B1 | 2.2a |
| \(2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\) | M1 | 1.1b |
| \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) oe | A1 | 2.5 |
| (3) | ||
| (6 marks) |
Notes
Condone mislabelled parts e.g. labelled as (a), (b) and (c) not (a)(i), (a)(ii), (b)
B1: \(2+2\sqrt{7}\) or \(2-2\sqrt{7}\) seen. Accept \(\sqrt{28}\) for \(2\sqrt{7}\) throughout this question.
M1: \(\text{``}2-2\sqrt{7}\text{''} \lt k \lt \text{``}2+2\sqrt{7}\text{''}\)
Selects the inside interval for their endpoints which must come from a correct method condoning slips. Condone use of \(y\) for \(k\).
May be seen separately e.g. \(\text{``}2-2\sqrt{7}\text{''} \lt k,\quad k \lt \text{``}2+2\sqrt{7}\text{''}\)
Condone e.g. \(\text{``}2-\sqrt{28}\text{''} \leqslant k \leqslant \text{``}2+\sqrt{28}\text{''}\) and allow inexact e.g. \(\text{``}{-3.291\ldots}\text{''} \lt k \lt \text{``}7.291\ldots\text{''}\)
An incorrect method would include e.g. \(5-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 5+2\sqrt{7}\) ie using the \(x\) coordinate of the centre rather than the \(y\) coordinate.
A1: Correct answer in exact form in set notation or interval notation in terms of \(k\).
Allow: \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cap \left\{k : k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cap \left\{k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left(2-2\sqrt{7},\ 2+2\sqrt{7}\right)\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \cap k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\}\) and \(\left\{k : k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) but not \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cup \left\{k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) and not \(\left[2-2\sqrt{7},\ 2+2\sqrt{7}\right]\) and not \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \leqslant k \leqslant 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\)
(b) Alternative 1
(substitutes \(y = k\) into the given or their circle equation and uses \(b^2 - 4ac = 0\) or \(b^2 - 4ac \gt 0\))
Scores in the same way following e.g.
\(x^2 + 10x + \left(k^2 - 4k + 1\right) = 0,\ 10^2 - 4\left(k^2 - 4k + 1\right) \gt 0,\ 24 + 4k - k^2 = 0\)
B1: \(2+2\sqrt{7}\) or \(2-2\sqrt{7}\) seen. Accept \(\sqrt{28}\) for \(2\sqrt{7}\) throughout this question.
M1: \(\text{``}2-2\sqrt{7}\text{''} \lt k \lt \text{``}2+2\sqrt{7}\text{''}\)
Selects the inside interval for their endpoints which must come from a correct method condoning slips. Condone use of \(y\) for \(k\).
May be seen separately e.g. \(\text{``}2-2\sqrt{7}\text{''} \lt k,\quad k \lt \text{``}2+2\sqrt{7}\text{''}\)
Condone e.g. \(\text{``}2-\sqrt{28}\text{''} \leqslant k \leqslant \text{``}2+\sqrt{28}\text{''}\) and allow inexact e.g. \(\text{``}{-3.291\ldots}\text{''} \lt k \lt \text{``}7.291\ldots\text{''}\)
If when finding their endpoints they make a sign error and obtain e.g. \(k^2 - 4k - 24 \gt 0\) and then choose the outside region, this scores M1 but it must be consistent with their inequality.
A1: Correct answer in exact form in set notation or interval notation in terms of \(k\).
Allow: \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cap \left\{k : k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cap \left\{k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left(2-2\sqrt{7},\ 2+2\sqrt{7}\right)\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \cap k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\}\) and \(\left\{k : k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) but not \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cup \left\{k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) and not \(\left[2-2\sqrt{7},\ 2+2\sqrt{7}\right]\) and not \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \leqslant k \leqslant 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\)
(b) Alternative 2
(substitutes \(x = \text{``}{-5}\text{''}\) into the given or their circle equation and solves for \(y\))
Scores in the same way following e.g.
\(25 + y^2 - 50 - 4y + 1 = 0 \Rightarrow y^2 - 4y - 24 = 0 \Rightarrow y =\)
(corrected from the printed mark scheme: “\(25 + y^2 - 50 - 4y + 1 - 0\)”)
B1: \(2+2\sqrt{7}\) or \(2-2\sqrt{7}\) seen. Accept \(\sqrt{28}\) for \(2\sqrt{7}\) throughout this question.
M1: \(\text{``}2-2\sqrt{7}\text{''} \lt k \lt \text{``}2+2\sqrt{7}\text{''}\)
Selects the inside interval for their endpoints which must come from a correct method condoning slips. Condone use of \(y\) for \(k\).
May be seen separately e.g. \(\text{``}2-2\sqrt{7}\text{''} \lt k,\quad k \lt \text{``}2+2\sqrt{7}\text{''}\)
Condone e.g. \(\text{``}2-\sqrt{28}\text{''} \leqslant k \leqslant \text{``}2+\sqrt{28}\text{''}\) and allow inexact e.g. \(\text{``}{-3.291\ldots}\text{''} \lt k \lt \text{``}7.291\ldots\text{''}\)
A1: Correct answer in exact form in set notation or interval notation in terms of \(k\).
Allow: \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cap \left\{k : k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cap \left\{k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left(2-2\sqrt{7},\ 2+2\sqrt{7}\right)\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k \cap k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) or \(\left\{k : 2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\}\) and \(\left\{k : k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) but not \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \lt k\right\} \cup \left\{k \lt 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\) and not \(\left[2-2\sqrt{7},\ 2+2\sqrt{7}\right]\) and not \(\left\{2-2\sqrt{7} \leqslant k \leqslant 2+2\sqrt{7}\right\}\)