October 2020 Paper 3 Q5
5. A health centre claims that the time a doctor spends with a patient can be modelled by a normal distribution with a mean of 10 minutes and a standard deviation of 4 minutes.
Some patients complain that the mean time the doctor spends with a patient is more than 10 minutes.
The receptionist takes a random sample of 20 patients and finds that the mean time the doctor spends with a patient is 11.5 minutes.
The health centre also claims that the time a dentist spends with a patient during a routine appointment, \(T\) minutes, can be modelled by the normal distribution where \(T \sim \mathrm{N}\left(5, 3.5^2\right)\)
The dentist believes that she cannot complete a routine appointment in less than 2 minutes.
She suggests that the health centre should use a refined model only including values of \(T \gt 2\)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| {Let \(X\) = time spent, \(\mathrm{P}(X \gt 15) =\) } 0.105649… awrt 0.106 | B1 | 1.1b |
| (1) |
Notes
B1: for awrt 0.106 (from calculator) [Allow 10.6%]
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \(\mathrm{H}_0 : \mu = 10 \quad \mathrm{H}_1 : \mu \gt 10\) | B1 | 2.5 |
| \(\bar{X} \sim \mathrm{N}\left(10, \left(\dfrac{4}{\sqrt{20}}\right)^2\right)\); \(\mathrm{P}\left(\bar{X} \gt 11.5\right) = 0.046766\ldots\) [Condone 0.9532…] | M1;A1 | 3.3;3.4 |
| [This is significant (< 5%) so ] there is evidence to support the complaint | A1 | 2.2b |
| (4) |
Notes
B1: for both hypotheses correct in terms of \(\mu\).
M1: for selection of a correct model (sight or use of correct normal- may not have label \(\bar{X}\))
1st A1: for use of this model to get probability allow 0.046~0.047 [Condone awrt 0.953]
ALT OR: test statistic \(z = 1.677\ldots\) (awrt 1.68) and cv of 1.64 (or better) or CR \(\bar{X} \gt 11.47\ldots\)
2nd A1: (dep on 1st A1 or at least \(\mathrm{P}\left(\bar{X} \gt 11.5\right) \lt 0.05\) (o.e.))
for a correct conclusion in context -must mention complaint/claim or time/mins is > 10
SC: (M0 for \(\bar{X} \sim \mathrm{N}(11.5, \ldots)\)) for correct probability and conclusion (score M0A0A1 on epen)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| [\(\mathrm{P}(T \lt 2) =\) ] 0.1956… awrt 0.196 | B1 | 1.1b |
| (1) |
Notes
B1: for awrt 0.196 (from calculator) [Allow 19.6%]
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| Require \(\dfrac{\mathrm{P}(0 \lt T \lt 2)}{\mathrm{P}(T \gt 0)} = \dfrac{0.119119\ldots}{0.923436\ldots}\); \(= 0.1289955\ldots\) awrt 0.129 | M1 A1;A1 | 3.4 1.1bx2 |
| (3) |
Notes
M1: for a correct probability ratio expression (may be implied by 1st A1 scored)
1st A1: for a correct ratio of probabilities (both correct or truncated to 2 dp)
2nd A1: for awrt 0.129
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| The current model suggests non-negligible probability of \(T\) values < 0 which is impossible | B1 | 3.5b |
| (1) |
Notes
B1: for a suitable explanation of why model is not suitable based on negative \(T\) values
Must say that a significant proportion of values < 0 (o.e.) e.g. \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt 0)\) should be closer to 1
or Difference between \(\mathrm{P}(T \lt 2 \mid T \gt 0)\) and \(\mathrm{P}(T \lt 2)\) is too big (o.e.)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| Require \(t\) such that \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt t \mid T \gt 2) = 0.5\) or \(\mathrm{P}(T \lt t \mid T \gt 2) = 0.5\) | M1 | 3.1b |
| e.g. \(\dfrac{\mathrm{P}(T \gt t)}{\mathrm{P}(T \gt 2)} = 0.5\); so \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt t) = 0.5 \times [1 - \text{(c)(i)}]\) or \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt t) = 0.5 \times 0.8043\ldots\) | M1; A1ft | 1.1b 3.4 |
| [i.e. \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt t) = 0.40\ldots\) implies] \(\dfrac{t - 5}{3.5} = 0.2533\) or \(\mathrm{P}(T \lt t) = \text{``}0.5978\ldots\text{''}\) | M1 | 1.1b |
| \(t = 5.886\ldots\) or from calculator \(5.867\ldots\) so awrt 5.9 | A1 | 1.1b |
| (5) | ||
| (15 marks) |
Notes
1st M1: for a correct conditional probability statement to start the problem or \(0.5 \times \mathrm{P}(T \gt 2)\)
2nd M1: for correct ratio of probability expressions [Must have \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt t)\) or \(\mathrm{P}(2 \lt T \lt t)\)]
1st A1ft: for a correct equation for \(\mathrm{P}(T \gt t)\) (o.e.) ft their answer to part (c)[May be in a diagram]
3rd M1: for attempt to find \(t\) (standardising and sight of 0.2533) or prepare to use calc (ft)
Arriving at \(\mathrm{P}(T \lt \text{median}) = 1 - 0.5 \times\)”their 0.8043” will score 1st 4 marks
2nd A1: for awrt 5.9
Sight of awrt 5.9 and at least one M mark scores 5/5 [Answer only send to review]