June 2023 Paper 3 Q5
5. Tisam is playing a game.
She uses a ball, a cup and a spinner.
The random variable \(X\) represents the number the spinner lands on when it is spun.
The probability distribution of \(X\) is given in the following table
| \(x\) | 20 | 50 | 80 | 100 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| \(\mathrm{P}(X = x)\) | \(a\) | \(b\) | \(c\) | \(d\) |
where \(a\), \(b\), \(c\) and \(d\) are probabilities.
To play the game
- the spinner is spun to obtain a value of \(x\)
- Tisam then stands \(x\) cm from the cup and tries to throw the ball into the cup
The event \(S\) represents the event that Tisam successfully throws the ball into the cup.
To model this game Tisam assumes that
- \(\mathrm{P}(S \mid \{X = x\}) = \dfrac{k}{x}\) where \(k\) is a constant
- \(\mathrm{P}(S \cap \{X = x\})\) should be the same whatever value of \(x\) is obtained from the spinner
Using Tisam’s model,
Nav tries, a large number of times, to throw the ball into the cup from a distance of 100 cm.
He successfully gets the ball in the cup 30% of the time.
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \(\mathrm{P}(S \cap \{X = 50\}) = \mathrm{P}(S \cap \{X = 80\})\)[= a constant, \(V\)] \(\Rightarrow b \times \dfrac{k}{50} = c \times \dfrac{k}{80}\) May see: \(\dfrac{k}{50} = \dfrac{V}{b}\) and \(\dfrac{k}{80} = \dfrac{V}{c}\) (condone any letter for \(V\) even \(S\)) | M1 | 3.1a |
| So \(c = \dfrac{8}{5}b\) * | A1cso* | 1.1b |
| (2) |
Notes
M1: for use of \(\mathrm{P}(S \mid X = x) \times \mathrm{P}(X = x)\) for \(x = 50\) and \(x = 80\) (Must see \(k\) or their \(V\))
Any expression or equation MUST be based on the probability statements in qu.
* A1cso: for rearranging to required result, no incorrect work seen, condone poor notation
NB: Use of values e.g. \(b = \dfrac{50}{20 + 50 + 80 + 100}\) to prove (a) is M0A0 but scores 2nd M1A1 in (b)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \(d = 2b\) or \(a = \dfrac{2}{5}b\) or \(c = 4a\) or \(d = 5a\) or \(d = \dfrac{5}{4}c\) | M1 A1 | 2.1 3.3 |
| \(\dfrac{2}{5}b + b + \dfrac{8}{5}b + 2b = 1\) | M1 | 2.1 |
| \(\Rightarrow 5b = 1\) so \(b = \dfrac{1}{5}\) (o.e.) | A1 | 1.1b |
| \(a = \dfrac{2}{25} \quad b = \dfrac{1}{5} \quad c = \dfrac{8}{25} \quad d = \dfrac{2}{5}\) | A1 | 3.2a |
| (5) |
Notes
Marks for (b) may be awarded for work seen in (a)
1st M1: for at least one other relationship (either probability the subject) from the list.
1st A1: for a second different relationship (either probability the subject) from the list.
or Allow for: \(\dfrac{ak}{20} = \dfrac{bk}{50} = \dfrac{ck}{80} = \dfrac{dk}{100}\) for 1st M1 1st A1
2nd M1: for using or stating sum of prob’s = 1 May be implied by one correct probability.
2nd A1: for one correct probability e.g. \(b = \frac{1}{5}\) or exact equivalent such as 0.2
3rd A1: for all correct probabilities. Allow exact equivalents e.g. \(c = 0.32\)
Sight of correct distribution or list of probs with no obvious incorrect working is 5/5
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| [Experiment suggests for Nav] \(\mathrm{P}(S \mid \{X = 100\}) = 0.3 \Rightarrow k = 30\) or \(0.3 = \dfrac{V}{0.4} \Rightarrow V = 0.12\) So model won’t work since \(\mathrm{P}(S \mid X = 20) = \dfrac{30}{20}\) or \(\dfrac{0.12}{0.08}\) and so would be greater than 1 | B1 | 2.4 |
| (1) | ||
| (8 marks) |
Notes
B1: for deducing \(k = 30\) and giving a suitable example to show model breaks down
Notes on Question 5
The question essentially uses the definition of \(\mathrm{P}(A \mid B)\) given in the formula booklet.
In particular \(\mathrm{P}(S \mid \{X = x\}) = \dfrac{\mathrm{P}(S \cap \{X = x\})}{\mathrm{P}(X = x)} \quad \boxed{1}\)
The first “blob” tells us that \(\mathrm{P}(S \mid \{X = x\}) = \dfrac{k}{x}\) where \(k\) is a constant.
The second “blob” tells us that \(\mathrm{P}(S \cap \{X = x\})\) is the same for all \(x\) so \(\mathrm{P}(S \cap \{X = x\}) = V\) where \(V\) is a constant.
Using these results in \(\boxed{1}\) gives \(\dfrac{k}{x} = \dfrac{V}{\mathrm{P}(X = x)} \quad \boxed{2}\)
Line 1 of MS for part (a) uses \(V = \mathrm{P}(X = x) \times \dfrac{k}{x}\) for \(x = 50\) and \(x = 80\)
Line 2 of MS for part (a) uses \(\boxed{2}\) with \(x = 50\) and \(x = 80\)
Other implications
Equation \(\boxed{1}\) can be rearranged to give \(\mathrm{P}(X = x) = x \times \dfrac{V}{k} \quad \boxed{3}\)
So when \(a + b + c + d = 1\) is used this gives \(1 = \dfrac{V}{k}(20 + 50 + 80 + 100)\) or \(\dfrac{V}{k} = \dfrac{1}{250} \quad \boxed{4}\)
In particular if we use this relationship in \(\boxed{3}\) the probabilities \(a\), \(b\), \(c\) and \(d\) can simply be written down for example \(b = \dfrac{50}{250}\) as given in the NB in the notes on the MS.
The point is that \(k\) and \(V\) will vary according to equation \(\boxed{4}\) but as part (c) shows there are some restrictions on the values \(k\), and therefore \(V\), can take.
Since \(\dfrac{k}{x}\) is a probability then, ignoring the trivial cases*, \(0 \lt \dfrac{k}{x} \lt 1\) and the “restricting” value of \(x\) is clearly \(x = 20\) so \(0 \lt k \lt 20\) and from \(\boxed{4}\) we get \(0 \lt V \lt \dfrac{20}{250} = \dfrac{2}{25} = a\)
So the restrictions on \(k\) and on \(V\) are given by the shortest distance and its associated probability.
* \(k = 0\) would say Tisam can never get the ball in the cup no matter what the distance.
\(k = 20\) says she always gets the ball in the cup for any distance.