June 2023 Paper 2 Q15
15. A student attempts to answer the following question:
| Given that \(x\) is an obtuse angle, use algebra to prove by contradiction that\[\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\] |
The student starts the proof with:
| Assume that \(\sin x - \cos x \lt 1\) when \(x\) is an obtuse angle \(\Rightarrow (\sin x - \cos x)^2 \lt 1\) \(\Rightarrow \ldots\) |
The start of the student’s proof is reprinted below.
Complete the proof. (3)
Assume that \(\sin x - \cos x \lt 1\) when \(x\) is an obtuse angle
\(\Rightarrow (\sin x - \cos x)^2 \lt 1\)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \((\sin x - \cos x)^2 \lt 1 \Rightarrow \sin^2 x - 2\sin x\cos x + \cos^2 x\ \ (\lt 1)\) o.e. | M1 | 1.1b |
| Examples: \(1 - 2\sin x\cos x \lt 1,\ \ 1 - \sin 2x \lt 1,\ \ -2\sin x\cos x \lt 0,\ \ -\sin 2x \lt 0\) | A1 | 2.2a |
| As \(x\) is obtuse then \(-2\sin x\cos x\) is positive because \(\sin x \gt 0\) and \(\cos x \lt 0\) so we have a contradiction. Therefore \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\) * | A1* | 2.4 |
| (3 marks) |
Notes
Condone poor notation e.g. \(\sin x^2\) or e.g. \(-2\sin\theta\cos x \lt 1\) for the first two marks only.
M1: Expands \((\sin x - \cos x)^2\) to obtain \(\sin^2 x \pm k\sin x\cos x + \cos^2 x\) where \(k = 1\) or 2 o.e. May be implied.
A1: Uses a correct identity \(\sin^2 x + \cos^2 x = 1\) or e.g. \(-\sin^2 x - \cos^2 x = -1\) to obtain a correct inequality in any form that does not include the \(\sin^2 x\) and \(\cos^2 x\) terms. Condone e.g. \(-2\sin\ \cos x \lt 0\)
A1*: Fully correct work which includes
- a convincing argument that explains why their inequality is not true
- a statement that indicates there is a contradiction
- a conclusion that \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\) (there is no need to repeat “when x is obtuse”)
- no contradictory statements
- no mixed/missed variables, e.g., \(-2\sin\theta\cos x \lt 1\) or \(1 - \sin 2 \lt 1\)
Examples:
From \(-2\sin x\cos x \lt 0\):
In the second quadrant \(-2\sin x\cos x\) is \(- \times + \times - = +\)
“(this is a) contradiction” or equivalent (therefore) \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\)
or
As x is obtuse, \(\sin x \gt 0\), \(\cos x \lt 0\) so \(-2\sin x\cos x \gt 0\)
“(this is a) contradiction” or equivalent (therefore) \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\)
From \(-\sin 2x \lt 0\):
As x is obtuse, 2x is reflex o.e. (i.e. \(\pi \lt 2x \lt 2\pi\)) so \(-\sin 2x \gt 0\)
“(this is) wrong” or equivalent (therefore) \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\)
From \(1 - \sin 2x \lt 1\):
As x is obtuse, 2x is reflex o.e. (i.e. \(180 \lt 2x \lt 360\)) so \(\sin 2x \lt 0\) so \(1 - \sin 2x \gt 1\)
“(this is a) contradiction” or equivalent (therefore) \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\)
From \(\sin 2x \gt 0\):
As x is obtuse, 2x is reflex o.e. (i.e. \(180 \lt 2x \lt 360\)) so \(\sin 2x \lt 0\)
“(this is) incorrect” or equivalent (therefore) \(\sin x - \cos x \geqslant 1\)
Note that you may condone the absence of a statement referring to the fact that \((\sin x - \cos x)^2 \lt 1\) is only valid since \(\sin x - \cos x \gt 0\) when x is obtuse.