June 2018 Paper 2 Q11
11 Rakti makes open-topped cylindrical planters out of thin sheets of galvanised steel.
She bends a rectangle of steel to make an open cylinder and welds the joint. She then welds this cylinder to the circumference of a circular base.

The planter must have a capacity of 8000 cm3
Welding is time consuming, so Rakti wants the total length of weld to be a minimum.
Calculate the radius, \(r\), and height, \(h\), of a planter which requires the minimum total length of weld.
Fully justify your answers, giving them to an appropriate degree of accuracy. [9 marks]
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| Obtains correct weld length in terms of \(h\) and \(r\) | B1 | 1.1b |
| Obtains formula for \(h\) in terms of \(r\) or vice versa using volume \(= 8000\) | M1 | 3.1b |
| Substitutes to get weld length in terms of one variable, obtaining correct formula for \(w\) | A1 | 1.1b |
| States that for a stationary point the first derivative is zero. (OE) | E1 | 2.4 |
| Differentiates correctly (FT provided formula includes negative powers) (accept numerical value of \(-\frac{16000}{\pi}\) used) | B1F | 1.1b |
| Solves to find a value of \(r\) and a value of \(h\) (do not award if the final value of \(r\) or \(h\) is negative) | M1 | 1.1a |
| Obtains \(r = 9\) or 9.3 (AWRT) and \(h = 29\), 29.3 (AWRT) or 30 | A1 | 1.1b |
| Differentiates ‘their’ first differential and substitutes in ‘their’ value of \(r\) or \(h\) | M1 | 1.1a |
| Sets out a well-constructed mathematical argument, using precise statements throughout to find the values of \(r\) (9 or 9.3) and \(h\) (29, 29.3 or 30) and justifies the minimum value. Can be awarded if E1 not obtained. | R1 | 2.1 |
| (9 marks) |
Typical solution
(using \(r\))
\[\text{Length of weld} = w = h + 2\pi r\]\[\text{Volume} = 8000 = \pi r^2 h\]\[\text{So } h = \frac{8000}{\pi r^2}\]\[w = \frac{8000}{\pi r^2} + 2\pi r\]For minimum length of weld
\[\frac{dw}{dr} = 0\]\[\frac{-16000}{\pi r^3} + 2\pi = 0\]\[\text{leading to } \pi^2 r^3 = 8000\]\[r = 9.32 \text{ cm}\]\[h = 29.3 \text{ cm}\]\[\frac{d^2w}{dr^2} = \frac{48000}{\pi r^4}\]which is positive, so this is a minimum for \(w\)
(using \(h\))
\[\text{Length of weld} = w = h + 2\pi r\]\[\text{Volume} = 8000 = \pi r^2 h\]\[r = \sqrt{\frac{8000}{\pi h}}\]\[w = h + 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{8000}{\pi h}}\]\[= h + \sqrt{32000\pi}\,h^{-\frac{1}{2}}\]For minimum length of weld
\[\frac{dw}{dh} = 0\]\[1 - \tfrac{1}{2}\sqrt{32000\pi}\,h^{-\frac{3}{2}} = 0\]\[\text{leading to } h^3 = 8000\pi\]\[h = 29.3 \text{ cm}\]\[r = 9.32 \text{ cm}\]\[\frac{d^2w}{dh^2} = \frac{3}{4}\sqrt{32000\pi}\,h^{-\frac{5}{2}}\]which is positive, so this is a minimum for \(w\)