May 2023 Paper 2 Q8
8. A wooden beam is used to support a wall built on horizontal ground as shown in the diagram.

The edge of the beam, AB, is 8 metres long.
C is at the foot of the wall.
A is 7 metres from C.
B is 4 metres from C.
Determine whether the wall is perpendicular to the ground.
Justify your answer. [4]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •1 | valid strategy | \(4^2+7^2\) and \(8^2\) |
| •2 | evaluation | \(4^2+7^2=65\) and \(8^2=64\) |
| •3 | explicit comparison | \(4^2+7^2\ne8^2\) |
| •4 | conclusion with valid reason | No, as angle is not a right angle |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •1 | valid strategy | \(4^2+7^2=65\) |
| •2 | evaluation | \(\sqrt{65}=8.06\ldots\) |
| •3 | explicit comparison | \(8\ne8.06\ldots\) |
| •4 | conclusion with valid reason | No, as angle is not a right angle |
| Method 3 | Method 3 | |
| •1 | valid strategy | \((\cos x=)\,\dfrac{4^2+7^2-8^2}{2\times4\times7}\) |
| •2 | evaluate \(\cos x\) | \((\cos x=)\,\dfrac{1}{56}\) |
| •3 | calculate angle | 88(.97) |
| •4 | conclusion with valid reason | No, as angle is not a right angle |
| (4) |
Notes:
- •1 is not available where a candidate starts by stating that \(4^2+7^2=8^2\) or \(4^2+7^2\ne8^2\)
\(4^2+7^2=8^2\) or \(4^2+7^2\ne8^2\) ✗•1 \(65\ne64\) ✓•2✓•3 No, as angle is not a right angle ✓•4 award 3/4 ✗✓✓✓ - There must be an explicit comparison stated for the award of •3
- For the award of •3 accept eg
(a) \(\sqrt{65}\ne\sqrt{64}\)
(b) \(\sqrt{65}\ne8\)
(c) \(a^2+b^2\ne c^2\) or \(\text{AC}^2+\text{CB}^2\ne\text{AB}^2\) (labelling consistent with diagram)
(d) 65 > 64 - The conclusion must include reference to 90° or a right angle.
- Inappropriate use of RAD or GRAD should only be penalised once in Qu 4, 8, 11 or 15
(a) 1.55… (RAD), no, as angle is not a right angle
(b) 98 (.86…) (GRAD), no, as angle is not a right angle
Commonly Observed Responses:
| 1. (a) \(4^2+7^2=65\to8.06\ldots=8;\ 8=8\to\) yes, as angle is a right angle | award 3/4 ✓✓✗✓1 |
| (b) \(4^2+7^2=65\to8;\ 8=8\to\) yes, as angle is a right angle | award 3/4 ✓✗✓1✓1 |
| 2. If triangle is right-angled then \(4^2+7^2=8^2\to65\ne64;\) No, as angle is not a right angle | award 4/4 |
| 3. (a) \(4^2+8^2\) and \(7^2\to80,\ 49\to80\ne49\to\) no, as angle is not a right angle | award 3/4 ✗✓1✓1✓1 |
| (b) \(4^2+8^2=7^2\to80,\ 49\to80\ne49\to\) no, as angle is not a right angle | award 3/4 ✗✓1✓1✓1 |
| 4. (a) \(\dfrac{4^2+7^2-8^2}{2\times4\times7}=\dfrac{1}{56}=0.017(\ldots)^\circ\) or \(\text{C}=0.017(\ldots)\to\) no, as angle is not a right angle | award 3/4 ✓✓✗✓1 |
| (b) \(\dfrac{4^2+7^2-8^2}{2\times4\times7}=\dfrac{1}{56}=0.017(\ldots)\to\) no, as angle is not a right angle | award 2/4 ✓✓^✗ |