May 2023 Paper 1 Q10
10. Alan buys some identical paving slabs to make a path.
Each slab is part of a circle.

The diagram below shows a single slab.

The circle, centre C, has a radius of 50 centimetres.
Length AB is 60 centimetres.
Calculate the width of the paving slab. [4]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •1 | marshal facts and recognise right angled triangle | ![]() |
| •2 | consistent Pythagoras statement | \(50^2-30^2\) |
| •3 | calculate third side | 40 |
| •4 | calculate width | 90 |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •1 | marshal facts and recognise right angled triangle | ![]() |
| •2 | consistent Pythagoras statement | \(100^2-60^2\) |
| •3 | calculate third side | 80 |
| •4 | calculate width | 90 |
| (4) |
Notes:
- Correct answer without working award 0/4
- In the absence of a diagram accept \(50^2-30^2\) or \(100^2-60^2\) as evidence for the award of •1 and •2.
- BEWARE
Where a diagram is shown, working must be consistent with the diagram; •2 is not available for an incorrect diagram leading to \(50^2-30^2\) or \(100^2-60^2\). - •4 is only available following a Pythagoras calculation within a valid right-angled triangle except in the examples outlined in note 5
eg \(d=100\to100-60=40\to40+50=90\) award 0/4 - Where a candidate demonstrates recognition of 3,4,5 Pythagorean triple, for the award of •1, •2 and •3 accept:
(a)
(b) 40, since 3, 4, 5 triangle or Pythagorean triple. - Where a candidate uses 60 and 50 or 50 and 50 within a Pythagorean statement, •1 and •4 are not available eg
(a) consistent with their diagram: \(60^2-50^2\to10\sqrt{11}\to50+10\sqrt{11}\) award 2/4 ✗✓1✓1✗
(b) no diagram: \(60^2-50^2\to10\sqrt{11}\to50+10\sqrt{11}\) award 1/4 ✗✗✓1✗ - Where a candidate’s Pythagoras statement leads to an invalid solution, do not award •3 but •4 is still available eg \(30^2-50^2\to\sqrt{\pm1600}\to40\to90\) •3 ✗ •4 ✓1
Commonly Observed Responses:
- \(40\to90\) award 0/4 ^^^✓2

