May 2022 Paper 2 Q14
14. The width of a river is represented by BC in the diagram below.
AB represents a tree on the river bank.

- From C, the angle of elevation to A is 28°.
- From D, the angle of elevation to A is 12°.
- The distance from C to D is 15 metres.
- BCD is a straight line.
Calculate BC, the width of the river. [5]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | ||
| •1 | correct substitution into sine rule to calculate AC | \(\dfrac{\text{AC}}{\sin12}=\dfrac{15}{\sin16}\) |
| •2 | rearrange equation | \(\dfrac{15\sin12}{\sin16}\) |
| •3 | calculate AC | \(\text{AC}=11.3(\ldots)\) |
| •4 | valid strategy to calculate BC | eg \(\cos28=\dfrac{\text{BC}}{11.3\ldots}\) or \(\sin62=\dfrac{\text{BC}}{11.3\ldots}\) |
| •5 | calculate BC | 9.99 (m) |
| Method 2 | ||
| •1 | correct substitution into sine rule to calculate AD | \(\dfrac{\text{AD}}{\sin152}=\dfrac{15}{\sin16}\) |
| •2 | rearrange equation | \(\dfrac{15\sin152}{\sin16}\) |
| •3 | calculate AD | \(\text{AD}=25.5(\ldots)\) |
| •4 | valid strategy to calculate BD | eg \(\cos12=\dfrac{\textbf{BD}}{25.5\ldots}\) or \(\sin78=\dfrac{\textbf{BD}}{25.5\ldots}\) |
| •5 | calculate BC ie BD − 15 | 9.99 (m) |
| (5) |
Notes:
- Correct answer without working award 0/5
- Accept 10 with relevant working
- Where intermediate calculations are shown, disregard premature rounding provided:
(a) trigonometric values are rounded to at least 3 decimal places
(b) lengths are rounded to at least 1 decimal place - For the award of •5 accept truncated or correctly rounded final answer
eg method 1 leading to \(\cos28=\dfrac{\text{BC}}{11.3}\to9.97\) - Where both AC and AD are calculated but one is calculated incorrectly, if there is
(a) further working, then apply the MIs based on length used to calculate BC
(b) no further working, disregard the incorrect length award 3/5 ✓✓✓^^ - Inappropriate use of GRAD or RAD should only be penalised once in Q6,9 or 14:
If already penalised, the following marks should be awarded:GRAD RAD Method 1 \(\text{AC}=11.3(\ldots)\to\text{BC}=10.2(\ldots)\)
Award 5/5\(\text{AC}=27.9(5\ldots)\to\text{BC}=\pm26.9(\ldots)\)
Award 4/5 ✓✓✓✓✓2
(•5 is not available due to the negative length)Method 2 \(\text{AD}=41.2(\ldots)\to\text{BC}=40.5(5\ldots)\)
Award 5/5\(\text{AD}=\pm48.6(\ldots)\to\text{BC}=41.0(\ldots)\)
Award 3/5 ✓✓✓2✓✓2
(•3 and •5 are not available due to the negative length)
Commonly Observed Responses:
| 1. Method 2 leading to \(\cos12=\dfrac{\textbf{BD}}{25.5\ldots}\to24.99\) | award 4/5 ✓✓✓✓✗ |
| 2. Method 2 leading to \(\cos12=\dfrac{\textbf{BC}}{25.5\ldots}\to24.99\) | award 3/5 ✓✓✓✗✗ |