June 2024 Unit 3 Q15
15. Robert wants to deposit £\(P\) into a savings account. He has a choice of two accounts.
- Account A offers an annual compound interest rate of 1%.
- Account B offers an interest rate of 5% for the first year and an annual compound interest rate of 0·6% for each subsequent year.
After \(n\) years, account A is more profitable than account B. Find the smallest value of \(n\). [5]
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| For £\(P\) invested, the return after \(n\) years is \(S\). | ||
| Use of GP formula for \(k\)th term | M1 | |
| \(S_A=P(1.01)^n\) | B1 | Allow \(P=1\) |
| \(S_B=P(1.05)(1.006)^{n-1}\) | B1 | Allow \(P=1\) |
| We want minimum \(n\) st \(S_A>S_B\) | ||
| \(P(1.01)^n>P(1.05)(1.006)^{n-1}\) | m1 | Allow \(P=1\). Condone \(\geqslant\) or \(=\) |
| \((1.006)(1.01)^n>(1.05)(1.006)^n\) \(\left(\frac{1.01}{1.006}\right)^n>\left(\frac{1.05}{1.006}\right)\) \(n\ln\left(\frac{1.01}{1.006}\right)>\ln\left(\frac{1.05}{1.006}\right)\) \(n>10.78(762515)\) | ||
| min \(n=11\) | A1 | cao Mark final answer |
| [5] |
Notes
Note: Accept any valid method (eg trial and error).
Alternative (trial and error)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Use of GP formula for \(k\)th term | M1 | at least two iterations |
| \(S_A=P(1.01)^n\) | B1 | Allow \(P=1\), used for 2 values of \(n\) |
| \(S_B=P(1.05)(1.006)^{n-1}\) | B1 | Allow \(P=1\), used for 2 values of \(n\) |
| Two iterations for \(n=9,10,11,12,13\) | m1 | |
| min \(n=11\) | A1 | cao Mark final answer |
| Bank B \(1.05\times 1.006^{n-1}\) | Bank A \(1.01^n\) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| \(n=9\) | 1.101 471 196… | 1.093 685 272… | \(B>A\) |
| \(n=10\) | 1.108 080 023… | 1.104 622 125… | \(B>A\) |
| \(n=11\) | 1.114 728 503… | 1.115 668 346… | \(B<A\) |
| \(n=12\) | 1.121 416 874… | 1.126 825 030… | \(B<A\) |
| \(n=13\) | 1.128 145 376… | 1.138 093 280… | \(B<A\) |
Therefore \(n=11\)