June 2023 Unit 2 Q6
6. Poppi and Clare are investigating Welsh language skills in Wales. Poppi randomly selects a sample of 20 different students from her school and asks them to state their Welsh language skills according to the categories in the 2011 census. She numbers the students in her school from 001 to 578. She uses a random number generator to select her sample. The first 6 numbers generated are shown below.
195 752 023 195 432 271
Clare selects a random sample of 20 students from a different school.
The data collected from the 2011 census for two regions in Wales are shown below.
| No skills in Welsh | Understand spoken Welsh only | Speak Welsh | Other skills in Welsh | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Region A | Number of people | 111 232 | 5517 | 13 103 | 4858 |
| Percentage | 82·6 | 4·1 | 9·7 | 3·6 | |
| Region B | Number of people | 102 153 | 4083 | 13 189 | 2744 |
| Percentage | 83·7 | 3·3 | 10·8 | 2·2 | |
On looking at these data, Poppi concludes that people in Region B have better Welsh language skills than people in Region A.
7·2 5·4 7·4 4·6 13·2 8·4 7·7
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Select students numbered 195, 023, 432, 271 | B1 | Must reject 752 (outside range) and second 195 (appears twice). Allow any order. |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Valid reasons. e.g. Different samples can lead to different conclusions. e.g. Clare’s school may be in a different area. e.g. Poppi and Clare are at different stages of schooling. e.g. One school may be Welsh medium, whilst the other may be English medium. | E2 | E1 for each – do not award E2 for the same comment written in two different ways. E0 for Clare’s sample is larger than Poppi’s. E0 for “use a bigger sample”. |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (i) Valid reason. e.g. 10.8% can speak Welsh in Region B compared to 9.7% in Region A. | B1 | B0 for answers based on the number of people rather than percentages (e.g. more people speak Welsh in Region B than Region A). Condone percentages not quoted (e.g. a greater percentage / proportion in Region B can speak Welsh compared to Region A). |
| (ii) Valid reason. e.g. Only 82.6% have no skills in Welsh in Region A compared to 83.7% in Region B. e.g. 3.6% have other skills in Welsh compared to 2.2% in Region B. e.g. 4.1% understand spoken Welsh in Region A compared to 3.3% in Region B. | B1 | B0 for answers based on the number of people rather than percentages Condone percentages not quoted |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| (i) \(\bar{x}\left(=\frac{\Sigma x}{n}=\frac{53.9}{7}\right)=7.7\) (minutes) | B1 | Allow embedded \(\bar{x}\) within a shown calculation (either alternative method). Allow labelled as \(\mu\). |
| Appropriate use of calculator \(\sigma=2.56\) (minutes) | M1 A1 | Allow 2.6 |
| (ii) Valid comparison of means in context with interpretation: e.g. The children who can speak Welsh can concentrate for longer on average / in general than those who have no skills in Welsh. e.g. The children who cannot speak Welsh concentrate for less time on average / in general than those who can speak Welsh. | E1 | Must be an interpretation not simply comparing values. FT their \(\bar{x}\). E0 for omission of “on average”. E0 for the mean concentration time for those who speak Welsh is higher than the mean concentration time for those who do not speak Welsh oe. |
| Valid comparison of standard deviations in context with interpretation: e.g. The length of time children who have no skills in Welsh can concentrate for is more variable / less consistent / more spread out than those who can speak Welsh. e.g. The length of time children who speak Welsh can concentrate for is less variable / more consistent / less spread out than those who have no skills in Welsh. | E1 | Must be an interpretation not simply comparing values. FT their \(\sigma\). E0 for the standard deviation for those who speak Welsh is less than the standard deviation for those who do not speak Welsh oe. |
| However, one should not overly heed these comparisons due to the small sample size. | (E1) | Only following on from a comparison of means or standard deviations. BOD for “1st group” in place of “children who speak Welsh”. |
| Total [10] |
Alternative (d)(i) (OR)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| \(\sigma=\sqrt{\frac{\Sigma x^2}{n}-\bar{x}^2}=\sqrt{\frac{7.2^2+5.4^2+7.4^2+4.6^2+13.2^2+8.4^2+7.7^2}{7}-7.7^2}=\sqrt{\frac{461.01}{7}-7.7^2}\) | (M1) | Equivalents are \(\sqrt{\frac{\Sigma x^2}{n}-\frac{(\Sigma x)^2}{n^2}}\) or \(\sqrt{\frac{S_{xx}}{n}}\) FT their mean provided positive term within square root for M1 |
| \(=2.56\) (minutes) | (A1) | Allow 2.6 |
Alternative (d)(i) (OR)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| \(\sigma=\sqrt{\frac{\Sigma(x-\bar{x})^2}{n}}=\sqrt{\frac{(7.2-7.7)^2+(5.4-7.7)^2+(7.4-7.7)^2+(4.6-7.7)^2+(13.2-7.7)^2+(8.4-7.7)^2+(7.7-7.7)^2}{7}}=\sqrt{\frac{45.98}{7}}\) | (M1) | FT their mean for M1 |
| \(=2.56\) (minutes) | (A1) | Allow 2.6 SC1 for \(\sigma^2=6.57\) or \(s^2=7.66\) Accept calculation of \(s^2\) leading to an answer of 2.768 for M1A1 |
Corrected by Westie's Workshop
- The board's mark scheme printed “\(\sqrt{\frac{\Sigma x^2}{n}-\frac{(\Sigma x)^2}{n}}\)”. Changed to “\(\sqrt{\frac{\Sigma x^2}{n}-\frac{(\Sigma x)^2}{n^2}}\)” because the mean squared is \(\bar{x}^2=\frac{(\Sigma x)^2}{n^2}\); with only \(n\) underneath the formula does not give the standard deviation.
Original: see the board's mark scheme PDF (link above).