June 2019 Unit 2 Q10
10. Two particles \(A\) and \(B\), of mass 3 kg and \(M\) kg respectively, are connected by a light inextensible string passing over a smooth fixed pulley. Initially, the particles are held at rest with the string just taut either side of the pulley.

The system is then released and the particles move with an acceleration of magnitude 4·2 ms–2.
(a) Calculate the possible values of the tension in the string and the corresponding values of \(M\). [7]
(b) Now suppose that the pulley is not smooth. Write down one assumption which you made in your solution to part (a) that is no longer valid. [1]

| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Apply N2L to particle \(A\) \(\pm T\mp3g=3(4{\cdot}2)\) | M1 A1 | Dimensionally correct equation, \(T\) opposing \(3g\) Either form, oe |
| Apply N2L to particle \(B\) \(\pm Mg\mp T=M(4{\cdot}2)\) | (M1) A1 | M1 available once for N2L to either particle (see above) Either form, oe |
| Adding \(\pm Mg\mp3g=4{\cdot}2(M+3)\) \(\pm Mg-4{\cdot}2M=3(4{\cdot}2)\pm3g\) \(5{\cdot}6M=42\) OR \(14M=16{\cdot}8\) | m1 | Eliminating \(T\) |
| \(M=7{\cdot}5\ \ (\text{kg})\) \(M=1{\cdot}2\ \ (\text{kg})\) | A1 | Either value, cao |
| \(T=3(\pm4{\cdot}2)+3g\) \(T=42\ \ (\text{N})\) OR \(T=16{\cdot}8\ \ (\text{N})\) | A1 A1 | Either value, cao Both corresponding pairs,cao \(7{\cdot}5\text{ kg},42\text{ N}\ \ \&\ \ 1{\cdot}2\text{ kg},16{\cdot}8\text{ N}\) |
| [7] |
Alternative solution
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Apply N2L to particle \(A\) \(\pm T\mp3g=3(4{\cdot}2)\) | M1 A1 | Dimensionally correct equation, \(T\) opposing \(3g\) Either form, oe |
| \(T=\begin{cases}3(4{\cdot}2)+3g\\-3(4{\cdot}2)+3g\end{cases}\) \(T=\begin{cases}42\\16{\cdot}8\end{cases}\ (\text{N})\) | A1 | Either value, cao |
| Apply N2L to particle \(B\) \(\pm Mg\mp T=M(4{\cdot}2)\) | (M1) A1 | M1 available once for N2L to either particle (see above) Either form, oe |
| \(9{\cdot}8M-4{\cdot}2M=42\) OR \(4{\cdot}2M+9.8M=16{\cdot}8\) \(5{\cdot}6M=42\) OR \(14M=16{\cdot}8\) | m1 | For substituting their \(T\) |
| \(M=\begin{cases}7{\cdot}5\\1{\cdot}2\end{cases}\ (\text{kg})\) | A1 A1 | Either value, cao Both corresponding pairs, cao \(7{\cdot}5\text{ kg},42\text{ N}\ \ \&\ \ 1{\cdot}2\text{ kg},16{\cdot}8\text{ N}\) |
| ([7]) |
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| No longer able to assume that tension is the same (throughout the string) OR No longer able to assume that tension is equal on both sides | B1 | |
| [1] | ||
| Total for Question 10 | 8 |