June 2023 Unit 4 Q2
2. A certain fungus occurs in a population of trees in two mutually exclusive types, \(X\) and \(Y\).
It is known that 4% of the trees have type \(X\) of the fungus and there is an unknown proportion, \(p\), of trees that have type \(Y\) of the fungus.
A tree surgeon has developed a test to help diagnose whether or not a tree has the fungus. Information collected during the research process is given in the table below.
| Given that the tree has | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Type \(X\) | Type \(Y\) | No fungus | |
| Probability of a positive test result | 0·95 | \(d\) | 0·02 |
| Probability of a negative test result | 0·05 | 1 – \(d\) | 0·98 |
The tree surgeon calculates that, for a randomly selected tree from the population,
- the probability of the tree testing positive for the fungus is 0·122,
- the probability of the tree not having the fungus, given that it tests positive, is \(\dfrac{87}{610}\).
Show that the value of \(p\) is 0·09 and find the value of \(d\). [7]
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| \((\mathrm{P}(+)=0.122)\) \(0.04\times 0.95+pd+(0.96-p)\times 0.02=0.122\) \((0.038+pd+0.0192-0.02p=0.122)\) \((pd-0.02p=0.0648)\) | M1A1 | May be seen later. M1 for attempt to form an equation in \(p\) and \(d\) OR in terms of \(d\) and \(0.09\) using \(\mathrm{P}(+)=0.122\) (at least two correct products) Must use 0.122 – sight of LHS alone earns M0 A1 for a fully correct equation in \(p\) and \(d\) OR \(d\) and 0.09, for example \(0.04\times 0.95+0.09d+0.87\times 0.02=0.122\) |
| \(\mathrm{P}(\text{no fungus}|+)=\frac{(0.96-p)\times 0.02}{0.122}=\frac{87}{610}\) | M1A1 | M1 for attempt at conditional probability: Numerator must be of the form \(f(p)\) or written as \(P(\text{no fungus}\cap +)\) to earn the M1 AND one of numerator or denominator must be correct along with equating to \(\frac{87}{610}\) to earn M1. OR sight of \(\frac{87}{610}\times 0.122\) or \(0.0174\) or \(\frac{87}{5000}\) earns M1. NOTE: \(\frac{87}{610}=\frac{k}{0.122}\) with \(k\neq 0.0174\) earns M0, for example \(\frac{87}{610}=\frac{0.02}{0.122}\) earns M0. A1 for fully correct equation including \(p\). |
| \(0.0192-0.02p=0.0174\) \(0.02p=0.0018\) \(p=0.09\) | A1 | *ag Convincing – at least one step between M1A1 and \(p=0.09\). |
| \(0.09d-0.02\times 0.09=0.0648\) | m1 | Dependent on first M1 only. FT their equation. Must use \(p=0.09\). NOTE: If candidates find \(p=0.09\) first, then proceed with the \(P(+)\) equation, they automatically earn this mark in conjunction with the first M1A1. |
| \(d=\ 0.74\) | A1 | CAO Use of \(p=0.09\) to find \(d=0.74\) without deriving \(p\) earns possible M1A1M0A0A0m1A1. |
| Total [7] |
Alternative to show \(p=0.09\)
| Scheme | Marks | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| \(P(+|\text{no fungus})=\dfrac{P(+\cap\text{no fungus}}{(\text{no fungus})}\) \(0.02=\dfrac{0.0174}{P(\text{no fungus})}\) | (M1) | |
| \(P(\text{no fungus})=\frac{0.0174}{0.02}=0.87\) | (A1) | |
| \(P(\text{has fungus})=1-0.87=0.13\) \(p=0.13-0.04=0.09\) | (A1) |