May 2022 Paper 2 Q8
8. A train tunnel has a circular cross-section with a horizontal floor.

A diagram of the cross-section is shown below.

- The centre of the circle is O.
- Chord AB is 4 metres.
- The radius OA is 2.9 metres.
Calculate the height of the tunnel. [4]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | marshal facts and recognise right-angled triangle | ![]() |
| •2 | consistent Pythagoras statement | \(2.9^2-2^2\) |
| •3 | calculate third side | 2.1 |
| •4 | calculate height | 5 (m) |
| (4) |
Notes:
- Correct answer without working award 0/4
- In the absence of a diagram, accept \(2.9^2-2^2\) as evidence for the awards of •1 and •2
- BEWARE where a diagram of a right-angled triangle is shown, working must be consistent with the diagram. •2 is not available for an incorrect diagram leading to \(2.9^2-2^2\)
- •2 is available for a valid trig. method leading to the length of the third side
(a) award •2 for eg \(x=\cos^{-1}\left(\dfrac{2}{2.9}\right)\to2\tan x\) or \(2.9\sin x\)
(b) do not award •2 for eg \(\cos^{-1}\left(\dfrac{2}{2.9}\right)=46.3(9\ldots)\) - •4 is awarded for adding 2.9 to a value which has been calculated using Pythagoras’ theorem or trigonometry
- •1 and •2 are not available for:
(a) \(4^2-2.9^2\to2.75\ldots;\ \text{height}=5.65\ldots\) award 2/4 ✗✗✓1✓1
(b) \(4^2+2.9^2\to4.94\ldots;\ \text{height}=7.84\ldots\) award 2/4 ✗✗✓1✓1 - Where a candidate assumes an angle of \(45^\circ\) in the right-angled triangle, only •1 and •4 are available
- Disregard errors due to premature rounding provided there is evidence
Commonly Observed Responses:
1. \(2.9^2+2^2\to3.52\ldots;\ \text{height}=6.42\ldots\)
| (a) working inconsistent with correct diagram | award 3/4 ✓✗✓1✓1 |
| (b) working consistent with candidate’s diagram (cosine rule may be used to calculate third side) | award 3/4 ✗✓1✓1✓1 |
| (c) no diagram | award 2/4 ✗✗✓1✓1 |
