May 2026 Paper 1 Q11
11.
Give a reason for your answer. [2]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •1 | know to use \(x=-2\) in synthetic division | \(\begin{array}{r|rrrr}-2&1&7&18&16\\&&&&\\\hline&1&&&\end{array}\) |
| •2 | complete division, interpret result and state conclusion | \(\begin{array}{r|rrrr}-2&1&7&18&16\\&&-2&-10&-16\\\hline&1&5&8&0\end{array}\) Remainder \(=0\therefore(x+2)\) is a factor |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •1 | know to substitute \(x=-2\) | \((-2)^3+7(-2)^2+18(-2)+16\) |
| •2 | complete evaluation, interpret result and state conclusion | \(=0\therefore(x+2)\) is a factor |
| (2) |
Notes:
- Communication at •2 must be consistent with working at that stage i.e. candidate’s working must arrive legitimately at 0 before •2 can be awarded.
- The conclusion for (a)(i) must be stated in (a)(i).
- Accept any of the following for •2:
- ‘\(f(-2)=0\) so \((x+2)\) is a factor’
- ‘since remainder = 0, it is a factor’
- the ‘0’ from any method linked to the word ‘factor’ by ‘so’, ‘hence’, \(\therefore\), \(\rightarrow\), \(\Rightarrow\) etc
- Do not accept any of the following for •2:
- double underlining the ‘0’ or boxing the ‘0’ without comment
- ‘\(x=-2\) is a factor’, ‘… is a root’
- the word ‘factor’ only, with no link
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate A - grid method
| •1 ✓ | ||||||||||||
with no remainder | |||||||||||||
| \(\therefore(x+2)\) is a factor | •2 ✓ |
Candidate B - grid method
| •1 ✓ | ||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||
| \(\therefore(x+2)(x^2+5x+8)=x^3+7x^2+18x+16\) | |||||||||||||
| \(\therefore(x+2)\) is a factor | •2 ✓ |
Corrected by Westie's Workshop
- The board's marking instructions printed “\(x^3+7x+18x+16\)”. Changed to “\(x^3+7x^2+18x+16\)” because \((x+2)(x^2+5x+8)\) expands to \(x^3+7x^2+18x+16\) (the grid gives \(5x^2+2x^2=7x^2\)), so the second term needs a square.
Original: see the board's marking instructions PDF (link above).
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •3 | use discriminant | \(5^2-4(1)(8)\) |
| •4 | evaluate discriminant and give valid reason | \(-7\lt0\), \(\Rightarrow x^2+5x+8\) does not factorise (so \((x+2)\) is the only linear factor) |
| (2) |
Notes:
- Evidence for •3 may appear in the quadratic formula.
- Accept \(b^2-4ac=-7\) for •3.
- Do not penalise candidates who replace “\(x^2+5x+8\)” with “the quadratic factor”.
- At •4 accept interpretations such as “no real roots”, “no (further) factors” and “cannot factorise (further)” with comparison with 0.
- Where the quadratic factor used in •3 can be factorised, •4 is not available.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate C - no reference to discriminant
| \(-7\lt0\) | •3 ^ |
| \(\Rightarrow\) the quadratic factor does not factorise | •4 ^ |
| \(\Rightarrow(x+2)\) is the only linear factor |
Candidate D - minimal reference to discriminant
| \(-7\lt0\) | •3 ^ |
| discriminant < 0 | |
| \(\Rightarrow\) the quadratic factor does not factorise | •4 ✓ |
| \(\Rightarrow(x+2)\) is the only linear factor |
Candidate E - no evaluation of discriminant
| \(b^2-4ac\lt0\) | •3 ^ •4 ^ |
| \(\Rightarrow\) the quadratic factor does not factorise | |
| \(\Rightarrow(x+2)\) is the only linear factor |
Candidate F - no evaluation of discriminant
| Product = 8 and Sum = 5 No integer pair have this product and sum so the quadratic factor does not factorise | •3 ^ •4 ^ |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •5 | equate curves | \(2x^3+20x^2+27x+9=6x^2-9x-23\) |
| •6 | rearrange and link to (a) | \(2x^3+14x^2+36x+32=0\) leading to \(2(x^3+7x^2+18x+16)=0\) |
| •7 | find \(x\)-coordinate | \(x=-2\) |
| •8 | find \(y\)-coordinate | \(y=19\) |
| (4) |
Notes:
- At •6 do not penalise candidates who have divided the cubic equation by 2.
- ‘\(=0\)’ must appear in at least one of the equations at the •6 stage.
- •7 may not be awarded for working in part (a).
- Where an error has occurred at the •5 or •6 stage, •7 and •8 are still available for finding all the solutions (the discriminant need not be used for •8 to be awarded on follow-through).
- Where candidates “factorise” an irreducible quadratic or use another invalid strategy, •7 and •8 are not available.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate G - not explicitly using part (a)
| \(2x^3+20x^2+27x+9=6x^2-9x-23\) | •5 ✓ |
| \(2x^3+14x^2+36x+32=0\) | |
| \(\begin{array}{r|rrrr}-2&2&14&36&32\\&&-4&-20&-32\\\hline&2&10&16&0\end{array}\) | |
| \((x+2)(2x^2+10x+16)=0\) | •6 ✓ |
| \(2(x+2)(x^2+5x+8)=0\) | |
| \(x=-2\) | •7 ✓ |
| \(y=19\) | •8 ✓ |
[Annotation in the marking instructions: callout on \(2(x+2)(x^2+5x+8)=0\): “To gain •7, \(x^2+5x+8\) must also be stated in (a) or the discriminant used. Also accept \(x=-2\) or \(x+2=0\), AND \(x^2+5x+8=0\) for •6 (or without \(=0\) if previously included)”]
Candidate H - not using part (a)
| \(2x^3+20x^2+27x+9=6x^2-9x-23\) | •5 ✓ |
| \(2x^3+14x^2+36x+32=0\) | |
| \(\begin{array}{r|rrrr}-2&2&14&36&32\\&&-4&-20&-32\\\hline&2&10&16&0\end{array}\) | |
| \((x+2)(2x^2+10x+16)\) | •6 ✓ |
| \(x=-2\) and \(10^2-4(2)(16)=-28\lt0\) so \(x=-2\) is the only root | •7 ✓ |
| \(y=19\) | •8 ✓ |
[Annotation in the marking instructions: a dashed bracket joins the lines from \(2x^3+14x^2+36x+32=0\) to \((x+2)(2x^2+10x+16)\), with the callout “Also accept \(x=-2\) or \(x+2=0\), AND \(2x^2+10x+16=0\) for •6 (or without \(=0\) if previously included)”]
Candidate I - no evidence of link to part (a)
| \(2x^3+20x^2+27x+9=6x^2-9x-23\) | •5 ✓ |
| \(2x^3+14x^2+36x+32=0\) | •6 ^ •7 ^ |
| \(x=-2\) | |
| \(y=19\) | •8 ✓1 |
Candidate J - subtracting equations
| \(0=(2x^3+20x^2+27x+9)-(6x^2-9x-23)\) | •5 ✓ |
| \(0=2x^3+14x^2+36x+32\) | |
| \(0=2(x^3+7x^2+18x+16)\) | •6 ✓ |
| However… | |
| \(y=(2x^3+20x^2+27x+9)-(6x^2-9x-23)\) | •5 ✗ |
| \(0=2(x^3+7x^2+18x+16)\) | •6 ✓1 |