May 2025 Paper 1 Q8
8. Given that \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\), \(a>0\), find the value of \(a\). [3]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •1 | rearrange and apply \(\log_a x-\log_a y=\log_a\dfrac{x}{y}\) | \(\log_a\dfrac{75}{3}=2\) |
| •2 | write in exponential form | \(\dfrac{75}{3}=a^2\) stated or implied by •3 |
| •3 | find \(a\) | \(5\) |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •1 | write 2 as \(2\log_a a\) and apply \(n\log_a x=\log_a x^n\) | \(\log_a 75=\log_a a^2+\log_a 3\) |
| •2 | apply \(\log_a x+\log_a y=\log_a xy\) | \(\log_a 75=\log_a 3a^2\) |
| •3 | find \(a\) | \(5\) |
| (3) |
Notes:
- Where candidates state expressions such as \(\sqrt{25}=a^2\) or \(a=25^2\), •3 is not available.
- Each line of working must be equivalent to the line above within a valid strategy.
- Where candidates state \(a=-5\) without discarding that ‘solution’, •3 is not available.
- Do not penalise candidates who score out ‘log’ from equations of the form \(\log_a x=\log_a y\). See Candidate H.
- For the correct answer without working, award 0/3.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate A - invalid strategy
| \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\) | |
| \(75=a^2+3\) | •1 ✗ •2 ✗ •3 ✗ |
| \(a=\sqrt{72}\) |
Candidate B - invalid strategy
| \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\) | |
| \(\log_a 75=\log_a 3^2\) | •1 ✗ •2 ✗ •3 ✗ |
Candidate C - valid strategy incorrectly applied
| \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\) | |
| \(\log_a(225)=2\) | •1 ✗ |
| \(225=a^2\) | •2 ✓1 |
| \(a=15\) | •3 ✓1 |
Candidate D - valid strategy incorrectly applied
| \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\) | |
| \(\log_a\left(\dfrac{75}{3}\right)=2\) | •1 ✓ |
| \(\log_a 15=2\) | |
| \(15=a^2\) | •2 ✗ |
| \(a=\sqrt{15}\) | •3 ✓1 |
Candidate E
| \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\) | |
| \(\log_a\left(\dfrac{75}{3}\right)-2\) | •1 ^ •2 ^ •3 ^ |
Candidate F - BEWARE
| \(\log_a 25=2\) | •1 ✓ |
| \(\log_a\sqrt{25}\) | •2 ✗ •3 ✗ |
| \(\log_a 5\) | |
| \(a=5\) | SEEN |
Candidate G
| \(\log_a 75=2+\log_a 3\) | |
| \(\dfrac{\log_a 75}{\log_a 3}=2\) | •1 ✗ •2 ✗ •3 ✗ |
| \(25=a^2\) | |
| \(a=5\) |
Candidate H - scoring out
| \(\cancel{\log_a}25=\cancel{\log_a}a^2\) | |
| \(a=5\) | •3 ✓ |
| However | |
| \(\dfrac{\cancel{\log_a}25}{\cancel{\log_a}}=\dfrac{\cancel{\log_a}a^2}{\cancel{\log_a}}\) | |
| \(a=5\) | •3 ✗ |