May 2024 Paper 1 Q11
11.
(a) Express \(\cos x^\circ+\sqrt{3}\sin x^\circ\) in the form \(k\cos(x-a)^\circ\), where \(k\gt0\) and \(0\lt a\lt360\). [4]
(b) Hence, or otherwise, sketch the graph with equation \(y=\cos x^\circ+\sqrt{3}\sin x^\circ\), \(0\leqslant x\leqslant360\).
Use the diagram provided in your answer booklet (shown below). [3]
Use the diagram provided in your answer booklet (shown below). [3]

| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | use compound angle formula | \(k\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+k\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) stated explicitly |
| •2 | compare coefficients | \(k\cos a^\circ=1,\ k\sin a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) stated explicitly |
| •3 | process for \(k\) | \(k=2\) |
| •4 | process for \(a\) and express in required form | \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) |
| (4) |
Notes:
- Accept \(k\left(\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\right)\) for •1. Treat \(k\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) as bad form only if the equations at the •2 stage both contain \(k\).
- Do not penalise the omission of degree signs.
- \(2\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+2\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) or \(2\left(\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\right)\) is acceptable for •1 and •3.
- •2 is not available for \(k\cos x^\circ=1,\ k\sin x^\circ=\sqrt{3}\), however •4 may still be gained- see Candidate E
- •3 is only available for a single value of \(k,\ k\gt0\).
- •3 is not available to candidates who work with \(\sqrt{4}\) throughout parts (a) and (b) without explicitly simplifying at any stage. •4 is still available.
- •4 is not available for a value of \(a\) given in radians.
- Candidates may use any form of the wave function for •1, •2 and •3. However, •4 is only available if the wave is interpreted in the form \(k\cos(x-a)^\circ\).
- Evidence for •4 may not appear until part (b).
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate A
| •1 ^ | |
| \(2\cos a^\circ=1\) \(2\sin a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) | •2 ✓ •3 ✓ |
| \(\tan a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) \(a=60\) | |
| \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) | •4 ✓ |
Candidate B - inconsistency
| \(k\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+k\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) | •1 ✓ |
| \(\cos a^\circ=1\) \(\sin a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) | •2 ✗ |
| \(\tan a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) \(a=60\) | |
| \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) | •3 ✓ •4 ✗ |
Candidate C
| \(\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) | •1 ✗ |
| \(\cos a^\circ=1\) \(\sin a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) | •2 ✓2 |
| \(k=2\) | •3 ✓ |
| \(\tan a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) \(a=60\) | |
| \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) | •4 ✗ |
Candidate D - errors at •2
| \(k\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+k\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) | •1 ✓ |
| \(k\cos a^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) \(k\sin a^\circ=1\) | •2 ✗ |
| \(\tan a^\circ=\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\) \(a=30\) | |
| \(2\cos(x-30)^\circ\) | •3 ✓ •4 ✓1 |
Candidate E - use of \(x\) at •2
| \(k\cos x^\circ\cos a^\circ+k\sin x^\circ\sin a^\circ\) | •1 ✓ |
| \(k\cos x^\circ=1\) \(k\sin x^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) | •2 ✗ |
| \(\tan x^\circ=\sqrt{3}\) \(x=60\) | |
| \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) | •3 ✓ •4 ✓1 |
Candidate F
| \(k\sin\mathrm{A}\cos\mathrm{B}+k\cos\mathrm{A}\sin\mathrm{B}\) | •1 ✗ |
| \(k\cos\mathrm{A}=1\) \(k\sin\mathrm{A}=\sqrt{3}\) | •2 ✗ |
| \(\tan\mathrm{A}=\sqrt{3}\) | |
| \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) | •3 ✓ •4 ✓1 |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •5 | exactly two roots identifiable from graph | \((150,0)\) and \((330,0)\) |
| •6 | coordinates of exactly two turning points identifiable from graph | \((60,2)\) and \((240,-2)\) |
| •7 | \(y\)-intercept and value of \(y\) at \(x=360\) identifiable from graph | 1
|
| (3) |
Notes:
- •5, •6 and •7 are only available for attempting to draw a “cosine” graph with a period of \(360^\circ\).
- Ignore any part of a graph drawn outwith \(0\leqslant x\leqslant360\).
- Vertical marking is not applicable to •5 and •6.
- Candidate’s sketch in (b) must be consistent with the equation obtained in (a), see also Candidates G and H.
- For any incorrect horizontal translation of the graph of the wave function arrived at in part (a) only •6 is available.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate G - incorrect translation
| (a) \(2\cos(x-60)^\circ\) - correct equation | |
| (b) Incorrect translation: Sketch of \(2\cos(x+60)^\circ\) only •6 is available |
Candidate H - incorrect equation
| (a) \(2\cos(x+60)^\circ\) - incorrect equation | |
| (b) Sketch of \(2\cos(x+60)^\circ\) all 3 marks available |

