May 2025 Paper 2 Q17
17. The volume, \(V\) cm3, of water in a tank is given by
\(V=\dfrac{1}{5}h^3\), where \(h\) cm is the depth of water in the tank.
Water is being piped into the tank at a rate of 6 cm3/second.
Water is leaking from the bottom of the tank at a rate of \(\dfrac{1}{10}\sqrt{h}\) cm3/second.
Calculate the rate of change of the depth of water when \(h=400\). [4]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •1 | state relationship between derivatives 1 | \(\dfrac{dh}{dt}=\dfrac{dh}{dV}\times\dfrac{dV}{dt}\) or equivalent |
| •2 | determine \(\dfrac{dV}{dh}\) 2 | \(\dfrac{dV}{dh}=\dfrac{3}{5}h^2\) |
| •3 | state expression for \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}\) 1,3,4 | \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}=6-\dfrac{1}{10}\sqrt{h}\) |
| •4 | calculate rate of change 1,5,6 | \(\dfrac{dh}{dt}=\dfrac{1}{24000}\) cm/sec |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •1 | begin to differentiate with respect to \(t\) 1 | \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}=\dfrac{3}{5}h^2\ldots\) |
| •2 | complete differentiation with respect to \(t\) 1 | \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}=\dfrac{3}{5}h^2\dfrac{dh}{dt}\) |
| •3 | state expression for \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}\) 1,3,4 | \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}=6-\dfrac{1}{10}\sqrt{h}\) |
| •4 | calculate rate of change 1,5,6 | \(\dfrac{dh}{dt}=\dfrac{1}{24000}\) cm/sec |
| Method 3 | Method 3 | |
| •1 | find \(\dfrac{dh}{dV}\) | \(\dfrac{dh}{dV}=\dfrac{5}{3}(5V)^{-\frac{2}{3}}\) stated or implied by •2 |
| •2 | differentiate with respect to \(t\) 1,2 | \(\dfrac{dh}{dt}=\dfrac{5}{3}(5V)^{-\frac{2}{3}}\dfrac{dV}{dt}\) |
| •3 | state expression for \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}\) 1,3,4 | \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}=6-\dfrac{1}{10}\sqrt{h}\) |
| •4 | calculate rate of change 1,5,6 | \(\dfrac{dh}{dt}=\dfrac{1}{24000}\) cm/sec |
| (4) |
Notes:
- Where a candidate uses a variable other than \(t\) (or \(T\)) for time, eg “sec” this must be explicitly defined. Otherwise, the mark where it is first used is not available.
- In Method 1, where a candidate equates \(\dfrac{dV}{dh}\) to \(V\), •2 is not available.
- Where a candidate equates \(\dfrac{dV}{dt}\) to \(V\), •3 is not available.
- Where a candidate has treated the increase and decrease separately, do not withhold •3 provided they subsequently combine them to produce the correct value.
- At •4, candidates must explicitly identify \(\dfrac{dh}{dt}\).
- Accept an answer (eg \(4.1\dot{6}\times10^{-5}\)) rounded or truncated to at least two significant figures.