Your progress
Ticks are kept only in this browser: clearing your browsing data or changing device loses them. · ·

October 2021 Paper 2 Q9

OCR MEICurrent spec5 marksIncludes samplingData Processing

9 Arun, Beth and Charlie are investigating whether there is any association between death rate per 1000 and physician density per 1000. They each collect a random sample of size 10.

Arun’s sample is shown in Fig. 9.1.

death rate per 1000physician density per 1000
Canberra7.23.62
Dhaka5.30.49
Brasilia6.82.23
Yaounde9.30.08
Zagreb12.53.08
Tehran5.41.16
Rome10.74.14
Tripoli3.82.09
Oslo7.94.51
Abuja9.70.35

Fig. 9.1

(a) Explain whether or not Arun collected his data from the pre-release material, or whether it is not possible to say. [1]

Beth and Charlie collected their samples from the pre-release material. Each of them drew a scatter diagram for their samples. The samples and scatter diagrams are shown in Figs. 9.2 and 9.3.

Beth’s sampledeath rate per 1000physician density per 1000
Sudan6.70.41
Cambodia7.40.17
Gabon6.20.36
Seychelles70.95
Mexico5.42.25
Kuwait2.32.58
Haiti7.50.23
Maldives41.04
Nauru5.91.24
Jordan3.42.34
Scatter diagram titled Beth’s sample: physician density per 1000 (0 to 3) against death rate per 1000 (0 to 8), showing the ten points of the table, with physician density generally decreasing as death rate increases

Fig. 9.2

Charlie’s sampledeath rate per 1000physician density per 1000
Vanuata40.17
Solomon Islands3.80.2
N. Mariana Islands4.90.36
Nauru5.91.24
United Kingdom9.42.81
Portugal10.63.34
North Macedonia9.62.87
Faroe Islands8.82.62
Bulgaria14.53.99
St. Kitts and Nevis7.22.52
Scatter diagram titled Charlie’s sample: physician density per 1000 (0 to 4) against death rate per 1000 (0 to 16), showing the ten points of the table, with physician density generally increasing as death rate increases

Fig. 9.3

Arun states that Charlie’s sample and Beth’s sample cannot both be random for the following reasons.

  • Both samples include Nauru – there should not be any common values.
  • Beth’s diagram suggests a negative association between death rate and physician density, whereas Charlie’s diagram suggests a positive association. If both samples are random the same relationship would be suggested.
(b)
  • Explain whether Arun’s reasons are valid.
  • State whether or not Arun is correct, or whether it is not possible to say. [3]

Kofi collects a sample of 10 African countries and 10 European countries. The scatter diagram for his results is shown in Fig. 9.4.

Scatter diagram titled African and European countries: physician density per 1000 (0 to 6) against death rate per 1000 (0 to 16); a group of ten points with physician density between 0 and about 0.4 and death rate between about 6.5 and 15, and a group of ten points with physician density between about 3.1 and 5.3 and death rate between about 9 and 14.5
Fig. 9.4
(c) On Fig. 9.4, use your knowledge of the pre-release material to identify the points representing the 10 European countries, justifying your choice. [1]