June 2019 Paper 1 Q4
4 Fig. 4 shows a uniform beam of mass 4 kg and length 2.4 m resting on two supports P and Q. P is at one end of the beam and Q is 0.3 m from the other end.
Determine whether a person of mass 50 kg can tip the beam by standing on it. [3]

| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| Let \(R_\mathrm{P}\) and \(R_\mathrm{Q}\) be the normal reactions upwards Assume the person stands on the end beyond Q and that the beam is in equilibrium Taking moments about Q: | M1 | 3.1b |
| \(50g \times 0.3 + R_P \times 2.1 = 4g \times 0.9\) | A1 | 1.1b |
| \(R_P = \dfrac{3.6g - 15g}{2.1}\ [= -53.2] < 0\) So the beam will tip. | A1 | 3.2a |
| [3] |
Notes
M1: Finding moment of a force about any point
If the weight of the person shown between P and Q allow M1 maximum.
A1: Correct equation from moments about Q
Could also be obtained from moments about P and resolving to evaluate \(R_P\)
A1: Conclusion must be clear from correct working (\(R_\mathrm{P}\) need not be evaluated but must be clear that it is negative)
Alternative solution
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| If the person stands \(x\) m beyond Q so that the beam is on the point of tipping \(R_\mathrm{P} = 0\) Taking moments about Q | M1 |
| \(4g \times 0.9 = 50gx\) giving \(x = 0.072\) | A1 |
| \(0.072 < 0.3\) so this is possible while standing on the beam | A1 |
M1: Finding moment of a force about any point
A1: Correct equation from moments about Q
A1: Conclusion must be clear from correct working and reference to 0.3 m
Second alternative solution
| Scheme | Marks |
|---|---|
| Largest clockwise moment of the weight of the person about Q is \(50g \times 0.3 = 15g\ [= 147]\) | M1 |
| Anticlockwise moment of the weight of the beam is \(4g \times 0.9 = 3.6g\ [= 35.28]\) | A1 |
| The moment of the person’s weight is larger so the beam will tip | A1 |
M1: Finding moment of a force about any point
A1: Both correct moments about Q required
A1: Conclusion must be clear from a comparison of moments of two forces
SC 2 (omitting \(g\))
\(0.9 \times 4 < 0.3 \times 50\)
\(3.6 < 15\)
So the beam will tip.