June 2018 Paper 3 Q17
17 Suzanne is a member of a sports club.
For each sport she competes in, she wins half of the matches.
Investigate, at the 10% level of significance, whether Suzanne’s new racket has made a difference to the probability of her winning a match. [7 marks]
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| States both hypotheses correctly for two-tailed test | B1 | AO2.5 |
| States model used PI | M1 | AO3.3 |
| Calculates \(P(X \leqslant 6)\) or \(P(X \leqslant 7)\) 0.828(1) or 0.945(3) | M1 | AO1.1a |
| Obtains the correct probability for \(P(X \geqslant 7)\) | A1 | AO1.1b |
| Evaluates Binomial model by comparing \(P(X \geqslant 7)\) with 0.05 | M1 | AO3.5a |
| Infers H0 accepted CSO | A1 | AO2.2b |
| Concludes correctly in context. (FT only available if previous M1 mark scored and B1 scored) | E1F | AO3.2a |
Typical solution
\(X\) = number of matches won
\(\mathrm{H_0}: p = 0.5\)
\(\mathrm{H_1}: p \neq 0.5\)
Under null hypothesis
\(X \sim \mathrm{B}(10, 0.5)\)
Accept \(\mathrm{H_0}\)
There is not sufficient evidence that Suzanne’s new racket has made a difference
Alternative
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| (ALTERNATIVE using critical region) States both hypotheses correctly for two-tailed test | B1 | AO2.5 |
| States model used PI | M1 | AO3.3 |
| Considers critical region | M1 | AO1.1a |
| Identifies critical region | A1 | AO1.1b |
| Evaluates Binomial model by comparing \(X = 7\) with critical values | M1 | AO3.5a |
| Infers H0 accepted CSO | A1 | AO2.2b |
| Correctly concludes in context. ‘Not sufficient evidence’ or equivalent required. | E1F | AO3.2a |
Typical solution
\(X\) = number of matches won
\(\mathrm{H_0}: p = 0.5\)
\(\mathrm{H_1}: p \neq 0.5\)
Under null hypothesis
\(X \sim \mathrm{B}(10, 0.5)\)
Critical region is
\(X \leqslant 1\) and \(X \geqslant 9\)
\(X = 7\) not in critical region
Accept \(\mathrm{H_0}\)
There is not sufficient evidence that Suzanne’s new racket has made a difference
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| States model used PI | M1 | AO3.3 |
| Expresses condition in terms of a cumulative probability statement PI by sight of \(P(Y \geqslant c) \lt 0.1\) | M1 | AO3.1b |
| Tests one appropriate value for \(y\) | R1 | AO3.2b |
| Obtains at least two correct cumulative probabilities | A1 | AO1.1b |
| Obtains the correct minimum number of matches CSO | A1 | AO3.2a |
| (12 marks) |
Typical solution
\[Y \sim \mathrm{B}(20, 0.5)\]Require \(P(Y \gt y) \lt 0.1\)
\[P\left(Y \geqslant 13\right) = 0.1316 \gt 0.1\]\[P\left(Y \geqslant 14\right) = 0.0577 \lt 0.1\]Minimum number of matches = 14
Notes
(corrected from the printed mark scheme: the typical solution prints \(P(Y \geqslant 14) = 0.0577 \gt 0.1\); it should be \(\lt 0.1\))