June 2020 Paper 2 Q7
7 \(a\) and \(b\) are two positive irrational numbers.
The sum of \(a\) and \(b\) is rational.
The product of \(a\) and \(b\) is rational.
Caroline is trying to prove \(\dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b}\) is rational.
Here is her proof:
| Step 1 | \(\dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b} = \dfrac{2}{a + b}\) |
| Step 2 | 2 is rational and \(a + b\) is non-zero and rational. |
| Step 3 | Therefore \(\dfrac{2}{a + b}\) is rational. |
| Step 4 | Hence \(\dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b}\) is rational. |
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| (i) Identifies the error lies in step 1 without contradiction. | E1 | 2.3 |
| (1) | ||
| (ii) Recalls correct addition Accept \(\dfrac{b}{ab} + \dfrac{a}{ab}\) | M1 | 1.1b |
| Completes rigorous argument to complete proof. Must state that \(ab\) is rational (and non-zero) and \(a + b\) is rational and conclude that \(\dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b}\) or \(\dfrac{a + b}{ab}\) is rational | R1 | 2.1 |
| (2) |
Typical solution
(i)
Mistake is \(\dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b} = \dfrac{2}{a + b}\)
(ii)
\[\frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{b} = \frac{a + b}{ab}\]\(a + b\) is rational and \(ab\) is rational and therefore \(\dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b}\) is rational.
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| States assumption to begin proof by contradiction may PI by \(\dfrac{a}{b} - x = \dfrac{c}{d}\) or \(x - \dfrac{a}{b} = \dfrac{c}{d}\) | M1 | 3.1a |
| Uses language and notation correctly to state initial assumptions: States their \(a, b, c\) and \(d\) are integers and \(x\) is irrational do not accept the irrational written as a fraction Condone missing \(b, d \neq 0\) | A1 | 2.5 |
| Demonstrates that \(x\) can be expressed as a rational number by obtaining \(x = \dfrac{ad - cb}{bd}\) OE | M1 | 1.1b |
| Completes rigorous argument to prove the required result, clearly explaining where the contradiction lies with ALL assumptions correct at the start (including \(b, d \neq 0\)) | R1 | 2.1 |
| (4) | ||
| (7 marks) |
Typical solution
Assume that the difference between a rational and an irrational number is rational.
\[\frac{a}{b} - x = \frac{c}{d}\]Where \(a, b, c\) and \(d\) are integers, \(b, d \neq 0\) and \(x\) is irrational
\[x = \frac{a}{b} - \frac{c}{d}\]\[= \frac{ad}{bd} - \frac{cb}{bd}\]\[= \frac{ad - cb}{bd}\]Hence \(x\) is rational. This is a contradiction hence the difference of any rational number and any irrational number is irrational.