JMC 2012 Q9
9. The diagram on the right shows the positions of four people (each marked ×) in an Art Gallery. In the middle of the room is a stone column. Ali can see none of the other three people. Bea can see only Caz. Caz can see Bea and Dan. Dan can see only Caz.
Who is at position \(P\)?
- A Ali
- B Bea
- C Caz
- D Dan
- E More information needed

Junior Mathematical Challenge 2012, Question 9. © UK Mathematics Trust. Original paper on ukmt.org.uk
Answer: C Caz
The person at position P can see exactly two of the other three people, so this person is Caz. The people he can see are at positions 1 and 2 and are Bea and Dan, each of whom can see exactly one person – Caz. This leaves Ali at position 3 – a position from which none of the three people can be seen, so all of the information given is consistent with Caz being at P.

Solution © UK Mathematics Trust, from the JMC 2012 solutions. Longer versions with investigations: Solutions and investigations (PDF).