JMC 2015 Q17
Knave of Clubs: “The Knave of Hearts is lying.”
Knave of Diamonds: “The Knave of Clubs is lying.”
Knave of Spades: “The Knave of Diamonds is lying.”
How many of the four Knaves were telling the truth?
- A 1
- B 2
- C 3
- D 4
- E more information needed
Junior Mathematical Challenge 2015, Question 17. © UK Mathematics Trust. Original paper on ukmt.org.uk
Answer: B 2
If the Knave of Hearts is telling the truth then the Knave of Clubs is lying, which means that the Knave of Diamonds is telling the truth, but the Knave of Spades is lying. Alternatively, if the Knave of Hearts is lying then the Knave of Clubs is telling the truth, which means that the Knave of Diamonds is lying, but the Knave of Spades is telling the truth. In both cases, we can determine that two of the Knaves are lying, although it is not possible to determine which two they are.
Solution © UK Mathematics Trust, from the JMC 2015 solutions. Longer versions with investigations: Solutions and investigations (PDF).