May 2023 Paper 1 Q14
14. Solve, algebraically, the inequation \(\dfrac{x+1}{3}-2>\dfrac{3x}{5}\). [3]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •1 | eliminate denominators | \(5(x+1)-30>9x\) or equivalent |
| •2 | rearrange into the form \(ax>b\) or \(b>ax\) | \(-4x>25\) or \(-25>4x\) |
| •3 | solve for \(x\) | \(x<-\dfrac{25}{4}\) or \(-\dfrac{25}{4}>x\) |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •1 | collect algebraic terms and express as a fraction in simplest form | \(\dfrac{5-4x}{15}>2\) or equivalent |
| •2 | rearrange into the form \(ax>b\) or \(b>ax\) | \(-4x>25\) or \(-25>4x\) |
| •3 | solve for \(x\) | \(x<-\dfrac{25}{4}\) or \(-\dfrac{25}{4}>x\) |
| Method 3 | Method 3 | |
| •1 | express left hand side as a fraction in simplest form | \(\dfrac{x-5}{3}>\dfrac{3x}{5}\) or equivalent |
| •2 | rearrange into the form \(ax>b\) or \(b>ax\) | \(-4x>25\) or \(-25>4x\) |
| •3 | solve for \(x\) | \(x<-\dfrac{25}{4}\) or \(-\dfrac{25}{4}>x\) |
| (3) |
Notes:
- Correct answer without working award 0/3
Treat repeated substitution as invalid working. - For the award of •3 accept eg \(x<-6\dfrac{1}{4}\), \(-6.25>x\), \(x<\dfrac{25}{-4}\)
- For the award of •3 the answer must be a non-integer value.
Do not award •3 for a decimal approximation of \(-\dfrac{25}{4}\), but do not penalise incorrect conversion to a mixed number or decimal approximation following an answer of \(-\dfrac{25}{4}\)
(a) \(5(x+1)-30>9x\to-4x>25\to x<-\dfrac{25}{4}\to x<-6.3\) award 3/3
(b) \(5(x+1)-30>9x\to-4x>25\to x<-6.3\) award 2/3 ✓✓✗ - (a) There must be evidence that the candidate has dealt with the negative coefficient of \(x\) on the LHS of the inequation by either:
(i) reversing the direction of the inequality sign at •3
eg \(5(x+1)-30>9x\to-4x>25\to x<-\dfrac{25}{4}\) award 3/3
OR
(ii) collecting the \(x\) term(s) on the RHS of the inequation at •2
eg \(5(x+1)-30>9x\to-25>4x\to-\dfrac{25}{4}>x\) award 3/3
(b) Where a candidate requires to do neither of the above, then •3 does not gain a mark
eg \(5(x+1)-30>9x\to4x>25\to x>\dfrac{25}{4}\) award 1/3 ✓✗✓2 - For subsequent incorrect working •3 is not available
eg \(-\dfrac{25}{4}>x\to x>-\dfrac{25}{4}\) award 2/3 ✓✓✗
Commonly Observed Responses:
- \(5(x+1)-2>9x\to-4x>-3\to x<\dfrac{3}{4}\) award 2/3 ✗✓1✓1
- (a) \(5(x+1)-30=9x\to-4x=25\to x=-\dfrac{25}{4}\to x<-\dfrac{25}{4}\) award 3/3
(b) \(5(x+1)-30=9x\to-4x=25\to x=-\dfrac{25}{4}\) award 2/3 ✓✓✗