May 2025 Paper 2 Q14
14. Circle C1 has equation \((x+5)^2+(y-6)^2=9\).
Circle C2 has equation \(x^2+y^2-14x+6y+54=0\).
Circles C1, C2 and C3 are touching as shown in the diagram.
The centre of circle C3 lies on the line joining the centres of C1 and C2.

| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | state coordinates of centre | (−5, 6) |
| •2 | state radius | 3 |
| (2) |
Notes:
- Accept \(x=-5,\ y=6\) for •1.
- Do not accept ‘\(a=\ldots,b=\ldots\)’ or ‘−5,6’ for •1.
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •3 | find coordinates of centre | (7, −3) |
| •4 | find radius | 2 |
| (2) |
Notes:
- Accept \(x=7,\ y=-3\) for •3.
- Do not accept ‘\(g=\ldots,\ f=\ldots\)’ or ‘7,−3’ for •3.
- Do not penalise candidates who treat negatives with a lack of rigour when calculating the radius. For example, accept \(\sqrt{7^2+3^2-54}=2\) or \(\sqrt{7^2+-3^2-54}=2\) or \(\sqrt{-7^2+3^2-54}=2\) for •4. However, do not accept \(\sqrt{7^2-3^2-54}=2\) for •4.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate A - repeated error within a question
| (a) −5,6 | •1 ✗ |
| (b) 7,−3 | •3 ✓1 |
Candidate B - two errors
| (a) 5,−6 | •1 ✗ |
| (b) 7,−3 | •3 ✗ |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •5 | find distance between centres of C1 and C2 | 15 |
| •6 | calculate radius of C3 | 8 |
| •7 | find centre of C3 and state equation of C3 | (−1, 3) stated explicitly and \((x+1)^2+(y-3)^2=64\) |
| (3) |
Notes:
- •5 may be awarded for \(\sqrt{(-5-7)^2+(6+3)^2}\) within a valid calculation for the radius of C3.
- •6 is only available where a valid approach to finding the distance between the centres of C1 and C2 has been used.
- Where candidates use a radius without valid supporting working, •7 is not available.
- Accept the centre of C3 written as a position vector.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Valid approaches for finding \(r\)
| \(r=\dfrac{15+3-2}{2}\ \therefore\ r=8\) | •6 ✓ |
| \(r=\dfrac{\sqrt{(7+5)^2+(6+3)^2}+3-2}{2}\ \therefore\ r=8\) | •5 ✓ •6 ✓ |
| \(r=3+3+\dfrac{(13-9)}{2}\ \therefore\ r=8\) | •6 ✓ |
| Let \(x=r_3-r_1\). Since \(r_3=13-x\), \(x=(13-x)-3\ \Rightarrow\ x=5\ \therefore\ r=8\) (may also use \(y+3=r_3-r_1\)) | •6 ✓ |
This list is not exhaustive
Invalid approaches and/or insufficient communication for finding \(r\)
| \(r=3+3+2\ \therefore\ r=8\) | •6 ^ |
| gap \(=2\ \therefore\ r=10-2\ \therefore\ r=8\) | •6 ^ |
| \(r=\dfrac{15}{3}+3\ \therefore\ r=8\) | •6 ^ |
| Distance = 15 \(\therefore\ r=8\) (with no supporting working) | •6 ^ |
This list is not exhaustive
Valid approaches for finding centre of C3
| Ratio \(=1:2\ \therefore\) C3\((-1,3)\) | |
| C3\(\left(-5+12\times\dfrac{1}{3},\,6-9\times\dfrac{1}{3}\right)\ \therefore\) C3\((-1,3)\) | |
| Ratio \(=15:10\) & stepping out \(\therefore\) C3\((-1,3)\) (may be drawn as similar triangles) | |
| Let \(x=r_3-r_1\). Since \(r_3=13-x\), \(x=(13-x)-3\ \Rightarrow\ x=5\) \(\Rightarrow\) Ratio \(=5:10\ \therefore\) C3\((-1,3)\) (may also use \(y+3=r_3-r_1\)) | |
| \(2\overrightarrow{\text{C}_1\text{C}_3}=\overrightarrow{\text{C}_3\text{C}_2}\ \therefore\ \text{C}_3=\begin{pmatrix}-1\\3\end{pmatrix}\) |
This list is not exhaustive
Invalid approaches and/or insufficient communication for finding centre of C3
| \(m_{\text{C}_1\text{C}_2}=-\dfrac{3}{4}\ \therefore\ \text{C}_1(-5,6)\to\text{C}_3(-1,3)\) | •7 ✗ |
| \(\dfrac{y-6}{x+5}=\dfrac{-3-y}{7-x}=-\dfrac{3}{4}\ \therefore\ \text{C}_3(-1,3)\) | •7 ✗ |
| \(\{3,4,5\}\) triangle with no evidence of a ratio \(\therefore\) C3\((-1,3)\) | •7 ✗ |
This list is not exhaustive