May 2022 Paper 2 Q8
8. A rectangular plot consists of a rectangular pond surrounded by a path.
The length and breadth of the plot are \(x\) metres and \(y\) metres respectively.
The path is 1.5 metres wide at the ends of the pond and 1 metre wide along the other sides as shown.

The total area of the pond and path together is 150 square metres.
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | determine expression for area of pond | \((x-3)(y-2)\) stated or implied by •3 |
| •2 | obtain expression for \(y\) | \(y=\dfrac{150}{x}\) |
| •3 | demonstrate result | \(A(x)=(x-3)\left(\dfrac{150}{x}-2\right)\) eg \(A(x)=\dfrac{150x}{x}-\dfrac{450}{x}-2x+6\) \(A(x)=156-2x-\dfrac{450}{x}\) |
| (3) |
Notes:
- Accept any legitimate variations for the area of the pond in •1, eg \(A=150-2(x-3)-2(y)(1.5)\).
- Do not penalise the omission of brackets at •1. See Candidate A.
- The substitution for \(y\) at •3 must be clearly shown for •3 to be available.
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate A
| \(A(x)=x-3\times y-2\) | •1 ✓ |
| \(A(x)=x-3\times\dfrac{150}{x}-2\) | •2 ✓ |
| \(A(x)=156-2x-\dfrac{450}{x}\) | •3 ^ |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •4 | express \(A\) in differentiable form | \(156-2x-450x^{-1}\) stated or implied by •5 |
| •5 | differentiate | \(-2+450x^{-2}\) |
| •6 | equate expression for derivative to 0 | \(-2+450x^{-2}=0\) |
| •7 | solve for \(x\) | \(x=15\) |
| •8 | verify nature of stationary point | table of signs for derivative \(\therefore\) maximum or \(A^{\prime\prime}(x)=-900x^{-3}\) and \(A^{\prime\prime}(15)\lt 0\) \(\therefore\) maximum |
| •9 | determine maximum area | \(A=96\left(\text{m}^2\right)\) |
| (6) |
Notes:
- For a numerical approach award 0/6.
- •6 can be awarded for \(450x^{-2}=2\).
- For candidates who integrate any term at the •5 stage, only •6 is available on follow through for setting their ‘derivative’ to 0.
- •7, •8, and •9 are only available for working with a derivative which contains an index \(\leqslant -2\).
- \(\sqrt{\dfrac{450}{2}}\) must be simplified at •7 or •8 for •7 to be awarded.
- Ignore the appearance of \(-15\) at mark •7.
- •8 is not available to candidates who consider a value of \(x\leqslant 0\) in the neighbourhood of 15.
- •9 is still available in cases where a candidate’s table of signs does not lead legitimately to a maximum at •8.
- •8 and •9 are not available to candidates who state that the maximum exists at a negative value of \(x\).
Notes (continued)
For the table of signs for a derivative, accept:

For the table of signs for a derivative, do not accept:

- For this question do not penalise the omission of ‘\(x\)’ or the word ‘shape’/‘slope’.
- Stating values of \(A^{\prime}(x)\) is an acceptable alternative to writing ‘\(+\)’ or ‘\(-\)’ signs.
- Acceptable variations of \(A^{\prime}(x)\) are: \(A^{\prime}\), \(a^{\prime}(x)\), \(\dfrac{dA}{dx}\), and \(-2+450x^{-2}\).
Commonly Observed Responses:
Candidate B - differentiating over multiple lines
| •4 ^ | |
| \(A^{\prime}(x)=-2-450x^{-1}\) | |
| \(A^{\prime}(x)=-2+450x^{-2}\) | •5 ✗ |
| \(-2+450x^{-2}=0\) | •6 ✓1 |
Candidate C - differentiating over multiple lines
| \(A(x)=156-2x-450x^{-1}\) | •4 ✓ |
| \(A^{\prime}(x)=-2-450x^{-1}\) | |
| \(A^{\prime}(x)=-2+450x^{-2}\) | •5 ✗ |
| \(-2+450x^{-2}=0\) | •6 ✓1 |