June 2019 Paper 2 Q10
10 The level, in grams per millilitre, of a pollutant at different locations in a certain river is denoted by the random variable \(X\), where \(X\) has the distribution \(\mathrm{N}(\mu, 0.0000409)\).
In the past the value of \(\mu\) has been 0.0340.
This year the mean level of the pollutant at 50 randomly chosen locations was found to be 0.0325 grams per millilitre.
Test, at the 5% significance level, whether the mean level of pollutant has changed. [7]
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| See the exemplars at the end of the MS (below) Allow 2 sf throughout \(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \neq 0.034\) where \(\mu\) = (pop) mean pollutant level Allow any letter (except \(X\) and \(\overline{X}\): B0B0) | B1 B1 | 1.1 2.5 |
| \(\mathrm{N}\left(0.034, \dfrac{0.0000409}{50}\right)\) & \(\overline{X} \lt 0.0325\) (condone \(\gt\), =) or \(\dfrac{a - 0.034}{0.00640 \div \sqrt{50}} = -1.96\) | M1 | 3.3 |
| \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \lt 0.0325) = 0.0486\) or CV is 0.0322 or acceptance region is 0.0322 to 0.0358 or \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \gt 0.0325) = 0.951\) | A1* | 3.4 |
| \(0.0486 \gt 0.025\) or \(0.0325 \gt 0.0322\) or 0.0325 is in AR or \(0.951 \lt 0.975\) A1A1 | A1 | 1.1 |
| Do not reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\) Or Insufficient (or No) evidence to reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\) Allow Accept \(\mathrm{H}_0\) | M1 | 1.1 |
| Insufficient (or No) evidence that (mean) pollutant level has changed oe or eg "It is unlikely that level has changed" "We can assume that level hasn't changed" | A1f | 2.2b |
| [7] |
Notes
B1 B1: Subtract B1 for each error eg:
1-tail B1B0
undefined \(\mu\) B1B0
not in terms of parameter B1B0
\(\mu\) = sample mean implied B1B0
Not include value 0.034 B0B0
eg \(\mathrm{H}_0 = 0.034\) etc: B0B0
M1: Stated or implied eg by 0.0486 or 0.951 or 0.0322 (corrected from the printed mark scheme: 0.322) even if within incorrect statement eg \(\mathrm{P}(X = 0.0325) = 0.0486\)
A1*: BC
or \(\dfrac{0.0325 - 0.034}{0.00640 \div \sqrt{50}} = -1.66\)
A1: or \(1.66 \lt 1.96\) or \(-1.66 \gt -1.96\)
dep A1* Must be seen, allow on diag
M1: Dep 0.0486 or 0.0322 or \(-1.66\) or \(0.951 \lt 0.975\) seen, or \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \lt 0.0325)\) stated or implied (possibly with wrong prob leading to opposite conclusion**)
but 0 if .951 > 0.025 M0
May be implied by conclusion
Condone Reject \(\mathrm{H}_1\)
A1f: In context. Context may be implied by eg "level" or "pollutant"
ft only ** above
Not "There is evidence that mean level has not changed" A0
Not definite, eg "Mean level has not changed" A0
If 1-tail test:
\(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\), defined \(\mu\), B1
\(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \lt 0.034\) B0
As LH column M1
\(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \lt 0.0325) = 0.0486\) or CV is 0.0325(1) A1
Comp 0.05 or \(\pm 1.645\) A1
or \(0.0325 \lt 0.0325(1)\)
or 0.0325 is within CR
No more marks
Exemplars for Q10
Hypotheses
| Response | Mark | |
|---|---|---|
| A | \(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \neq 0.034\) where \(\mu\) = (pop) mean pollutant level | B1B1 |
| B | \(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \neq 0.034\) | B1B0 |
| C | \(\mathrm{H}_0\): The (pop) mean pollutant level is 0.034 \(\mathrm{H}_1\): The (pop) mean pollutant level is not 0.034 See Specimen paper q10 MS "Must be in terms of parameter values" | B1B0 |
| D | \(\mathrm{H}_0 = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_0 \neq 0.034\) | B0B0 |
| E | \(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu = 0.0325\) where \(\mu\) = (pop) mean pollutant level | B1B0 |
Probability and conclusion
| Response | Mark | |
|---|---|---|
| F | No statement of distribution \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} = 0.0325) = 0.0486\) \(0.0486 \gt 0.025\) Don't reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\) Likely that mean level of pollutant hasn't changed | M1A1 A1 M1 A1 |
| G | \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} = 0.0325) = 0.0486\) \(0.0486 \gt 0.025\) Accept \(\mathrm{H}_0\) There is evidence that mean level of poll'nt hasn't changed | M1A1 A1 M1 A0 |
| H | \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \lt 0.0325) = 0.951\) \(0.951 \gt 0.025\) Insufficient evidence that poll't level has changed | M1A0 A0 M0A0 |
| I | \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \gt 0.0325) = 0.951\) \(0.951 \gt 0.025\) Sufficient evidence that mean poll't level has changed | M1A1 A0 M0A0 |
| J | \(\overline{X} \sim \mathrm{N}(0.034, 0.000000818)\) \(\mathrm{P}(\overline{X} \lt 0.0325) = 0.013\) \(0.013 \lt 0.025\) Sufficient evidence that level has changed | M1A0 A0 M1A1 |
| K | \(\mu \pm 1.96\sigma = 0.0322\) to 0.0358 0.0325 lies within this range Reject \(\mathrm{H}_1\) Insufficient evidence that level of poll't has decreased | BOD M1A1 A1 M1 A0 |
| L | CV = 0.0322 \(0.0325 \gt 0.0322\) Reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\). Evidence that level of poll't has changed. | M1A1 A1 M0A0 |
| M | \((0.0325 - 0.034) \div \sqrt{0.0000409/50} = -1.66\) \(1.66 \lt 1.96\) Don't reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\). Level of poll't hasn't changed. | M1A1 A1 M1A0 |
(Exemplar M corrected from the printed mark scheme: it prints \((0.0322 - 0.034)\), but the value \(-1.66\) comes from the sample mean 0.0325.)
1-tail
| Response | Mark | |
|---|---|---|
| N | \(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \lt 0.034\) where \(\mu\) = (pop) mean pollutant level | B1B0 |
| O | \(\mathrm{H}_0: \mu = 0.034\) \(\mathrm{H}_1: \mu \lt 0.034\) | B0B0 |
| P | \(\mathrm{H}_0\): The (pop) mean pollutant level is 0.034 \(\mathrm{H}_1\): The (pop) mean pollutant level is less than 0.034 | B0B0 |