June 2024 Paper 1 Q13
13 Some students at a large school are doing a survey about attitudes to school uniform. They want to give a questionnaire to a random sample of 50 students at their school.
The school has three entrances. Gabi suggests giving the questionnaire to the first 50 students who arrive at a particular entrance on a randomly chosen morning.
The students are also doing a survey about attitudes to school lunches. Jane claims that 30% of students think the lunches are satisfactory. Dev claims that the true percentage is less than 30%. The students decide to test Jane’s claim by taking a random sample of 50 students and noting the number who think the lunches satisfactory.
Out of the 50 students in the sample, 9 said that they thought the lunches are satisfactory.
Explain whether you agree with this statement. [1]
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| Arrivals at other gates may not be included | B1 | 1.1 |
| Arrivals at other days/times may not be included | B1 | 1.1 |
| [2] |
Notes
(must give two distinct points and refer specifically to the sampling method i.e. entrance, time or ‘first 50’)
Examples:
- “It doesn’t include the entire population” B0
- “Not everyone has an equal chance of being chosen” B0
- “the sample size is probably too small” B0
- “they are only sampling from one entrance” B1
- “they are only asking from a pool of people who arrive early” B1
- “students using a particular entrance are going to have similar results” B1 BOD
- “Most students might not pick that entrance” B1 BOD
- “More students might come in on a different morning” B1 BOD
- “a particular year group might prefer coming through a specific gate” B1 BOD
- “the first 50 students will be those who arrive earliest and may not be representative” B1
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| \(\mathrm{H}_0: p = 0.3\) where \(p =\) proportion of students (at college) who think lunches satisfactory | B1 | 1.1 |
| \(\mathrm{H}_1: p \lt 0.3\) | B1 | 2.5 |
| \(\mathrm{B}(50, 0.3)\) & \(X = 9\) Allow \(X = 8\) or 10 | M1 | 3.3 |
| \(\mathrm{P}(X \leqslant 9) = 0.04023\ldots\) | A1 | 3.4 |
| \(0.040\ldots \lt 0.05\) | A1FT | 1.1 |
| Reject \(\mathrm{H}_0\) | M1 | 1.1 |
| Sufficient evidence that proportion who think lunches satisfactory is \(\lt 0.3\) | A1 | 2.2b |
| [7] |
Notes
Allow 2 sf throughout
B1B1: Allow "where \(p\) is the population proportion"
Allow “like” for “think lunches satisfactory”
Subtract B1 for each error e.g.:
- 2-tail B1B0
- undefined \(p\) or ‘probability’ B1B0
- use of \(X\),\(x\) and not defined B0B0
- not in terms of parameter B1B0
- \(p\) = sample proportion implied B1B0
- Not include value 0.3 B0B0
- e.g. \(\mathrm{H}_0 = 0.3\) etc: B0B0
M1: Correct distribution and value of \(X\), both may be stated or implied e.g. by 0.0183 \((X \leqslant 8)\) or 0.0220 \((X = 9)\) even if within incorrect statement e.g. \(\mathrm{P}(X = 9) = 0.040\).
A1: BC allow 2 sf (0.040)
A1FT: Correct for their value of 0.0402, FT their hypotheses (e.g. \(\gt 0.95\)) and condone 5% for 0.05.
M1: dep \(\mathrm{P}(X \leqslant 9\) or 8 or 10) stated or calculated.
Condone “Accept \(\mathrm{H}_1\)” but not “Do not reject \(\mathrm{H}_1\)”
Correct conclusion from their comparison.
A1: In context, not definite, e.g. not "Proportion who think lunches satisfactory is \(\lt 0.3\)" or “has decreased”
Accept “sufficient evidence to support Dev’s claim” but not just “Dev is correct”
www (not dependent on B1B1 and can gain this mark if 0.04 to 1sf only)
| Scheme | Marks | AO |
|---|---|---|
| Yes. Whether one sample member says lunch is satisfactory is not independent of other members. | B1 | 3.5b |
| [1] |
Notes
Accept Yes, P(success) not constant
Accept No, P(success) is nearly constant [because the school is large]
Examples:
- “each student may not be independent from one another” (not sample member and no mention of opinion) B0