SMC 2017 Q13
| 13. Isobel: “Josh is innocent” | Genotan: “Tegan is guilty” |
| Josh: “Genotan is guilty” | Tegan: “Isobel is innocent” |
Only the guilty person is lying; all the others are telling the truth. Who is guilty?
- A Isobel
- B Josh
- C Genotan
- D Tegan
- E More information required
Senior Mathematical Challenge 2017, Question 13. © UK Mathematics Trust. Original paper on ukmt.org.uk
Answer: C Genotan
Since only one person is lying this must be Genotan or Josh; their statements cannot both be true. If Josh were lying (and therefore guilty) then Genotan's statement would mean that Tegan was also guilty, a contradiction. Hence Genotan is lying and we can check that all four statements are consistent with this.
Solution © UK Mathematics Trust, from the SMC 2017 solutions. Longer versions with investigations: Solutions and investigations (PDF).