SMC 2012 Q9
9. Pierre said, “Just one of us is telling the truth”. Qadr said, “What Pierre says is not true”. Ratna said, “What Qadr says is not true”. Sven said, “What Ratna says is not true”. Tanya said, “What Sven says is not true”.
How many of them were telling the truth?
- A 0
- B 1
- C 2
- D 3
- E 4
Senior Mathematical Challenge 2012, Question 9. © UK Mathematics Trust. Original paper on ukmt.org.uk
Answer: C 2
If Pierre is telling the truth then Qadr is not telling the truth. However, this means that Ratna is telling the truth, so this leads to a contradiction as Pierre stated that just one person is telling the truth. So Pierre is not telling the truth, which means that Qadr is telling the truth, but Ratna is not telling the truth. This in turn means that Sven is telling the truth, but Tanya is not. So only Qadr and Sven are telling the truth.
Solution © UK Mathematics Trust, from the SMC 2012 solutions. Longer versions with investigations: Solutions and investigations (PDF).