SMC 2011 Q21
21. Each of the Four Musketeers made a statement about the four of them, as follows.
Athos: “Exactly two of us are lying.”
Porthos: “An odd number of us is lying.”
Aramis: “An even number of us is lying.”
How many of them were lying (with the others telling the truth)?
- A one
- B one or two
- C two or three
- D three
- E four
Senior Mathematical Challenge 2011, Question 21. © UK Mathematics Trust. Original paper on ukmt.org.uk
Answer: C two or three
At least one of d'Artagnan and Athos is lying. One of Porthos or Aramis is telling the truth and the other is lying. So the number of liars is either two (d'Artagnan and Porthos) or three (all except Porthos).
Solution © UK Mathematics Trust, from the SMC 2011 solutions. Longer versions with investigations: Solutions and investigations (PDF).