May 2025 Paper 2 Q4
4. The weights, in kilograms, of a sample of rugby players in Scotland are shown.
93 103 99 105 88 106 92
(a) Calculate the mean and standard deviation of these weights. [4]
A sample of rugby players in France has a mean weight of 105 kilograms and a standard deviation of 5.9 kilograms.
(b) Make two valid comments comparing the weights of the rugby players in the samples from Scotland and France. [2]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | ||
| •1 | calculate mean | 98 |
| •2 | calculate \(\left(x-\bar{x}\right)^2\) | 25, 25, 1, 49, 100, 64, 36 |
| •3 | substitute into formula | \(\sqrt{\dfrac{300}{6}}\) |
| •4 | calculate standard deviation | \(7.07(1\ldots)\) or 7.1 |
| Method 2 | ||
| •1 | calculate mean | 98 |
| •2 | calculate \(\sum x\) and \(\sum x^2\) | 686, 67528 |
| •3 | substitute into formula | \(\sqrt{\dfrac{67528-\dfrac{686^2}{7}}{6}}\) |
| •4 | calculate standard deviation | \(7.07(1\ldots)\) or 7.1 |
| (4) |
Notes:
- For 98 and \(7.07(1\ldots)\) without working. award 1/4 ✓^^✗
- (a) For 98 and \(\dfrac{\sqrt{300}}{6}=7.1\) award 4/4
(b) For 98 and \(\dfrac{\sqrt{300}}{6}=2.89\) award 3/4 ✓✓✗✓1 - For the award of •4 accept an answer in simplified surd form eg \(5\sqrt{2}\)
- If one \(x\) value is missing from list, do not award •2; however, •3 may be awarded for consistent substitution into standard deviation formula with:
(a) 5 in the denominator (from number of values on written list).
(b) 6 in the denominator (from wording of the question).
Commonly Observed Responses:
| 1. 98 and \(\dfrac{300}{6}=50\) | award 2/4 ✓✓✗✗ |
| 2. 98 and \(\sqrt{\dfrac{300}{98-1}}=1.75\ldots\) | award 3/4 ✓✓✗✓1 |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •5 | compare means | eg on average the weights of the rugby players in Scotland are lower. |
| •6 | compare standard deviations | eg the weights of the rugby players in Scotland are more varied. |
| (2) |
Notes:
- Answers must be consistent with answer to part (a).
- If standard deviation answer to part (a) is left in surd form, •6 can only be awarded if there is evidence that the comparison is based on two numbers in decimal format.
- Statements must involve reference to weights and Scotland or France:
(a) Accept eg- on average the weights of Scottish players were lower.
- on average the Scottish rugby team’s weights are lighter.
- on average the players in Scotland were lower.
- on average the results/scores/data were lower.
- the Scotland players’ results/scores/data were less consistent.
- on average the Scottish rugby team is lighter.
- For the award of •5
(a) Accept eg- the weights of the players in Scotland averaged less.
- the average weight was less for the Scottish players.
- the players in Scotland weighed less.
- on average the mean weights of the players in Scotland were less.
- the mean weight was lower for the players in Scotland.
- on average the weights of the players in France were better.
- For the award of •6
(a) Accept eg- the weights of the players in Scotland were less consistent.
- the weights of the players in Scotland were more spread out.
- the Scotland players were more spread out.
- the Scotland players were more varied.
- the standard deviation of the weights of the players in Scotland were less consistent.
- the range of the weights of the players in Scotland was more.
- Numbers are not required for •5 and •6 however, where they appear they must be consistent with the statement. For answers in parts (a) and (b) award as follows:
eg (i) (a) mean = 98 and sd = 7.07 award 4/4
(b) On average the weights of the rugby players in Scotland are lower as \(5.9\lt7.07\)
The weights of the rugby players in Scotland are more varied as \(98\lt105\) award 0/2
(ii) (a) mean = 98 and sd = 7.07 award 4/4
(b) On average the weights of the rugby players in Scotland are lower as \(98\gt105\)
The weights of the rugby players in Scotland are more varied as \(5.9\gt7.07\) award 0/2