May 2022 Paper 2 Q5
5. A school netball team recorded the number of sit-ups each player completed in a minute.
The numbers for the seven players were:
29 27 24 31 22 19 30
(a) Calculate the mean and standard deviation of the numbers of sit-ups. [4]
Some players in the school’s hockey team also recorded the number of sit-ups they completed in a minute.
Their numbers gave a mean of 29 and a standard deviation of 3.2.
(b) Make two valid comments comparing the numbers of sit-ups of the players in the netball team and the hockey team. [2]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | ||
| •1 | calculate mean | 26 |
| •2 | calculate \(\left(x-\bar{x}\right)^2\) | 9, 1, 4, 25, 16, 49, 16 |
| •3 | substitute into formula | \(\sqrt{\dfrac{120}{6}}\) |
| •4 | calculate standard deviation | \(4.47(2\ldots)\) or 4.5 |
| Method 2 | ||
| •1 | calculate mean | 26 |
| •2 | calculate \(\sum x\) and \(\sum x^2\) | 182, 4852 |
| •3 | substitute into formula | \(\sqrt{\dfrac{4852-\dfrac{182^2}{7}}{6}}\) |
| •4 | calculate standard deviation | \(4.47(2\ldots)\) or 4.5 |
| (4) |
Notes:
- For 26 and \(4.47(2\ldots)\) or 4.5 without working award 1/4 ✓^^✓2
- (a) For 26 and \(\dfrac{\sqrt{120}}{6}=4.47(2\ldots)\) or 4.5 award 4/4
(b) For 26 and \(\dfrac{\sqrt{120}}{6}=1.8(2\ldots)\) award 3/4 ✓✓✗✓1
- For the award of •4 accept an answer in simplified surd form eg \(2\sqrt{5}\)
- If one \(x\) value is missing from list, do not award •2; however •3 may be awarded for consistent substitution into standard deviation formula with:
(a) 5 in the denominator (from number of values on written list)
(b) 6 in the denominator (from wording of the question)
Commonly Observed Responses:
| 1. (a) 26 and \(\sqrt{\dfrac{120}{6}}=4.47(2\ldots)=4.4\) | award 4/4 |
| (b) 26 and \(\sqrt{\dfrac{120}{6}}=4.4\) | award 3/4 ✓✓✓✗ |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •5 | compare means | eg on average the hockey team recorded a higher number of sit-ups |
| •6 | compare standard deviations | eg the hockey team’s numbers of sit-ups were more consistent |
| (2) |
Notes:
- Answers must be consistent with answer to part (a)
- If standard deviation answer to part (a) is left in surd form, •6 can only be awarded if there is evidence that the comparison is based on two numbers in decimal format
- Statements must involve reference to number of sit-ups and include netball team and/or hockey team
(a) Accept eg- on average the hockey team did more sit-ups
- the hockey team’s sit-ups went up
- on average the hockey team’s results/scores/data were higher
- the hockey team’s results/scores/data were more consistent
- For the award of •5
(a) Accept eg- the hockey team’s average number of sit-ups was more
- the average amount of sit-ups was more for the hockey team
- the hockey team had more sit-ups
- the mean number of sit-ups was higher for the hockey team
- the average number of sit-ups was better for the hockey team
- For the award of •6
(a) Accept eg- the hockey team’s numbers of sit-ups were less varied
- the hockey team’s numbers of sit-ups were less spread out
- the hockey team’s sit-ups were less spread out
- the hockey team was less varied
- the hockey team’s standard deviation was more consistent
- the range of the hockey team’s numbers of sit-ups was less