May 2026 Paper 2 Q15
15. Let \(r\) be a positive real number and consider the following statement:
If \(r\) is irrational then \(\sqrt{r}\) is irrational.
(a) Write down the contrapositive of the statement. [1]
(b) Hence prove that the statement is true. [3]
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | write down contrapositive 1,2 | If \(\sqrt{r}\) is rational then \(r\) is rational |
| (1) |
Notes:
- Accept “not irrational” in place of “rational”.
- Accept equivalent variations, eg “\(r\) is rational if \(\sqrt{r}\) is rational” or “\(\sqrt{r}\) rational \(\Rightarrow r\) rational”.
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •2 | write down appropriate form for \(\sqrt{r}\) 1,2,7 | \(\sqrt{r}=\dfrac{p}{q}\), |
| •3 | state source set and obtain expression for \(r\) 3,4,7 | \(p,q\in\mathbb{Z}\ (q\neq0),\ r=\dfrac{p^2}{q^2}\) |
| •4 | communicate rationality and state conclusion 4,5,6,7 | which is rational; contrapositive is true and which implies original statement is true |
| (3) |
Notes:
- At •2, the expression must be consistent with the candidate’s response to (a). For example, if in (a), a candidate’s attempt at writing the contrapositive has an antecedent relating to \(r\), •2 is awarded where the candidate proceeds from consideration of the form of \(r\). See CORs C and D.
- At •2, do not accept a fraction which contains the letter \(r\), eg \(\sqrt{r}=\dfrac{r}{s}\).
- Where a candidate’s response uses contradiction, •2 and •3 are available but •4 is not.
- Do not withhold •3 for the omission of \(q\neq0\).
- Where a candidate produces a ‘contrapositive’ which contains ‘If \(r\) is rational’ or ‘If \(r\) is not rational’, •3 and •4 are not available.
- For the award of •4, the statement about rationality must relate to a fraction. It must also be consistent with the candidate’s response to (a). For example, if in (a), a candidate’s attempt at writing the contrapositive ends with a statement about \(r\), •4 is awarded where the candidate concludes that \(r\) is rational.
- For the award of •4, the conclusion must state that the contrapositive is true and also indicate that this implies the truth of the original statement, eg “so”, “\(\therefore\)” but not “and” or “,”.
- Where a candidate produces an incorrect statement between eg \(r=\dfrac{p^2}{q^2}\) and the conclusion, •4 is not available.
Commonly Observed Responses:
COR A
| If \(\sqrt{r}\) is rational then \(r\) is irrational. | |
| \(\sqrt{r}=\dfrac{p}{q}\) | Award •2. |
| \(p,q\in\mathbb{Z},\ r=\dfrac{p^2}{q^2}\) | Award •3. |
| Do not award •4. |
COR B
| If \(\sqrt{r}\) is irrational then \(r\) is irrational/rational. | |
| \(\sqrt{r}\neq\dfrac{p}{q}\) | Award •2. |
| Do not award •3 or •4. |
COR C
(following from “\(r\) is rational if \(\sqrt{r}\) is rational” – here, the antecedent is “\(\sqrt{r}\) is rational”)
Full marks are available
COR D
(following from “\(\sqrt{r}\) is rational if \(r\) is rational” – here, the antecedent is “\(r\) is rational”)
Only •2 is available, and the candidate must begin with “\(r=\)”