May 2024 Paper 2 Q15
15. A storage tank contains a mixture of salt and water. An additional amount of salt and water pours in while, at the same time, some of the existing mixture pours out.
The process can be modelled by the differential equation
\[\frac{dW}{dt}=\frac{36-W}{120},\ W<36\]where \(W\) is the amount of salt in kilograms at time \(t\) minutes.
Initially, the storage tank contains 8 kilograms of salt.
As the process continues, the amount of salt approaches a limit \(L\) kilograms.
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | separate variables and write down integral equation 1,2 | \(\displaystyle\int\frac{dW}{36-W}=\int\frac{dt}{120}\) |
| •2 | integrate LHS 1,3 | \(-\ln(36-W)\) |
| •3 | integrate RHS 1,4 | \(\dfrac{1}{120}t+c\) |
| •4 | find constant of integration 1,4,5,6 | \(c=-\ln28\) |
| •5 | express \(W\) in terms of \(t\) 1,4,5,7,8,9 | \(W=36-28e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}\) |
| (5) |
Notes:
- Where a candidate attempts to integrate an expression involving \(W\) with respect to \(t\), award 0/5
- •1 is not available if either \(\int dW\) or \(\int dt\) is omitted.
- For the award of •2, \(-\ln\ldots\) must be present. Accept \(-\ln|36-W|\).
- •3 may be awarded if constant of integration is omitted. However, •4 and •5 are unavailable if no constant of integration subsequently appears.
- If the constant of integration is not given as an exact value, award •4 only if the answer is correct to two significant figures (\(-3.3\)). However, do not award •5 if 28 does not appear in expression for \(W\).
- Where a candidate evaluates a constant after incorrectly rearranging, •4 is still available.
- For the award of •5, \(-\ln\ldots\) must be present at •2.
- Accept equivalent answers- eg \(W=36-\dfrac{28}{e^{\frac{1}{120}t}}\).
- Do not award •5 for \(W=36-e^{-\frac{1}{120}t+\ln28}\) or \(W=36-e^{\ln28}e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}\).
Commonly Observed Responses:
Using integrating factor:
| Integrating factor \(=e^{\frac{1}{120}t}\) | award •1 |
| \(e^{\frac{1}{120}t}W=\displaystyle\int\frac{36}{120}e^{\frac{1}{120}t}\) | award •2 |
| \(e^{\frac{1}{120}t}W=36e^{\frac{1}{120}t}+c\) | award •3 |
| \(c=-28\) | award •4 |
| \(W=36-28e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}\) | award •5 |
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Method 1 | Method 1 | |
| •6 | find \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) in terms of \(t\) | \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}=\dfrac{36-\left(36-28e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}\right)}{120}\) |
| •7 | evaluate \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) 1,2 | \(\dfrac{7}{30}e^{-\frac{67}{120}}\) (kilograms per minute) |
| Method 2 | Method 2 | |
| •6 | evaluate \(W\) at \(t=67\) and consider \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) | \(W=20\) and \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}=\ldots\) |
| •7 | evaluate \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) 1,2 | \(0.13\ldots\) (kilograms per minute) |
| Method 3 | Method 3 | |
| •6 | find \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) | \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}=\dfrac{28e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}}{120}\) |
| •7 | evaluate \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) 1,2 | \(\dfrac{7}{30}e^{-\frac{67}{120}}\) (kilograms per minute) |
| (2) |
Notes:
- At •7 accept any answer which rounds to \(0.13\) to two significant figures.
- At •7 units need not be given.
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •8 | state limit and give justification 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 | \(L=36\) AND \(e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}\to0\) as \(t\to\infty\) (or \(28e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}\to0\) as \(t\to\infty\)) |
| (1) |
Notes:
- There must be clear identification (eg “limit is 36”, “36 as…”, “… so 36”, “…therefore 36”) of the limit equalling 36 (or \(35.\dot{9}\) but not \(35.99\ldots\)).
- Where a candidate uses an expression which does not produce a limit, •8 is not available.
- Except as indicated in Note 4, do not accept \(W=36\).
- Where a candidate proceeds from the original differential equation, accept \(L=36\) along with either:
- a statement that \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}=0\) (or a statement that the rate of change would be 0) “when” \(W=36\) (There must be the explicit appearance of \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\), \(\dfrac{36-W}{120}\), or reference to derivative or rate of change. \(W=36\) may be implied by substitution into the original differential equation) or
- an explicit statement that \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\to0\) (or rate of change/derivative…) as \(W\to36\).
- Do not accept \(e^{-\frac{1}{120}\infty}\ldots\), or \(e^{-\frac{1}{120}t}=0\) as part of a justification.
- For consideration of an expression involving an exponential term, there must be reference (in words or symbols) to that term tending to zero as \(t\) increases.
- Disregard incorrect information which does not relate to candidate’s justification.
Commonly Observed Responses:
COR A
| 36 as \(\dfrac{36-36}{120}=0\), rate of change \(=0\ldots\) | award •8 |
COR B
| 36 as \(\dfrac{36-36}{120}=0\) | do not award •8 (no mention of derivative) |
COR C
| \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}=\dfrac{36-36}{120}=0\), therefore 36 | award •8 (justification followed by conclusion) |
COR D
| \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}=0\) as \(W\to36\) so \(L=36\) | do not award •8 (mixture of \(=,\to\) in same statement) |
COR E
| \(L=36\) as, after this, \(\dfrac{dW}{dt}\) is decreasing | do not award •8 |
COR F
| 36, as the rate of change would be 0 | do not award •8 (no association with \(W\)) |