May 2024 Paper 2 Q11
11. Consider statements A and B below.
For each statement: if true, provide a proof; if false, provide a counterexample. [3]
A: The sum of the squares of any two consecutive integers is always prime.
B: The sum of the squares of any two consecutive integers is always odd.
| Mark | Generic scheme | Illustrative scheme |
|---|---|---|
| •1 | A give counterexample1 and communicate 1,2,3 | eg \(3^2+4^2=25\) which is not prime |
| •2 | B state form of two consecutive integers 4,5,6 | eg \(k,\ k+1,\ k\in\mathbb{Z}\) |
| •3 | show \(k^2+(k+1)^2\) is odd and communicate 7,8 | \(2\left(k^2+k\right)+1\) which is odd |
| (3) |
Notes:
- Where the answer relating to statement A contains incorrect information (before, between or after correct information) •1 is not available.
- Alternative communication for “not prime” includes “\(25=5\times5\)” or “25 is divisible by 5” or “25 is composite.”
- Accept “A is false” for communication at •1.
- For •2, accept “\(k\) is an integer” or “let the integers be \(k\) …” but do not accept other source sets in words or symbols.
- Do not accept eg \(2k,\ 2k+1\) at •2, unless the candidate also considers \(2k-1,\ 2k\).
- Where a candidate starts by equating eg \(k^2+(k+1)^2\) to \(2m+1\), •2 is available only if \(m\) is not defined as an integer at this stage.
- For the award of •3, the candidate must deal with \(k,\ k+1\) or both pairs of \(2k,\ 2k+1\) and \(2k-1,\ 2k\).
- Accept “B is true” for communication at •3.